Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Russia Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Russian Involvement in Afganistan
Phoenix Rising    11/29/2001 9:38:33 AM I'm surprised that the Russians were so quick to return. It sounds like they didn't bring much with them, but the fact that their presence is so open is surprising. The Americans and British seem to be taking all lengths possible to stay out of sight. The Afghans have even more reason to hate the Russians, but the Russians just walked into Kabul with a sign that said "here we are!" Then again, the Russians claim that they aren't there to fight, while the Americans and the British obviously couldn't do that. What I'm really wondering about is not why the Russian troops are there now, but how many more they plan to bring in. It sounds like their numbers are low enough now that they could very believably be exactly what Moscow says they are: security for re-opening the Russian embassy in Kabul and facilitating the delivery of humanitarian aid. If they leave it at that, that would not make them overly welcome, but it would probably at least make them tolerable. On the other hand, it does seem to go against the American conventional wisdom that says the best way to get involved in Afghanistan is to get in, stay mobile, and get out. I'm not surprised that this development (Russian presence) happened, but I'm surprised that it happened so early. I never thought they would go in in advance of the bulk of the international coalition. Oh well. --Phoenix Rising
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
E G Farblo    RE:Russian Involvement in Afganistan   11/29/2001 6:36:52 PM
What did you expect after the Bush-Putin summit, cold pizza and no caviar?
Quote    Reply

bsl    RE:Russian Involvement in Afganistan   11/30/2001 6:01:43 PM
It's not as if Russia doesn't have a strategic interest in the area, now, is it? Certainly as great an interest as Pakistan has. I'm less suprised than some by the seeming repprochment between Russia and America because I have long believed that Russia has an even more powerful strategic interest in fighting the malignant branch of Islam because Russia is closer to the heart of the Islamic world, and faces, in abstract, even greater danger than we do. I'd say that the experience with the islamcist Taliban and Al Qaeda has shown Russia that it's whole Asian underbelly is threatened. The Moslem former SSRs, first. Later, though, even inside Russia, itself, which has a very substantial moslem population. Al Qaeda sent people to the Balkans. Has people in Chechnya. May have been involved in those bombings in Moscow a while back. Is trying to foment rebellions in some of the Central Asia ex-SSRs. No suprise Russia sees a reason to have some say in what happens in Afghanistan in the future
Quote    Reply