The Curious Case of Martin James Monti
Born in 1921, Martin James Monti was one of seven children of
hard working immigrant parents in St.
father was a prosperous investment broker originally from the Italian region of
and his mother was from Germany. Raised a Catholic, during the 1930s Monti
became an enthusiastic anti-communist, and avid fan of Father Charles Coughlin, the notorious
"Radio Priest" with an anti-Semitic, anti-communist, and pro-Fascist
agenda that was so rabid, in 1936 he was silenced by the Vatican at the request
of the American Catholic hierarchy, and with the cooperation of Cardinal
Eugenio Pacelli (later Pope Pius XII), themselves hardly leftists.
In August of 1942, Monti registered for the draft. Two months later, he traveled to Detroit to meet with his
idol, Father Coughlin. What transpired
at this meeting is unknown, but shortly
after meeting Coughlin, Monti attempted to enlist in the Navy, in which four of
his brothers would serve honorably, and then on November 29th
enlisted in the Army Air Forces as an aviation cadet. He reported for training early in 1943, and
in March of 1944 was commissioned as a "Flight Officer." He subsequently qualified in the P-39
Aircobra and the P-38 Lightning, and was promoted to second lieutenant. In August of 1944 Monti shipped out for India, where he
was attached to the 126th Replacement Depot,
(now in Pakistan),
awaiting assignment to a combat squadron.
On October 1st, wearing his uniform, Monti, by
then a first lieutenant, hitched a ride on an air transport bound for Cairo,
then talked himself aboard another plane to Tripoli, and thence yet another to
Naples, where he arrived on the 4th; security seems to have been amazingly lax.
Monti made his way to the complex of allied air bases neat, Foggia, east of Naples, where he arrived on the 10th. At Foggia
he visited the 82nd Fighter Group, in which some of his friends from
flight school were serving, and attempted to be assigned to a combat squadron. Lacking paperwork, he was turned down. He then made his way to Pomigliano d'Arco, north of Naples, where the 354th Air
Service Squadron prepared aircraft for assignment to line squadrons. On October 13th, passing himself
off as a pilot from the 82nd Fighter Group, Monti talked his way into
a "test flight" in a photographic reconnaissance version of the P-38,
taking off at about 1230. About two
hours later he landed at a small grass airstrip near Milan, and was shortly
taken into custody by German troops.
Although he claimed he wanted to serve the Reich, Monti was initially treated as an
ordinary prisoner-of-war, and assigned to a Luftstalag. Nevertheless, by mid-November, the
Germans decided that Monti was a real deserter (perhaps the arrest orders
broadcast by the U.S.
forces on October 14th helped tip them off).
Monti made several radio propaganda broadcasts
from Berlin, and also helped prepare literature for distribution to American
troops, using the name "Captain Martin Weithaupt," based on his
mother's maiden name, claiming to be an army officer who had deserted to the
Germans when he decided that the war was actually a Communist plot to enslave
the world, and that the U.S. should be allied with Germany and not Russia. Eventually, Monti joined the Waffen-SS as an Untersturmführer (a demotion, since the equivalent
rank was second lieutenant), assigned to the SS-Standarte Kurt Eggers. Initially
remaining in Berlin
performing propaganda duties, very late in the war Monti was ordered to report
to his unit, then in Northern Italy.
10, 1945, shortly after Germany surrendered, Monti turned
himself in to American forces in Italy, still wearing his SS uniform,
which he explained away by saying it had been given to him by partisans who
helped him escape. Amazingly, the Army
did not realize that Monti had deserted to the enemy. He was charged with being AWOL and
misappropriating government property (i.e.,
the P-38), which he claimed he had flown against the Germans, and to have been shot down! Monti was sentenced to 15 years at hard labor. On February 4, 1946 President Harry S Truman commuted Monti's
sentence to time served. Amazingly, a
week later Monti enlisted as a private in the Army Air Corps.
Soon after this, Monti's wartime activities began to attract
wider attention. Tipped off by an Army Criminal Investigation officer who had
handled Monti's case, in November of 1947 columnist Drew Pearson broke the
story in the Washington Post. This kick-started a
major investigation of Monti's activities.
Detained, on January
26, 1948, Monti, by then a sergeant, was discharged from the Air
Force at Mitchell Field, New York, and promptly arrested by the F.B.I.
Monti was evaluated by a team of psychologists. They found that he was of superior intelligence (an IQ of over 130), but was immature, and had obsessive-compulsive and paranoid tendencies, though legally he was not mentally ill. Certainly it doesn't take a psychiatrist to realize that Monti lacked good judgment; with the Americans and British at the West Wall and the Russians on the borders of East Prussia, October 1944 was hardly the time to defect to the Nazis.
Brought to trial on treason charges on January 17, 1949, Monti first entered a “not guilty” plea, but then immediately changed it to “guilty.” The following day he was sentenced to a $10,000 fine and 25 years imprisonment. Released in 1968, Monti died in 2000.
"And So Have I!"
In 1796, after the United States refused to join
Republican France in its war with Britain, the French began seizing
American ships. By 1798 the two nations
were in an unofficial state-of-war at sea, and Congress began issuing letters
of marque and reprisal to privateers and authorized the recently re-activated
United States Navy to take action.
On July 7,
1798, the 20-gun sloop-of-war Delaware (converted from a merchant ship in
about two months), came upon the French 12-gun privateer La Croyable off the southern coast of New Jersey.
The Delaware's skipper, Stephen Decatur, immediately
cleared for action, and the out-gunned privateer wisely struck his colors. As he came aboard the Delaware, the French captain asked, "Is the
at war with France."
"No, but your country is with mine," replied Decatur.
The Frenchman said, "Oh, but I have a commission for
what I do."
"And so have I," responded Decatur.