The Strategypage is a comprehensive summary of military news and affairs.
 News As History - December 1, 2008

Dunnigan's and Bay's Latest

Advertisement



New Strategy - Wargames at Discount Prices
1.Squad Battles: Winter War
2.Silent War
3.Manoeuvre
4.Gallic Wars
5.Fast Action Battle: The Bulge

100+ Computer and Board games all with free shipping.
 
 
 

Online Giving

Utah SEO Firm

Xango

Smiley Gifts for Babies

Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use
Surface Forces Discussion Board
Sign In   Return to Topic Page
Subject: LHD procurement plan
Ezekiel    12/2/2007 2:57:16 AM
1) what is considered generally to be the best LHD design?... I was under the impression it is the new canberra class that the aussies are buying two of.
2) what is the specific criteria in which one makes a judgement on a good or bad LHD, including bang for the buck considerations???
3) How many of thiese crafts would a country need for a force deployment 5000-7000 km away in multiple drop points???
4) what would be the projected overall naval budget for such a procurement plan envisioned in your LHD program???
 
Quote    Reply
 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics

Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Sort in Reverse Order Posted

verong       12/2/2007 9:56:58 PM
OK,
 
Lets Say your the USA.
 
conditions
war against North Korea and PRC over South Korea and Taiwan
objective
1. keep Taiwan  free
2. Stop Battle over South Korea
in this scenario very few would be needed
 
now condition was full scale invasion of PRC
just to begin with you would need to be able to put ashore 1,000,000 combat troops for a simple foothold thus your talking 30 CVBG ,40 ARG, just simply a hugh force just for a foothold your talking 1000 ships maybe more
 
Sincerely,
 
Keith
P.S. your talking USD of 5,000,000,000,000 plus to equip that force
 
Quote    Reply

Herald1234       12/2/2007 11:30:47 PM

1) what is considered generally to be the best LHD design?... I was under the impression it is the new canberra class that the aussies are buying two of.
2) what is the specific criteria in which one makes a judgement on a good or bad LHD, including bang for the buck considerations???
3) How many of thiese crafts would a country need for a force deployment 5000-7000 km away in multiple drop points???
4) what would be the projected overall naval budget for such a procurement plan envisioned in your LHD program???

1. That depends on what you want to accomplish. the bigger the job, the bigger the LHA and the more you need.
2. Same as 1.
3. Same as 1.
4  $1K per 100 tons.
 
Quote    Reply

WarNerd       12/3/2007 3:56:53 AM

4  $1K per 100 tons.

This is way low.  I think you mean $1M per 100 tons.
 
Quote    Reply

Herald1234       12/3/2007 10:44:21 AM



4  $1K per 100 tons.


This is way low.  I think you mean $1M per 100 tons.

50,000 tonne ship/100 tonnes.

500 tonnes x $1M= $500M US. Agreed-2 magnitude error. Must have been tired and suffered BF.

Herald 


 
Quote    Reply

Ezekiel       12/10/2007 9:54:57 AM
How much would it cost to procure 5 wasp class LHD's fully equipped and maintained???
 
What is the capabilities of such a force if projected 3000 km away from home??
 
Quote    Reply

verong       12/10/2007 7:44:48 PM
Hey Ezekiel,
 
about ten billion procure including helo and escorts but not training or O&M.  each!!!!!x 5 equals 50,000,000,000 USD
 
Sincerely,
 
Keith
 
Quote    Reply

B.Smitty       12/11/2007 8:14:22 AM
New Wasps would likely run $2-3 billion each, just for the ship.
 
Quote    Reply

TDidier       12/23/2007 4:42:57 PM

1) what is considered generally to be the best LHD design?... I was under the impression it is the new canberra class that the aussies are buying two of.
2) what is the specific criteria in which one makes a judgement on a good or bad LHD, including bang for the buck considerations???
3) How many of thiese crafts would a country need for a force deployment 5000-7000 km away in multiple drop points???
4) what would be the projected overall naval budget for such a procurement plan envisioned in your LHD program???


4 LHD of the Mistral size are enougth to carry all the vehicles and materials for a 5000 men strong Mecanized brigade (100 MBT, 200 APC, 50 155/120mm tubes and all the usual stuff).
 
For a short sail (1 week) somewhat the half of the men are able to be transported bye those four, the rest on the escort fleet. For a longer operation only 1800 onboard the rest on the escorters and supply ships.
 
What is this aussie thing? A spanish Buque de Projection?
 
Quote    Reply

TDidier       12/23/2007 5:07:31 PM

1) what is considered generally to be the best LHD design?... I was under the impression it is the new canberra class that the aussies are buying two of.
2) what is the specific criteria in which one makes a judgement on a good or bad LHD, including bang for the buck considerations???
3) How many of thiese crafts would a country need for a force deployment 5000-7000 km away in multiple drop points???
4) what would be the projected overall naval budget for such a procurement plan envisioned in your LHD program???


4 LHD of the Mistral size are enougth to carry all the vehicles and materials for a 5000 men strong Mecanized brigade (100 MBT, 200 APC, 50 155/120mm tubes and all the usual stuff).
 
For a short sail (1 week) somewhat the half of the men are able to be transported bye those four, the rest on the escort fleet. For a longer operation only 1800 onboard the rest on the escorters and supply ships.
 
What is this aussie thing? A spanish Buque de Projection?
 
Quote    Reply

Yimmy       12/23/2007 5:12:08 PM


4 LHD of the Mistral size are enougth to carry all the vehicles and materials for a 5000 men strong Mecanized brigade (100 MBT, 200 APC, 50 155/120mm tubes and all the usual stuff).

 

So each ship can carry 25 MBT's, 50 APC's and 12 SPG's in addition to 1,250 troops?

 
Quote    Reply

TDidier       12/24/2007 4:35:17 AM





4 LHD of the Mistral size are enougth to carry all the vehicles and materials for a 5000 men strong Mecanized brigade (100 MBT, 200 APC, 50 155/120mm tubes and all the usual stuff).



 



So each ship can carry 25 MBT's, 50 APC's and 12 SPG's in addition to 1,250 troops?


By MBT I was meaning a mix between AMX Leclerc (+50t) and AMX-10RC (+20t). In fact Mistral is said to be sized for 13 Leclercs and somewhat 200 vehicles, 2650m² of vehicle parking+ all what you can put in the 4 LCM if it is a short range assault.
For the men, it is designed for a comfortable 450 trooper for some months, but 600 is not a problem for a week (a lot of empty space: optionnal HQ command center or additionnal hospital).
As I said, only a part of those 5000 men have to be put in the 4 Mistrals, 2400 for a short range assault, 1800 "only" for a months long operation.
 
Quote    Reply

stingray1003       1/1/2008 7:26:12 AM
The Canberra class will be made up of atleast two spanish built hulls of BPE of 27,900 t.
 They can carry ~1,000 troops (978+ 182 additional), a crew ~250, vechicals, landing craft, they can operate a F-35B (questionable carrier capability - manufacturers claim up to 30 can be carried), helicopters, vechicals etc.
 
 Australia is likely to make a few more modifications. Accomodation will change, to a slightly lower standard but possibly allowing more personel. The ski jump may be removed, allowing a 7th helo spot. Certainly weapons, sensor, systems fitout will be unique to Australia
 
 *ttp://www.lhd.tenix.com/
 
 Bar the US wasp and its replacement, they are proberly the most capable LHD. For a nation like Australia two (or hopefully three) would make a huge leap in capability. Prices vary, manufacturer claims about $300-400 million euro, Australia has budgeted over a billion each.
 
Quote    Reply

Ezekiel       1/18/2008 9:17:07 AM
1.what would your LHD procurement policy be if you were to plan an aphibious landing on Egypt?

2. what would your LHD procurement policy be if you were to plan an aphibious landing on Iran?




 
Quote    Reply

Yimmy       1/18/2008 5:34:03 PM
Surely Australia will have even greater problems defending thise new LHD's in a high intensitve conflict than the Rn will have with our two new carriers.
 
Quote    Reply

StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2008StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy