Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Russia
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
If Hitler had invaded ONLY east - not west?
reefdiver
10/4/2006 4:38:10 PM
Much has been said that Hitler's foley and downfall was in opening an eastern and 2nd front against Russia, but what if he'd ONLY gone after Russia (well and Poland etc in the middle)? Could he have beaten them? Would western Europe have reacted if he'd left them alone and only gone after Russia?
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
AdvanceAustralia
Too late
10/18/2006 2:18:49 PM
Western Europe's involvement had little to do with Hitler attacking westwards. After years of appeasement the UK and France drew a line in the sand and guaranteed Polish independence. As soon as Hitler invaded Poland they declared war on Germany.
Even if Poland had not been in the way it is debatable whether Germany could have defeated Russia, with it's seemingly never-ending strategic depth and enormous human resources upon which to draw.
To many students of military history the first rule of warfare is "don't invade Russia". Just ask Napoleon.
Quote
Reply
S-2
Hitler's Panzers East
10/18/2006 2:37:34 PM
Sure would be nice if somebody used the History boards now and again for this stuff, but that's just me and my sense of tidiness.
Might want to take a look though, as there's been tons of discussions about possible scenarios/variants discussed to exhaustion.
Quote
Reply
AdvanceAustralia
Thanks S2
10/18/2006 3:00:30 PM
I'd never actually noticed the Military History link on the top left of the page. Your comment led me to have a look and find it. I'll have read through.
Cheers.
Quote
Reply
reefdiver
10/19/2006 12:19:11 AM
Likewise - never noticed the history threads either.
Quote
Reply
jastayme3
10/23/2006 3:29:22 PM
Western Europe's involvement had little to do with Hitler attacking westwards. After years of appeasement the UK and France drew a line in the sand and guaranteed Polish independence. As soon as Hitler invaded Poland they declared war on Germany.
Even if Poland had not been in the way it is debatable whether Germany could have defeated Russia, with it's seemingly never-ending strategic depth and enormous human resources upon which to draw.
To many students of military history the first rule of warfare is "don't invade Russia". Just ask Napoleon.
Or you can ask the Golden Horde.
Russia's legendary inpregnability is based on Poltava(which hardly any remember), 1812, and world war ii.
There were more excuses for "don't besiege Constantinople"-now known as Istanbul.
The first rule of warfare is that there is an exception to every rule.
Quote
Reply
Photon
4/23/2007 3:15:04 PM
In the historical 1941, the Germans came pretty close, as the opening phase went pretty much as a 'wet dream': The Russians were not ready for the German onslaught, both politically and militarily, and could not effective control their forces until the Germans approached Moscow and Leningrad.
As for Poland: By the time the Germans annexed Czechoslovakia, the line was drawn between themselves and the British/French. It would have been the best for him, had he allowed to gobble up Poland with bluff, just like what he has done with the Rhineland, Austria, and Czechoslovakia. When the Brits and the French drew the line, Hitler was greatly pissed off -- he was not quite ready for the escalation.
For the Germans to have been more effective, they would have had to do the following:
1. Gear up for multi-season campaigns; total mobilization. (The Germans did not start total mobilization until 1943 ... too little, too late.)
2. Better propaganda. (What the Germans should have done was to play up the Russians' fear and hatred towards Stalin's regime; also play up ethnic and regional tension towards Kremlin. They should have been exploited to the max in places like the Ukraine and the Baltic States.)
3. Had the Germans pursued #1 early, they could have built more aircraft and submarines to have a better luck in the Atlantic. (Establishing the means of strangling the Brits should have been a major part of their overall strategic objective from the Day One, regardless of what happened in Russia.)
4. Persuade the Japanese to attack Siberia. (Not sure how well the Germans would persuade the Japanese, though, since, by then, the Japanese were more interested in Southeast Asia. At the global level, the German-Japanese alliance did not turn out to be much; they were geographically too far apart and could not coordinate their military plans.)
Quote
Reply
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
PHILIPPINES: The Plan To Stop China
PROCUREMENT: USMC Builds Their Backup System
MURPHY'S LAW: How Islam Breeds Defeat In The Air
SURFACE FORCES : Saar For The Rest Of Us
NIGERIA: The Hills Are Alive With The Sound Of Burning Churches
WINNING: Victory For The Bad Guys In Darfur
ATTRITION: The Destruction Of The Syrian Air Force
IRAQ: Holding Off The Holocaust
AIR DEFENSE: Patriot Gains A Longer Reach Against Missiles
PROCUREMENT: How Israeli Tech Gets To Eager Moslem Customers
MURPHY'S LAW: How The Generals Learned To Tolerate The Internet
YEMEN: Al Qaeda Scrambles To Survive
AFGHANISTAN: Taliban Divided On Making Peace
ISRAEL: Palestinians Inspired, Confused And Divided By Syria
MURPHY'S LAW: The Search For Politically Correct Weapons
COUNTER-TERRORISM: Why Syrian Rebels Have Their Own Internal Civil War
INFORMATION WARFARE: Data Mining Screws The Pirates
RUSSIA: The Red Army Gets Its Mojo Back
INFORMATION WARFARE: NetTraveler Joins Red October
WARPLANES: Yet More New Arrival Dates For The F-35
ARTILLERY: Caesar Gets Bulletproof, Just In Case
INDIA-PAKISTAN: Dark Days For The Generals
NAVAL AIR: U.S. Navy Ships Get a New UAV
INTELLIGENCE: How To Spot North Korean Spies
PROCUREMENT: Russia Battles Incompetent Shipyards
MURPHY'S LAW: The Chinese Edge Over South Asia
SYRIA: A Bloody Summer Guaranteed
SUDAN: Misery
NAVAL AIR: Russia Plays Catch Up
IRAN: The Sure Thing
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
Attrition: The Destruction Of The Syrian Air Force
WARS Iraq: Holding Off The Holocaust
Air Defense: Patriot Gains A Longer Reach Against Missiles
Procurement: How Israeli Tech Gets To Eager Moslem Customers
Information Warfare: Data Mining Screws The Pirates
Murphy's Law: How The Generals Learned To Tolerate The Internet
Murphy's Law: The Search For Politically Correct Weapons
WARS Russia: The Red Army Gets Its Mojo Back
WARS Yemen: Al Qaeda Scrambles To Survive
WARS Israel: Palestinians Inspired, Confused And Divided By Syria
WARS Afghanistan: Taliban Divided On Making Peace
Artillery: Caesar Gets Bulletproof, Just In Case
Warplanes: Yet More New Arrival Dates For The F-35
Counter-Terrorism: Why Syrian Rebels Have Their Own Internal Civil War
WARS India-Pakistan: Dark Days For The Generals
Information Warfare: NetTraveler Joins Red October
Naval Air: U.S. Navy Ships Get a New UAV
Intelligence: How To Spot North Korean Spies
Procurement: Russia Battles Incompetent Shipyards
Murphy's Law: The Chinese Edge Over South Asia
WARS Syria: A Bloody Summer Guaranteed
Naval Air: Russia Plays Catch Up
Intelligence: World War II LST Threatens China
NBC Weapons: New Nukes Overshadowed By Massive Retirements
WARS Iran: The Sure Thing
MURPHY'S LAW: The Search For Politically Correct Weapons
SYRIA: A Bloody Summer Guaranteed
MURPHY'S LAW: Russian Diplomats Wield Their Missiles Deftly
IRAN: The Sure Thing
IRAQ: Holding Off The Holocaust
WARPLANES: Yet More New Arrival Dates For The F-35
INTELLIGENCE: World War II LST Threatens China
SUBMARINES: American SSN Fleet Shrinks
RUSSIA: The Red Army Gets Its Mojo Back
MURPHY'S LAW: How The Generals Learned To Tolerate The Internet
ATTRITION: The Destruction Of The Syrian Air Force
NIGERIA: The Hills Are Alive With The Sound Of Burning Churches
SURFACE FORCES : Saar For The Rest Of Us
MURPHY'S LAW: How Islam Breeds Defeat In The Air
WINNING: Victory For The Bad Guys In Darfur
COUNTER-TERRORISM: Why Syrian Rebels Have Their Own Internal Civil War
ARTILLERY: Caesar Gets Bulletproof, Just In Case
INTELLIGENCE: Chinese Spies Slip Into India
INDIA-PAKISTAN: Dark Days For The Generals
PROCUREMENT: USMC Builds Their Backup System
Procurement: USMC Builds Their Backup System
Surface Forces: Saar For The Rest Of Us
Philipines: The Plan To Stop China
Murphy's Law in Action: How Islam Breeds Defeat In The Air
Leadership: Shut Up You Whore,
Nigeria: The Hills Are Alive With The Sound Of Burning Churches
Who's Winning: Victory For The Bad Guys In Darfur
Procurement: How Israeli Tech Gets To Eager Moslem Customers
Books of Interest
Gettysburg: The Last Invasion
American Gun: A History of the U.S. in Ten Firearms
The Chinese Information War: Espionage, Cyberwar, Communications Control and Related Threats to United States Interests
The Guns at Last Light: The War in Western Europe, 1944-1945 (Liberation Trilogy)
From Amazon
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Prediction Market
Wargames
Measure of Respect
On War and Warfare
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
Military Movie Reviews
StrategyPage
Subscribe
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Account Manager
Advertise With Us
Search