by Austin Bay
June 7, 2011
2011's Arab Spring is an astonishing moment. Yes, somewhere
on the calendar of the next decade's history a fall of lowered expectations
will occur and a winter of cold disappointment -- but the hopes and passions
powering it will not disappear.
Michael Totten's new book, "The Road to Fatima
Gate" (Encounter Books, 2011), provides a first-person look at Arab
Spring's immediate predecessor, Lebanon's Beirut Spring of 2005. Totten then
moves to a detailed discussion of Hezbollah's increasing power within Lebanon,
followed by a compelling, on-the-ground look at the 2006 Hezbollah-Israeli war
(the July War, in Lebanese parlance). Totten portrays the war as an
Iranian-Israeli war, with Hezbollah as Tehran's proxy.
Totten's introduction to the Beirut Spring begins with the
murder of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri. A bomb destroyed his
Mercedes. The Hariri assassination remains current news, for a U.N.
investigation implicated Syrian intelligence agents as the culprits, with the
order to kill Hariri coming from the highest levels of the Assad dictatorship.
Complicity in Hariri's murder is another reason to regard anyone who claims
Bashar Assad is a reformist as being inexcusably ignorant or a paid
The murder was supposed to cow Lebanon. "It didn't
work," Totten observes. "Lebanon exploded in revolt the likes of
which the modern Middle East had never seen."
More terror bombs exploded. Totten "hopped a flight to
Beirut from Germany," as pro-democracy Lebanese demonstrators rose up
against Syria's occupation forces -- the soldiers and intelligence officers of
the same Assad regime that this spring is shooting its own citizens. The
pro-Syrian marches featured angry Hezbollah supporters carrying pictures of
Bashar Assad and wielding pistols and knives.
The Syrians withdrew, suffering a political defeat. But the
guns and loyal fighters of Lebanese factions replaced them, not peace and
certainly not unity. Iran, through Hezbollah, filled the power vacuum. Through
Hezbollah, Totten argues, Iran boosts Lebanese Shia Arab factions, in the same
way France and America support Lebanese Christians and Saudi Arabia supports
With factional tension increasing, Totten headed south, to
Hezbollah land, a "miniature one party state" that was
"mobilized" for external and internal war. Lebanese government
soldiers and police did not go there. Posters of the Ayatollah Khomeini, Iran's
current supreme cleric, Ayatollah Khamenei, and Lebanese Hezbollah's own Hassan
Nasrallah were ubiquitous.
Fatima Gate had been the major crossing point between Israel
and southern Lebanon prior to 2000, when the border closed. Totten found the
gate wrapped in cyclone fencing "two stories high." Arabs drove down
to the gate to "throw rocks at Israel."
Rocks are one thing, barrage rockets another. From late 2005
to the summer of 2006, rockets supplanted hurled rocks. Israeli towns were
subjected to random then increasingly fierce bombardments. Hassan Nasrallah
provided the polemics, but the puppeteers were in Tehran. Iran wanted to goad
Israel into fighting a dirty war on a battlefield of villages interlaced with
mines and bunkers. Southern Lebanon became the July War's battlefield.
Totten's chapter on the Siege of Ain Ebel documents
Hezbollah's intentional use of civilian homes and churches as fighting
positions. Hezbollah did not care. The more destruction, the better. Ain Ebel
is a Christian community.
Totten's road ends with a look at Iran's disputed election
of June 2009. Why Iran when his focus is Lebanon's chaos? Because Iran seeds
the chaos. Topple the ayatollahs' regime, and Lebanon's troubles will diminish.