Air Weapons: Carpet Bombing Died For Our Sins

Archives

November 18, 2011: In Afghanistan, the Taliban have been less active this year, with violent incidents by them down over 25 percent. Moreover, the Taliban are staying away from foreign troops. That's a matter of self- preservation. Once they engage foreign troops, they are usually doomed. That because if they stand and fight, the more skilled and better armed foreign soldiers quickly win the battle. If the Taliban try and flee, the foreign troops have airpower and Afghan troops on the ground, to effectively pursue. The foreign warplanes have smart bombs, which can hit fleeing troops wherever they are, even in an area full of civilians.

Smart bombs have led to far fewer bombs being dropped. This has led to many changes in the way wars are fought. Keep in mind that during the peak six years of the Vietnam War, 6.7 million tons of bombs were dropped. That was the same rate they were dropped during the major bombing campaigns of World War II. Most of those bombs were dropped in large quantities, all at once ("carpet bombing").

But in ten years of fighting in Afghanistan and Iraq, less than 45,000 tons have been dropped. Thus, while during World War II or the Vietnam War, a million tons were dropped a year, for the war on terror, less than 6,000 tons a year was dropped. That means a reduction of over 99 percent. Even when you adjust for the different number of U.S. troops involved, that's still over 97 percent fewer bombs dropped.

It's not only been fewer bombs and missiles, but smaller ones. While during Vietnam the average bomb size was close to 455 kg (1,000 pounds), now it's less than half that. Weapons like the 50 kg (108 pound) Hellfire missile are more popular with the ground troops, than the 910 kg (2,000 pound) bomb that was so often used in Vietnam.

Most of the bombing is now being done in Afghanistan. In Iraq, less than a ton of bombs a month were being dropped three years ago, and now U.S. troops will be gone in less than a month. In Afghanistan, about 100 tons a month are used. In Afghanistan, this tonnage has declined in the last year, as there were fewer encounters with the Taliban. Partly due to the greater use of smaller bombs and missiles and partly due to the greater use of civilians as human shields by the Taliban.

This human shield tactic is all part of a clever Taliban effort to exploit local and foreign media. By using civilians as human shields, and getting more Afghan civilians killed, thus forcing the foreigners to change their ROE (Rules of Engagement) to the point that the Taliban can avoid air strikes if they just grab some women and children. About a hundred civilians are killed each month in Afghanistan. Most are killed by the Taliban, but ten percent, and sometimes more, are killed by American smart bombs, missiles and shells. So far, the foreign air forces have managed to keep hitting Taliban targets without killing a lot of human shields. Partly this is due to Afghan civilians not cooperating with the Taliban.

The Afghan government can only condemn the Taliban use of terror (murder, kidnapping, arson and looting), but they are expected to do something about the civilian deaths caused by foreign troops. The government is forced, by media stories of the bombing deaths, to call for "fewer civilians deaths." When it's pointed out that this makes it more difficult to fight the Taliban, the Afghans suggest that foreign troops go in and kill the Taliban one by one. But this gets more U.S. and NATO troops killed, and even suggesting this is bad for troop morale. No one likes to discuss this openly, because U.S. and NATO commanders admit, at least off the record, that the lives of their troops are more valuable than those of Afghan civilians being used as human shields. Letting the Taliban get away, because of the use of human shields, is no solution either, because those Taliban will eventually kill more civilians and foreign troops. But the media outcry, often bought and paid for by the Taliban or drug lords, works its magic. The Taliban also use these fatalities to stir up those opposed to foreign troops even being in Afghanistan (an ancient and cherished tradition among many Pushtun tribes), and this results in newsworthy demonstrations and protests.

There are actually fewer civilian deaths in Afghanistan, compared to Iraq, because of terrorist attacks. Al Qaeda learned their lesson in Iraq, and is not as murderous against uncooperative Afghan tribal leaders as they were against Iraqi ones. This time around, the Taliban seek to either ally with, scare off, or buy off all the tribes in southern Afghanistan, and form a Pushtun coalition capable to defeating the tribes that comprise the other 60 percent of the Afghan population. At best, that will lead to another civil war. But this reality does not dissuade the Taliban leaders, who believe they are on a Mission From God. And those civilians who are killed while serving as human shields, are declared "involuntary martyrs." So far, though, Taliban theology has not been able to come up with anything to deal with the damn smart bombs.

 


Article Archive

Air Weapons: Current 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 1999 


X

ad
0
20

Help Keep Us Soaring

We need your help! Our subscription base has slowly been dwindling. We need your help in reversing that trend. We would like to add 20 new subscribers this month.

Each month we count on your subscriptions or contributions. You can support us in the following ways:

  1. Make sure you spread the word about us. Two ways to do that are to like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.
  2. Subscribe to our daily newsletter. We’ll send the news to your email box, and you don’t have to come to the site unless you want to read columns or see photos.
  3. You can contribute to the health of StrategyPage. A contribution is not a donation that you can deduct at tax time, but a form of crowdfunding. We store none of your information when you contribute..
Subscribe   Contribute   Close