Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
United Kingdom Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: British Forces at War: As Witnessed by an American
AdamB    4/13/2007 2:54:36 PM
American Michael Lyon was impressed as he witnessed the British Army at war in Iraq....... British Forces at War: As Witnessed by an American Basra, Iraq Michael Lyon The explosions from enemy rockets and mortar fire have been constant companions for the small contingent of Coalition forces based at the former Basra Palace, on the banks of Shatt al Arab River. In the past five months, more than a thousand bombs have been fired at this small base, all while these British combat troops, Romanian soldiers and a small contingent of Americans continue their attempts to stabilize Iraq. The nearby US Regional Embassy office also is frequently targeted. A dramatic surge in IDF attacks (indirect fire: rockets and mortars) began here in September 2006, subsequent an increase in British troops. Locals cite Iranian influence behind the attacks, while British officers say this is the most IDF’d base in Iraq. The dozens of bombs that exploded on the base in the first five days of my embed with a British infantry platoon punctuated those claims. The building where many British forces live is frequently hit. Recently a rocket slammed into the living quarters, creating a massive gape and much wreckage, while severely wounding one soldier from 5 Platoon. Just this week, a mortar bomb severely damaged a British armored vehicle parked outside, and another bomb explosively pruned a treetop, fragging the building where soldiers live, and leaving ears ringing. A 5 Platoon soldier videotaped the impact as it happened. Amazingly, despite the frequency of the IDF attacks, a combination of force protection measures and sheer luck have prevented the death of any British soldier, though combat forces have been seriously wounded from them. The risk of spending an hour outside the building might be equivalent to smoking a thousand cartons of unfiltered cigarettes. And Crossfit exercise might not help: the old gym was blasted a few days ago. Earlier this week, when Moqtada al Sadr issued a call to violence against Coalition forces, multiple IDF strikes were launched against this base. Militias based in the al Quibla district of Basra, a notorious haven for Shia “JAM” militias who are loyal to or influenced by al Sadr, were believed responsible. Many of their shots miss the base, landing in civilian populations. According to the British commanders, JAM members will attack local journalists who report these mistakes. Before al Sadr issued his provocation, the British Army was planning aggressive offensive actions against terrorists and militia members, and allowed this writer to join 5 Platoon, 2nd Battalion, “The Rifles” Battle Group for six days of missions. Those missions included Operation Arezzo, named for the Tuscan city that was the site of famous battles in the 14th century, and of an important victory for British troops in July 1941 as they drove the Axis forces north and out of Italy for good. Surrounded by JAM: British Forces just before the shootout Operation Arezzo Lieutenant Colonel Justin Maciejewski MBE, the Battle Group Operations Commander (equivalent to an American Battalion Commander), allowed this writer unprecedented access to the planning details of Operation Arezzo, part of three simultaneous strike and arrest operations in the al Quibla district of Basra, designed in part to bait the enemy into attacking British forces. In all, 13 platoons would partake, and I’d accompany 5 Platoon. LTC Maciejewski further permitted me to record both video and still camera images during the operation, and to get as close to the combat as I dare. 5 Platoon has seen a lot of fighting in recent months, and had already taken me on several minor missions. For Operation Arezzo, they adopted me as one of their own. The plan for Operation Arezzo was cleverly contrived. While Americans count on helicopter support for deliberate high-intensity combat here, the Brits were going into extremely hostile terrain, outnumbered, without helicopter support, relying instead upon timing, terrain, maneuverability, firepower, and sheer audacity. In combat, luck can be a decisive factor, but Murphy’s Law remains in effect. For Operation Arezzo, the risks of something going catastrophically wrong were apparent at the outset. The soldiers in 5 Platoon had never conducted such an audacious operation—in broad daylight—but LTC Maciejewski intended to show the enemy that even in their strongest bastion, outnumbered British forces could strike into their heart and inflict heavy losses. Shortly before the mission, as soldiers from 5 Platoon disassembled their weapons for cleaning (again), performed functions checks, the tone of the music coming out of their speakers changed. As with American combat forces, before embarking on a deliberate fight, the music became more rousing and to the bone. For Operation Arezzo, the pre-battle tune was Gimme Shelter, by the Rolling Stones: War, Children, it’s just a s
 
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Pages: 1 2
AdamB       4/13/2007 2:57:15 PM
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo2.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo2.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo2.jpg">

Surrounded by JAM: British Forces just before the shootout
------------------------
 
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo3.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo3.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo3.jpg">
British Forces at War: “Squaddies” from 5 Platoon burst into first target house, part of a force of about 400 soldiers on an audacious daylight raid into an enemy stronghold.
---------------------------
 
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo4.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo4.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo4.jpg">
Surrounded by enemy forces, men appear on a roof. A British sniper can be seen on the roof in the background. Unfortunately, the primary (“alpha”) targets were not home and escaped death or capture. Nearby, at about the same time, an Iraqi policeman was murdered.
-----------------------
 
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo5.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo5.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo5.jpg">
5 Platoon on second entry
---------------------------
 
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo6.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo6.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo6.jpg">
During the third entry, the terrorists were not home, but a woman and two small children were obviously present. 5 Platoon did not throw flashbangs, and their touch was so light that the small children did not cry.
-----------------------
 
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo7.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo7.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo7.jpg">
Almost as if on cue, small-arms fire begins.
------------------------
 
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo8.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo8.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo8.jpg">
Reloading during one of the firefights
----------------------------
 
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo9.jpg'" alt="Image hotlink - 'http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo9.jpg'" src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a63/trikatnieks/Photo9.jpg">
Members of 5 Platoon after the battle
-----------------------------
 
Quote    Reply

SGTObvious       4/13/2007 3:23:35 PM
Very nice, Adam, but why aren't they wearing eye protection during the fight?
 
Eye injuries are very nasty, often result in permanent damage, and are often caused by very minor fragments, like a chip of concrete spalled off by a bullet, easily blocked by eye protection.  One flying pebble could have blinded any one of those men.
 
SGTObvious
 
Quote    Reply

SGTObvious       4/13/2007 3:26:09 PM
Sorry. I meant to say why aren't they ALL wearing eye protection.  Some are.  Those are the smarter ones.
 
A good NCO should make sure they ALL do.
 
SGTObvious
 
Quote    Reply

VelocityVector       4/13/2007 3:49:07 PM

In exchange for being granted access the blog author has painted a rosey picture.  No surprises there nor with the timing of the article release viz a recent incident by which British forces including "elite" marines and a naval "Jabba the Hut" were snatched by an isolated country.  He might impress me by including pertinent criticisms like such routinely directed at the American forces.  Ballyhoo old chap, hip hip for the lads -- all the world is a stage as you know.

v^2

 
Quote    Reply

flamingknives       4/13/2007 4:05:42 PM
The timing of this article is not necessarily due to the MoD. Being as Michael Yon is an American - writes quite nicely too - and this story was written very recently (the casualties from the Warrior incident mentioned were only repatriated on Thursday).

He paints a pretty rosy picture of US forces too, although, having been embedded with them longer, he has reported some human frailties there too. If he stays with and reports on the British, no doubt some of those will get into his reports on them. 

Regarding eye protection, those without might have a reason for eschwing goggles - glare, dirt, condensation might get in the way of seeing a threat.

What pertinent criticisms might one expect?
 
Quote    Reply

VelocityVector       4/13/2007 4:42:14 PM
What pertinent criticisms might one expect?
"Amazingly, despite the frequency of the IDF attacks, a combination of force protection measures and sheer luck have prevented the death of any British soldier, though combat forces have been seriously wounded from them. The risk of spending an hour outside the building might be equivalent to smoking a thousand cartons of unfiltered cigarettes. And Crossfit exercise might not help: the old gym was blasted a few days ago."

Failure to resolve a long-term shelling problem.

"Many of their shots miss the base, landing in civilian populations. According to the British commanders, JAM members will attack local journalists who report these mistakes."

Failure to safeguard the local civilian population.

"The plan for Operation Arezzo was cleverly contrived. While Americans count on helicopter support for deliberate high-intensity combat here, the Brits were going into extremely hostile terrain, outnumbered, without helicopter support, relying instead upon timing, terrain, maneuverability, firepower, and sheer audacity."

Failure to deploy adequate overwatch forces (note:  this has bitten Britain in its arse recently).

"As with American combat forces, before embarking on a deliberate fight, the music became more rousing and to the bone. For Operation Arezzo, the pre-battle tune was Gimme Shelter, by the Rolling Stones:
War, Children, it’s just a shot away
It’s just a shot away
War, Children, it’s just a shot away
It’s just a shot away"

Failure to abide by political correctness.

"Just last week a formidable Challenger tank was destroyed by an explosion that also cost the driver his legs. Days before, four British soldiers and their Iraqi interpreter had been killed at the same place when a similar bomb detonated."

Failure to defend against IEDs.

"Unfortunately, the primary ('alpha') targets were not home and escaped death or capture. Nearby, at about the same time, an Iraqi policeman was murdered.

Failure to achieve the mission objective; failure to protect allies.

"With no helicopters above to help develop ground awareness or to help shape the combat by engaging targets, British commanders directed their elements by map and ground-feel. Having no helicopters also left rooftops open to the enemy, adding another dimension to the combat."

Failure to deploy adequate overwatch forces (this has bitten Britain in its arse recently).

"But with all the IDF attacks, soldiers here truly are taking extreme risks to smoke outside."

Failure to obey operational protocol.

"Rifleman Lee Hulbert, wearing his helmet and body armor, was smoking with his friends when Murphy’s Law kicked in. There was no rocket attack, no lightning strike. About 15 meters (about 50 feet) above Lee’s head, three heavy pieces of marble, each weighing perhaps 10 kg (more than 20 lbs), dislodged from the palace, and hurtled toward Lee Hulbert. One piece struck the back of his helmet, crashed off his body armor, and he fell quiet to the ground. Hulbert had fought well throughout his tour in Iraq, only to be felled by a piece of marble. He’s been med-evac’d and is said to be in good condition."

Failure to observe common sense.

"These soldiers are so good that I have requested from British commanders to be allowed to stay longer."

Small wonder "these soldiers are so good!"

"Failures" such as the above are practically the sole focus of MSM reports on US efforts in like actions.  We just don't receive the positive press and recognition by the British/Europeans/MSM.

v^2

 
Quote    Reply

flamingknives       4/13/2007 4:54:41 PM
So the criticisms are there, he reports them but chooses not to make a big thing of them. Have you read his accounts of being embedded with a US Stryker unit? The style (unsurprisingly) is very similar.

I think you're stretching it a bit with some of your points though. Political correctness? I do not see how the music/lyrics mentioned are politically incorrect at all. Your comment on operational protocol is not based on anything in the article - so whether or not it is operational protocol to smoke outside or not is pure speculation. The common sense bit (apart from invoking common sense, which is frequently neither) is criticising what exactly? The perils of standing by walls? Not doing damage assessment frequently enough? I'm not psychic.

With the other criticisms, with whom does the fault lie?
 
Quote    Reply

DNS77       4/13/2007 8:17:22 PM
Nice article.  I like the fact that they had the balls to march right into the center of JAM country in broad daylight and proceed to kick the militia's asses. I wish some of our NATO allies in Afghanistan would fight like the Brit's.
 
Quote    Reply

Padfoot       4/14/2007 9:06:02 PM
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/42791000/jpg/_42791617_basra_ap203b.jpg" alt="British soldiers in basra" border="0" height="152" hspace="0" vspace="0" width="203">
The gunmen were laying bombs when they were killed
British forces have killed eight gunmen laying landmines in southern Iraq, local police have confirmed.

The operation took place in Basra on Friday night in the area where four soldiers and a translator were killed in a roadside bomb earlier this month.

The Ministry of Defence said it was not possible to directly link those killed last night with last week's bombs.

"However, these militiamen were intent upon launching exactly the same type of attack in the same area," he added.

The operation at 2240 local time was carried out by the 2nd Battalion Duke of Lancaster regiment on the outskirts of the Hyall Shuala district to the west of Basra city.

Two roadside bomb teams were hit as they laid devices, the MoD said.

http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gif" alt="" border="0" height="1" hspace="0" vspace="0" width="5">
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/start_quote_rb.gif" alt="" border="0" height="13" width="24"> Operations against rogue militia will therefore continue, especially so against their leadership and their weapons stocks but also, as in this case, against operatives http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/end_quote_rb.gif" alt="" align="right" border="0" height="13" vspace="0" width="23">
Lt Col Kevin Stratford-Wright

Police in Basra were unable to confirm the eight dead men were from the Mehdi Army, but other local sources claimed they were from the Shia militia, loyal to Moqtada al Sadr.

The police also said the British detained a local Mehdi Army commander during the operation.

Lt Col Kevin Stratford-Wright, military spokesman in Basra, said the multinational force "must be able to strike militia who seek to kill its soldiers, and who also intimidate the people of Basra with death threats".

He said: "Operations against rogue militia will therefore continue, especially so against their leadership and their weapons stocks but also, as in this case, against operatives.

"Increasingly, over the coming weeks and months, these operations will become Iraqi-led and executed."

Second Lt Joanna Yorke Dyer, 24, Cpl Kris O'Neill, 27, Pte Eleanor Dlugosz, 19, and Kingsman Adam James Smith, 19, were attacked on 5 April near Basra.

All four soldiers died when a Warrior armoured vehicle returning from patrol near Basra was attacked.

A Kuwaiti interpreter was also killed in the blast, which seriously injured a fifth soldier and left a 3ft-deep crater in the road.


 
Quote    Reply

neutralizer       4/15/2007 8:01:02 AM
Competantly conducted operation, with the UK commanders out-thinking the insurgents.  Also demonstates good risk assesssment, it's all too easy to get bogged down with excessive force protection at the expense of the main game.  Obviously after 5 months the guys have also worked out the negative/positive risks (hence not bothering about eye-protection in that particular area).  Certainly not the first time anywhere that a lift is attempted only to find the target missing, some of these guys are so uncooperative.  It's interesting that the Brits aren't wedded to heli overwatch, this was quite a large op by the scale of things in Basra, if they'd wanted a Lynx one would have been available, or perhaps RPV.  It would seem that they reckon helis are more downside than upside, it would be interesting to know the reasoning.
 
It also looks like there is currently an upgrade to IED command detonation arrangements that will take a few weeks to get on top of.  Given that the Brits have been playing this particular ECM game for over 30 yrs there's no doubt a software upgrade in the offing. 
 
Quote    Reply
1 2



 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics