WARS UPDATE

THE MIDDLE EAST +

EUROPE +

SUB SAHARAN AFRICA +

ASIA +

THE AMERICAS +

INTERNATIONAL +


Visit StrategyPage's US Cavalry Store



Afghanistan Article Index : Current 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Why Who
 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics

Do Or Die Time For The Taliban

June 12, 2009: The influx of American troops is showing up throughout southern Afghanistan. Areas that had long been dominated by the Taliban, or pro-Taliban tribes, are now being raided by American troops. U.S. intelligence forces arrived before the combat troops, and the increased reconnaissance and electronic monitoring effort produced a more detailed picture of who the Taliban were, where they lived and what they were up to. All that was needed was more troops to work the target list. The Taliban tactics appear to consist of avoiding foreign troops (except for greater use of roadside bombs), and trying to concentrate forces to drive Afghan police and government officials out of the countryside. This would have some chance of success were it not for the foreign troops.

The buzz in the villages and neighborhoods of southern in Afghanistan is all about the Taliban bombing a mosque in Pakistan, and the local Pushtun clans there forming militias (which are only done in the most dire emergency) and going after any Taliban fighters, or pro-Taliban tribesman, they can find. The new American commander (Stanley McChrystal) in Afghanistan, who has a Special Forces background, wants to take advantage of this by having foreign troops work more closely with local (to their bases) Afghans. General McChrystal has more Special Forces, along with lots more soldiers and marines. McChrystal is also keeping his staff of 400 troops in Afghanistan for three years at a time. This will provide more continuity, although at some cost to family life for the personnel involved. McChrystal is being given a lot of leeway to modify tactics and methods. It's understood that the Special Forces are used to operating this way, and getting away with it. McChrystal has been told to try the Special Forces techniques on a large and broad scale. The collapse of Taliban in support in Pakistan makes the Afghan Taliban vulnerable, and now is the time to take advantage of that.

The intensity of operations can be seen in the American combat casualties. This time last year, 40 U.S. troops had died so far that year. This year, American deaths are 70 so far (a 40 percent increase). Last year, 151 American troops died in Afghanistan. There are 58,000 U.S. troops in Afghanistan now (nearly 50 percent more than last year), with 68,000 planned by the end of the year. Thus U.S. casualties are up mainly because there are more American troops in action.

The Taliban are not keeping up. The Taliban are using more roadside bombs, a tactic that requires more cash than just gangs of gunmen intimidating villagers and killing cops. The bombs require better paid bomb builders and teams for placing and detonating the explosives. While the bombs are the most effective way to kill foreign troops, this still results in a lower casualty rate than was encountered in Iraq. There, the roadside bomb tactic ultimately failed. But the Taliban, knowing this, have no choice, because if they don't kill at least a few foreign troops, their credibility, and morale, will collapse. That is happening anyway, as the foreign troops now go after the sources of Taliban cash (smuggling, drugs, extortion). In Pakistan, the army is breaking all tradition and going after the pro-Taliban tribes. Since the founding of Pakistan (and for centuries before), soldiers stayed out of the tribal territories. No more, and the Taliban have lost their sanctuary, and much tribal support. It's do or die time for the Taliban. With so many things going against them, they have to show some progress this year, or find themselves in a downward spiral they won't recover from.

Al Qaeda is also having cash flow problems. Recent audio messages passed around to Moslems has al Qaeda leaders pleading for money. Al Qaeda admits that its operations in Afghanistan, and elsewhere, are hobbled by a lack of resources. There should be no surprise here, as counter-terror operations have concentrated, for years, on sources of terrorist financial assistance. Moslem charities, which actually raised money for terrorist operations, were shut down (especially in the Persian Gulf), and large contributors were convinced to halt their support. Al Qaeda also lost a lot of popular support because of their indiscriminate killings in Iraq, and now Afghanistan. It's no wonder they are broke.

In the last week, there were 400 terrorist related incidents in the country, an all time high. At its peak, there were several thousand a week in Iraq, so it's not the same in Afghanistan. The Taliban have far less reach than the Sunni Arab terrorists of Iraq. But the Taliban are using the same tactics as the Iraqi terrorists, and getting the same result.

June 5, 2009: In Kandahar, police located and killed two Taliban commanders. The Taliban are finding that they are increasingly vulnerable to informers. The Taliban use of intimidation and terror attacks has created many more enemies. That, and the growing availability of cell phones, has proved to be a disastrous combination. Gossip quickly reveals who key Taliban officials are, and if one of the locals has a grudge against the Taliban (because a friend or family member was injured or killed by them), and a cell phone, it takes less than a minute to tip off the police (who distribute "tip lines" for such information, and offer rewards). The Afghan police have SWAT and quick reaction teams, which proved very successful in Iraq, for following up on tips.

submit to reddit
Send Link to a Friend
Next Article ARMOR: Making MRAPs More Mobile

Make A Comment     View Comments (5)
Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Sort in Reverse Order Posted

Chris       6/12/2009 10:06:59 AM
It has been reported that the Taliban stay away from areas where there is cellular telephone service, as the locals will often call the Afghan Police (etc) to report Taliban locations, thereby having them removed.  Hence, the US/NATO/Afghanis need to speed up the creation of a cellular infrastructure country-wide.
 
That in addition to the new special-forces tactics being used (plus spreading the news from Pakistan, etc) should help speed the demise of both Al Queda and the Taliban.  Of course, then the government (etc) will have to get moving on the public works projects to demonstrate that life for Afghan citizens is tangibly improving.
 
 
 
Quote    Reply

cwDeici       6/12/2009 5:00:48 PM
Collapse?
 
Rapidly growing notoriety snowballing in localized militias and increased awareness in Punjab-Sindh hardly equals collapse. The Taliban is strongly supported in wide swaths of the FATA and Northwest and while their actions earns them hatred in the rest of the country, the massacres by the army certainly strengthens them within their home territory.
 
Quote    Reply

cwDeici       6/12/2009 5:08:22 PM
Also, it's hardly do or die time for the Taliban. They're seeing more heat than they have in recent years, but the Army isn't fully or even moderately committed yet. I don't know how Punjab-Sind Pakistanis feel about the current situation, but the best way to describe the crucial parts of government is 'mildly committed' and 'showing off for profit and vastly exagerrating the results'.
 
If the Pak casualty figures were true the Taliban would be reeling. They're feeling the hurt, but so is the army though they can take more of it than the AQT does. The Taliban aren't fighting for it, they're redeploying to terrorizing further inland while fighting partial holding actions and retreating from some areas while holding others.
 
Don't hold your breath until there's some sort of climactic battle in Swat with thousands of Paki soldiers dying.
 
There are tens of thousands of AQT and Pro-Talib Tribal soldiers with up to 10,000 on active duty and I estimate they've lost probably less than a thousand by now, as has the army.
 
Quote    Reply

Gerry       6/12/2009 8:52:48 PM

Also, it's hardly do or die time for the Taliban. They're seeing more heat than they have in recent years, but the Army isn't fully or even moderately committed yet. I don't know how Punjab-Sind Pakistanis feel about the current situation, but the best way to describe the crucial parts of government is 'mildly committed' and 'showing off for profit and vastly exagerrating the results'.

 

If the Pak casualty figures were true the Taliban would be reeling. They're feeling the hurt, but so is the army though they can take more of it than the AQT does. The Taliban aren't fighting for it, they're redeploying to terrorizing further inland while fighting partial holding actions and retreating from some areas while holding others.

 

Don't hold your breath until there's some sort of climactic battle in Swat with thousands of Paki soldiers dying.

 

There are tens of thousands of AQT and Pro-Talib Tribal soldiers with up to 10,000 on active duty and I estimate they've lost probably less than a thousand by now, as has the army.

 

Very true about the Pak army distorting casualty figures. However the Taliban have used this to their advantage and more often reported more accurate  figures. I don't see that happening this time around. The Taliban have been very closed mouth about their casualties lately, while the Pakistani army has been making significant progress.
 
It would appear many of the people are fed up with the Taliban and since the Pakistani army is finally doing what it said it would do 10 years ago they are going for the winning side and evicting the Taliban.



 
Quote    Reply

WarNerd       6/14/2009 4:45:09 AM

Don't hold your breath until there's some sort of climactic battle in Swat with thousands of Paki soldiers dying.


The will not be a climactic battle unless Islamabad falls.  The Taliban is following traditional guerrilla tactics -- dispersing, going into hiding, and falling back before a superior force to avoid a decisive battle that they would almost certainly lose.  They will reappear shortly.  Pakistan is winning ONLY if the following conditions are achieved and maintained:
The Pakistani Army can keep terrorism under control in the liberated cities.
 
The Pakistani government can negotiate a deal that will allow them to station military units in the tribal areas to provide direct support for the tribal militias.  This will be tough because the tribes do not trust the government (surprise, surprise).  The tribes insist that if the government just gives them money and weapons they can do the job, despite multiple demonstrations that they lack the strength to keep the Taliban and al-Qaeda from murdering their leaders and terrorize the rest into submission.
 
The Pakistani security apparatus reduce the level of terrorist activity in the rest of the country and keep it under control with no more large scale attacks.
 
The ISI is brought under civilian control and purged of the elements supporting the Taliban and al Qaeda.  Currently the terrorists seem to know more about what the army plans than the troops on the ground.
 
Quote    Reply





New Strategy - Wargames at Discount Prices
1.Modern Air Power: War Over the Middle East
2.Commander: Napoleon at War
3.Close Combat: Watch am Rhein
4.Gallic Wars
5.Fast Action Battle: The Bulge

100+ Computer and Board games all with free shipping.
 
 
 

StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2009StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy