Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
The French "Union" Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Questions For French Posters
JIMF    8/30/2006 3:05:37 PM
1. A number of years ago a French friend told me that most French people maintain that they are atheists or agnostics, however, in their later years if they have the opportunity they will generally confess and accept the last rites of the Catholic Church. If this was ever true, is it still true? 2. What was the political motivation for giving us (America) The Statue of Liberty? 3. Is their any possibility of reintroducing conscription/national service, or is it a dead issue?
 
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Pages: 1 2
french stratege       8/30/2006 3:09:16 PM
test
 
Quote    Reply

french stratege       8/30/2006 3:24:09 PM

1. A number of years ago a French friend told me that most French people maintain that they are atheists or agnostics, however, in their later years if they have the opportunity they will generally confess and accept the last rites of the Catholic Church. If this was ever true, is it still true?

2. What was the political motivation for giving us (America) The Statue of Liberty?

3. Is their any possibility of reintroducing conscription/national service, or is it a dead issue?


1: Agnostic mean you don't know.So it is more true to this kind of people.In the doubt I guess some people do it.Also as a tradition to be buried as a christian (you know family pressure)

2: It is a gift for the 100 year anniversary of USA , initially a private initiative of Bartholdi who was a french republican (in french meaning) and wanted as other republican to strengthen links between USA and France.I remember you that France was the only major republic in world aside USA at this time.

3: reintroducing conscription/national service: yes at any time as it is suspended and not cancelled.The governement do not need a new law to reintroduce it.Moreover a majority of French including the left, favor draft:

-Left think that draft avoid army to become a pretorian army commited to expeditionnary wars, and it is good to educate and mix people

-Right think it strengthen national values, tradition and disciplin

A lot of people think also that defense is a matter of everybody and not only professionals.

However it is unlikely it is now reinstalled unless a strong threat appears (likely in Europe)or a war, as army do not need it now since it would compell it to redo a major organisational change and moreover do not need a full class of age.

 
Quote    Reply

Herc the Merc    More questions for FS   8/30/2006 3:28:44 PM
Sometime ago u mentioned that French women were easier  than Anglo-Saxons. So say I went over to France for a 2 week vacation--just what would be the process- meet girl at disco-pay drinks-offer dinner--and thats it???
 
Quote    Reply

jean       8/30/2006 3:33:36 PM

1) I don't know the proportion , but there are some french who consider themselves as atheists or agnostics . That's true , but "most " i don't think. The agnostics are more rare than the atheists.  80% of the french are supposed to be catholics , truely or by tradition. The republic has always fought the weight of the religions, France is a secular country, that's the most important for me.

2) No it was sincerely given to USA by France to hail and celebrate the centennial of your revolution. I hope it's always a symbol of friendship for you.

3) No i think it's over , at least , for a long time, alas. I did it , and don't regret. They should have kept 2 months to be familiar with the military stuffs.

 
Quote    Reply

soleil9       8/30/2006 5:46:43 PM

3. Is their any possibility of reintroducing conscription/national service, or is it a dead issue?
Cnscription could be reactived with a simple "decret" of the president, but few months ago politicians spoke about that and it was calculated that NS will cost 14 billions ??? /years

 
Quote    Reply

JIMF       8/30/2006 7:34:12 PM

Herc,

Thanks for elevating the level of conversation.  I have never been to France either, but I understand there is an area of Paris called Pigalle where the women are quite "easy" if not necessarily cheap.  

 

 

 

 
Quote    Reply

JIMF       8/30/2006 7:47:11 PM

Thanks for the responses. 

I've read some articles recently raising the "Praetorian" issue with regard to the U.S. military. 

 

 
Quote    Reply

VelocityVector       8/30/2006 11:39:35 PM

I have never been to France either

I visit quite regularly.  Two big shockers.  One, French people go out of their way to be nice to Le Americain.  Two, no other country I've visited hosts more Ugly Americans, specifically those from the Texas oil patch.  It's no wonder they dislike Bush.


v^2

 
Quote    Reply

Herc the Merc    Velocity vector   8/31/2006 1:03:25 PM

Do Aggies like me make it on Frenchies "dislike" list--oh well but I live in California now.....

I can be like a Chameleon.

 
Quote    Reply

Godofgamblers    herc   9/6/2006 12:25:53 AM

Sometime ago u mentioned that French women were easier  than Anglo-Saxons. So say I went over to France for a 2 week vacation--just what would be the process- meet girl at disco-pay drinks-offer dinner--and thats it???


At last a French board where we can discuss the important things in life!
 
I think you'll find that feminism has not made serious inroads in france. In fact, many French women feel that feminism in the 70s 'went too far'.
 
So imagine you're in the US in the 70s.... sort of a Happy Hunting Ground, Herc.
 
Two weeks doesn't give you much time... make sure to brush up your Friendster profile first he he
 
Quote    Reply
1 2



 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics