Book Review: July, 1914: Countdown to War

Archives

by Sean McMeekin

New York: Basic Books, 2014. Pp. xviii, 465. Illus., maps, personae, chron., notes, biblio., index. $22.00 paper. ISBN: 0465060749

From Assassination to Global War

Despite the title, this book actually begins on June 28 with the assassination of the Archduke and his wife. Besides the horrendous tragedy familiar to us is that nobody liked the Archduke. He was the heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne but had married for love far beneath his station resulting in the ostracism of his wife and general disparagement of himself. For such a horrendous and far-reaching war to be based on his murder is incomprehensible-almost. His murder brought nationalistic hatred to the surface and provided the desired excuse for one nation, Austria, to wreak havoc on another, Serbia.

What followed the assassination was a convoluted interplay between the great and not-so-great powers of Europe, some seeking peace and others an opportunity to pursue their own goals. Diplomatic dispatches were worded in such a way to communicate the truth but not the whole truth, actions were taken covertly to gain an advantage over other nations, intelligence reports were incomplete, leaving recipients unaware of the seriousness of the situation and national intentions were misunderstood.

Even within the major powers, communication was less than forthright. Churchill ordered the fleet north to Scapa Flow without lights or bothering to inform Foreign Minister Grey. Russia began mobilizing without informing the Tsar. Chancellor Bethann did not keep the Kaiser informed, playing on Wilhelm’s limited attention span and frequent mood changes. Grey would speak to Parliament for ninety minutes and yet left out such details as why France should be supported, Belgium’s rejection of Germany’s ultimatum, and just what England would do about the situation. Grey uttered many words but did not communicate with Parliament or Germany that England was willing to fight.

Nations distracted by internal problems, behind the scenes maneuvering, information withheld or distorted or incompletely presented, leaders who did not comprehend or were ignored, and other irresponsible acts contributed to the collision. Yes, the troops came home before Christmas—of 1918—those who survived.

So who really started the war? The author absolves Germany of some but not all war guilt, and assigns more responsibility to Russia and Austria than previous historians, but draws no absolute conclusions. While he has unearthed, deciphered, and revealed more information than previously available, too many documents from various countries have been destroyed or remain unavailable to reach a rock solid conclusion. Yet, as I read the book, I saw no innocent parties. The amount of guilt varied but all were stained either by omission or commission. Serbia probably was behind the assassination plot. What McMeekin has not indicted is the war jubilation of the good citizens of several nations, particularly England, France, and Russia. Perhaps if those good citizens had understood who or how many would die horribly, their cheering would have been subdued.

Mentally tracking the moves and countermoves in this book is a serious challenge. Readers would have been better served if the author had provided a graphic time line as to events, presentation of diplomatic conclusions and who became aware and when. Read the book for new information, the serious challenge of keeping all the events and actors mentally organized and to understand how communications and travel were so much different and played a background role before the world turned inside out.

 

Our Reviewer: Ron Drees is an archivist, retired from processing the collection of Dr. Michael DeBakey, the world-famous cardiologist at the Baylor College of Medicine. His interest in history dates back to junior high school with an emphasis on American military history, particularly the Civil and World Wars. He has written several reviews for Michael Hanlon's blog "Roads to the Great War", about the catastrophe that still shapes the world. His favorite WWI book is Margaret MacMillan’s Paris, 1919 which tells how the tragedy was compounded by setting the stage for even greater misery. He lives in Houston with his wife of 42 years, Lin, a retired librarian, and their Sheltie, Hannah. He had a grandfather who was a teamster on the German side in WWI, his first boss had been a Marine at Iwo Jima, virtually the only survivor of his company, and his brother-in-law had been at Inchon. Ron’s previous reviews include Imperial Germany and War, 1871-1918, Beneath the Killing Fields: Exploring the Subterranean Landscapes of the Western Front, Tirpitz and the Imperial German Navy, Between Mutiny and Obedience: The Case of the French Fifth Infantry Division during World War, The Kaiser’s U-Boat Assault on America, This Time Next Year We'll Be Laughing, 1918: Winning the War, Losing the War, After the Ruins: Restoring the Countryside of Northern France After the Great War, A Mad Catastrophe, and Verdun: The Lost History of the Most Important Battle of World War I.

 

---///---

 

Note: July, 1914: Countdown to War is also available in audio- and e-editions.

 

StrategyPage reviews are published in cooperation with The New York Military Affairs Symposium

www.nymas.org

Reviewer: Ron Drees   


Buy it at Amazon.com