WARS UPDATE

THE MIDDLE EAST +

EUROPE +

SUB SAHARAN AFRICA +

ASIA +

THE AMERICAS +

INTERNATIONAL +


Visit StrategyPage's US Cavalry Store



Afghanistan Article Index : Current 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Why Who
 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics

The Civil War Line Up

November 6, 2009: The U.S. political leadership is reluctant to send the additional 40,000 troops the U.S. commander in Afghanistan wants. That would increase the U.S. force to 108,000 troops. In the past month, Taliban and al Qaeda violence has left about 300 dead. Most of the victims were killed in bombing attacks, or attacks done in cities to gain maximum medium exposure. These attacks were meant to inspire fear, and the UN, which lost seven dead when the Taliban attacked a UN guesthouse in Kabul, has moved over a thousand personnel to safer quarters or outside the country. The UN has 5,600 employees in Afghanistan, but only about 1,100 of them are foreigners.  

The Afghan Election Commission declared Hamid Karzai the winner of the presidential election, because his runoff opponent withdrew. Karzai promised to clean up the corruption. This is unlikely to happen. Taking, and paying, bribes is part of the Afghan culture. Only a minority of Afghans are even familiar with anything else, and few of them are willing to go against tradition while in Afghanistan. It's one thing to lose the bribery habit while living in the West, it's something else again to try and say no when back home. On the down side, all the bribes and shady dealings means that that you don't have the efficiency and productivity that emigrating Afghans so admire in the West. Thousands of Afghans have returned from the West, determined to make Afghanistan less corrupt and more prosperous. But they are a small minority. So far, they are not having much impact. The government of Afghanistan is deep into corrupt practices, and has no motivation to change. As for the foreigners; you just lie to them. A popular sport among government officials is coming up with new ways to deceive the foreigners about anti-corruption measures, while continuing to plunder all the foreign aid coming into the country. The Afghan government has no local income to speak of (in the 1990s, the Taliban got by via a heavy tax on the heroin trade), so the only money available for stealing comes from foreigners.

The Taliban are telling a lot of their operatives to stay inside Afghanistan over the Winter and try to organize attacks within southern cities, particularly Kandahar. The Taliban have plenty of cash to pay for Winter accommodations, and to bribe anyone they can't bully into cooperating. This is good times for the Taliban, as the drug gangs are paying them lots of money to keep the foreign troops occupied, and away from drug production and smuggling operations. Lots of jobs for adventurous, and unemployed, youth. Lots of bribes for ambitious and greedy military and government officials. The Pushtun tribes of the south know that all that drug money will buy them victory in the coming civil war with the rest of the Afghan tribes (60 percent of them are not Pushtun, and don't like the Pushtun very much.) The Pushtun feel they should run Afghanistan, and are split between those who are willing to do it with a Taliban/drug gang coalition (that operated, not very successfully, in the 1990s), or a coalition, including non-Pushtuns, subsidized by foreigners.

November 3, 2009: In Helmand province, an Afghan policeman walked into a British compound and killed five British soldiers, and wounded six others. The killer had been a policeman for three years, and it's not known if he was simply mad at the British for being recently being criticized by one of his advisors, or had been bribed by the Taliban. Both conditions occur frequently with the Afghan police.

November 2, 2009: The first of 2,244 special, all-terrain, MRAPs (Mine Resistant Ambush Protected) have arrived. The M-ATV (MRAP-All Terrain Vehicle) is a 15 ton, 4x4 (with independent wheel suspension) armored vehicle. Payload is 1.8 tons, and it can carry five passengers (including a gunner). Top speed is 105 kilometers an hour, and range on internal fuel is 515 kilometers. The M-ATV is slightly larger than a hummer. The reason for the M-ATV is that all other MRAPs are, after all, just heavy trucks. And the capsule design produces a high center of gravity, that makes the vehicles prone to flipping over easily. They are also large vehicles, causing maneuverability problems when going through narrow streets. Most MRAPs don't have a lot of torque, being somewhat underpowered for their size. And, being wheeled vehicles, they are not very good at cross country movement (especially considering the high center of gravity.) The M-ATV was designed to deal with all of these problems. Each M-ATV costs $446,000. They are flown to Afghanistan, which, with operating and maintenance costs for one year, triples their cost. In Iraq, troops in MRAPS had casualties 65 percent less than those in other armored vehicles. Because so many of the casualties in Afghanistan are from roadside bombs, vehicles like the M-ATV can cut that in half. But only for troops in vehicles. In Afghanistan, troops operate more frequently on foot.

November 1, 2009: Former foreign minister Abdullah Abdullah, the runner up in the recent presidential elections, has withdrawn from the runoff election. Abdullah believes that the runoff will have the same corrupt practices would take place in the runoff, as in the previous election.

submit to reddit
Send Link to a Friend
Next Article PEACEKEEPING: The Great Chopper Shortage

Make A Comment     View Comments (7)
Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Sort in Reverse Order Posted

Chris       11/6/2009 7:12:09 AM
After reading Gen McCrystals report (especially the background/history), what is clear is that 7 years of neglect was the primary cause of the Taliban resurgence.  As the man says (or wrote), instead of wiping them out when they were on the run, the government allowed itself to be distracted where the war wasn't, which allowed the Taliban to regroup, recruit, build alliances with other "organizations", find new sources of funding, and infest the country (not to mention Pakistan) wherever we weren't.
 
Result: severely compromising the chances of success of was already a very difficult original mission.
 
How sad...
 
Quote    Reply

AlMansour       11/6/2009 9:09:43 AM
There are many things wrong with the campaign in Afghanistan but it all boils down to the drug economy..
This is creating corrupt practices in government and taking out some of the poppy fields will only force up the price of heroin so that producing less will net the same money.
Maybe it's time to see our old friend agent orange make a return.
 
Quote    Reply

Mike From Brielle       11/6/2009 10:03:27 AM

After reading Gen McCrystals report (especially the background/history), what is clear is that 7 years of neglect was the primary cause of the Taliban resurgence.  As the man says (or wrote), instead of wiping them out when they were on the run, the government allowed itself to be distracted where the war wasn't, which allowed the Taliban to regroup, recruit, build alliances with other "organizations", find new sources of funding, and infest the country (not to mention Pakistan) wherever we weren't.

 

Result: severely compromising the chances of success of was already a very difficult original mission.

 

How sad...


While I think its true enough that to a degree the eye was taken off the ball but if the the eye had been on the ball how much good could it have been if the Pakistanis were not on board?  And they weren't on board really until just recently!
 
Quote    Reply

WarNerd       11/6/2009 7:53:46 PM

While I think its true enough that to a degree the eye was taken off the ball but if the eye had been on the ball how much good could it have been if the Pakistanis were not on board?  And they weren't on board really until just recently!

They may be on board, but not really. 
 
All Pakistan really wants is for the Taliban and al-Qaeda to restrict their military attacks to areas outside of Pakistan, preferably inside India, but Afghanistan will do as well.  That is why it was so was for them too make a deal to NOT to pursue fighters who fled their offensive in South Waziristan into North Waziristan.  They have also justified refusals to crack down Afghan Taliban bases in North Waziristan because of interference by India in Afghanistan (which is supplying humanitarian aid and support for nation building only, no troops).
 
Quote    Reply

Mike From Brielle    WarNerd    11/12/2009 11:27:00 AM
I'm sorry I don't quite understand.  Do you know about this bribe for a fact?  I have not read anything about it.  Why would the Taliban and Al Qeada fight for South Waziristan (as all reports seem to indicate that they are fighting very hard) if they know they only have to fall back to North Waziristan and be a guest for a short while of the Haqquani's (I believe) who would be foolish to refuse them because the next time the bell tolls it may be for the Haqquani's if there is no one else for the Pakistanis to fight?  I believe the Pakistanis now believe the created a Frakenstien in the Taliban which is an existential threat to their nation.
 
Quote    Reply

WarNerd       11/13/2009 7:00:23 AM

I'm sorry I don't quite understand.  Do you know about this bribe for a fact?  I have not read anything about it.

What bribe?  You must be referring to a different posting.

Why would the Taliban and Al Qeada fight for South Waziristan (as all reports seem to indicate that they are fighting very hard) if they know they only have to fall back to North Waziristan and be a guest for a short while of the Haqquani's (I believe) who would be foolish to refuse them because the next time the bell tolls it may be for the Haqquani's if there is no one else for the Pakistanis to fight?
 
Government estimates of the number of dead Taliban (which are almost certainly inflated by 200% to 1000%) account for less than 10% of the estimated hard core fighting strength.  These casualties are probably the slowest and the stupidest members of the Taliban.  The majority are either hiding locally, moved south of the conflict zone to hide with the rest of the local refuges, or fled to North Waziristan to wait out the Army offensive before returning to South Waziristan.
 
I believe the Pakistanis now believe the created a Frakenstien in the Taliban which is an existential threat to their nation.

Not really. 
 
Pakistan continues to see muslim fanatics as their best weapon against other countries, especially India.  They even divide the Taliban into 2 groups.  The 'good' Afghanistan Taliban are fighting India (and the US/NATO) in Afghanistan from North Waziristan areas controlled by the Haqqani Network and supported by the Pakistan government via the ISI.  The 'bad' Pakistan Taliban are trying to overthrow the existing government and replace it with a Pushtun/Wahabi theocracy, and operate from South Waziristan.  The 2 groups are actually closely allied with each other and similar government supported groups based on the eastern border with India that are responsible for most of the infiltration into India and most of the recent terrorist attacks, to the point of sharing personnel and training facilities. 
 
Pakistan is still deluding itself into thinking that it is possible to target and defeat the 'bad' Pakistan Taliban without effecting their relationship with the allied groups. 
 
Quote    Reply

Mike From Brielle       11/13/2009 3:32:14 PM
 "too make a deal to NOT to pursue fighters"  this bribe.  Also at once you seem to saying that the supposed two Taliban are not connected in the eyes of the Pakistanis and then you seem to indicate that the Pakistanis are cognecent of the fact that the Taliban are trying over through their governmnent;)?  
 
Quote    Reply





New Strategy - Wargames at Discount Prices
1.Modern Air Power: War Over the Middle East
2.Commander: Napoleon at War
3.Close Combat: Watch am Rhein
4.Gallic Wars
5.Fast Action Battle: The Bulge

100+ Computer and Board games all with free shipping.
 
 
 

StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2009StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy