Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Israel
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
Can Israel get the job done?
flyingarty
9/29/2009 9:09:01 AM
What do you think? If Israel attacks Iran's nuclear sites, can they accomplish their task?
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
Shirrush
No.
9/29/2009 12:14:31 PM
According to open sources, the IDF does not have what it takes to go on the offense against a foe as big as Iran. The Israel
Defense
Forces are presently trained and equipped to bleed an attacking enemy at, or near Israel's borders. Force projection and long-range
conventional
offense are not in the book, and never have been.
The IDF/AF currently has a little more than 100 fighters, i.e. one F15I and 3-4 F16I squadrons, which have the adequate nominal combat range to reach targets in Iran. There are but a handful of tanker, electronic intelligence/ attack and early warning aircraft which might be used to escort a strike package, but would be extremely vulnerable in hostile airspace, meaning all of the airspace comprising the ~1,000 miles distance to Iranian targets. None of these planes is a low-observable platform, but most of them can "pave" without exhausting their pilots, as they apparently did in Syria. One massive strike could conceivably achieve mission success, but follow-on flights would be in doubt with the enemy on full alert, and Arab (and US?) air forces running interference with the best and the latest Western fighters and IADS.
The lack of a possibility for the required sustained air campaign would probably ensure the survival of many if not most of Iran's offensive assets, such as the dispersed, mobile and concealed MRBM TELs and its cruise missiles, enabling the enemy to retaliate at will.
The damage from such a single strike on multiple, hardened nuclear installations, would probably be rather limited if not symbolic, and would not stop the mullah's programme for any length of time while ensuring the regime popular support because of the national affront, the unavoidable loss of life and the possible radioactive contamination of large areas (Hissing UF
6
: not pretty!).
Israel's naval offensive capabilities out of the Mediterranean are nil. While the IAI and the ISA have certainly made their point as to their ability to design and build big rockets and achieve a little more than 50% success with space shots, there is no convincing evidence that an Israeli ballistic missile capability has ever been implemented, let alone funded. Same goes, by the way, for the alleged nuclear arsenal, which lacks both the money trail and the societal footprint to be more than a rumor-milled deterrent-on-the-cheap.
Most importantly, causing dire damage to Iran's infrastructure and shedding Persian blood is definitely not in Israel's best interest. There are no territorial contention, border dispute, or even conflict of interests between the two countries.
Iran presently has a religious-fascist regime which is irrationally hostile to Israel, and which is as unpopular with the Iranian people as it is feared by the Israeli citizenry. There is much mutual understanding and even admiration between the two cultures, and 25 centuries of common recorded History. Regime change is what we want for Iran, not war: we'll have enough of that with the Arabs for the foreseeable future. Then, Iran can have its nukes if it feels it needs them, and, with Arab and Shoorevi neighbors who are not likely to change their ways it probably does. After all, who cares about India having them? A democracy is not bent on aggression, and post-Islamic Persia will probably be able to afford both a nuclear and a space program, with which Israel will be more than happy to cooperate.
Quote
Reply
Ezekiel
YES
9/29/2009 3:39:42 PM
Yes it can!!!
if there is any airforce that has the experience, know-how, motivation and capabilities to pull this off...it is the IAF.
Quote
Reply
Shirrush
True...
9/29/2009 5:14:57 PM
...But unfortunately, not the stealth bombers nor the airbases in Herat and in Balad.
Quote
Reply
Ezekiel
Underestimate
9/30/2009 5:47:16 AM
as of 15 months ago Israel had green light to use georgian air bases which no one knew about. WHy can't this be duplicated on another territory???
As for Israeli stealth and radar evading capabities....there is much we do not know, and it would be folly to underestimate Israeli resourcefulness.
Quote
Reply
Shirrush
9/30/2009 6:02:56 AM
Please note I wrote the above posts
before
reading
this
.
A. Cordesman is not all-knowing, but he's been in the business of making sense a lot more, and for a lot longer than I have.
Quote
Reply
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
WEAPONS: Unjammable Wire Controlled UAVs
RUSSIA: Russia Claims a Lot More Than Ukraine
ARMOR: Russia Rebuilds Its Tank Forces
ARTILLERY: Fire Weaver and Long Spike
ARMOR: Evolution of Tank Warfare in Ukraine
SURFACE FORCES : Ada Class Corvettes
ARMOR: Evolution of Tank Warfare in Ukraine
WEAPONS: Putting a Spike in North Korean Aggression
AIR WEAPONS: The Ukraine Unmanned Systems Force
PROCUREMENT: The Russian Smuggling Industry
AFGHANISTAN: Afghanistan March 2024
ATTRITION: Patterns of American Combat Casualties
ELECTRONIC WEAPONS: Norway Again Attacked by Russian Jamming
SURFACE FORCES : Unmanned LUSV Ships at Sea
MURPHY'S LAW: China Harasses Foreign Investment it Encouraged
PROCUREMENT: Russian Demand and North Korean Arms Production
PROCUREMENT: Russian Demand and North Korean Arms Production
WARPLANES: F22 Gets an End Date
ARTILLERY: More Truck Mounted Artillery for Ukraine
SPACE: Russian Roscosmos Retreating
INTELLIGENCE: Americans Use AI to Plan Airstrikes
SPACE: Russian Roscosmos Retreating
ARTILLERY: More Truck Mounted Artillery for Ukraine
AIR DEFENSE: Russian Air Defense Tries Something New
SUBMARINES: Stumbling Through Submarine Repairs
SPECIAL OPERATIONS: A Decade of CIA Operations in Ukraine
SURFACE FORCES : Despised LCS Survives with Upgrades
SYRIA: Syria March 2024
WARPLANES: F-35 Aircraft in Action
LEADERSHIP: Russia’s Wartime Economic Crisis
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
Artillery: Artillery Ammunition Quality and Quantity
Surface Forces: Russian Black Sea Fleet Disappears
WARS Russia: Can Russia Continue the War After 2024?
Armor: K2 Tanks For Everyone
WARS China: China Needs South Korea More Than North Korea
Surface Forces: Naval Reload Realities
WARS Korea: Korea March 2024
Air Weapons: Dealing With FPV UAVs
Special Operations: Somali Pirates are Back
Logistics: The Black Sea Blockade
Procurement: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
Attrition: Russian Losses so Far in Ukraine
Procurement: French Support for Ukraine
NBC Weapons: Chinese Biowar Laboratories in California
Procurement: 3D Printers For Ukraine
Air Defense: NASAMS Under Fire
NBC WEAPONS: Chinese Biowar Laboratories in California
ATTRITION: Russian Losses so Far in Ukraine
PROCUREMENT: French Support for Ukraine
ARMOR: New American M10 Tank
AIR WEAPONS: Western Russia Under Attack
ARTILLERY: Artillery Ammunition Quality and Quantity
SURFACE FORCES : Naval Reload Realities
ARMOR: K2 Tanks For Everyone
AIR WEAPONS: Dealing With FPV UAVs
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
PROCUREMENT: 3D Printers For Ukraine
LOGISTICS: The Black Sea Blockade
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
KOREA: Korea March 2024
SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Somali Pirates are Back
CHINA: China Needs South Korea More Than North Korea
Russia: Can Russia Continue the War After 2024?
Russia: Russia Claims a Lot More Than Ukraine
Procurement: French Support for Ukraine
Attrition: Russian Losses so Far in Ukraine
Armor: New American M10 Tank
Warplane Weapons: Western Russia Under Attack
Artillery: Artillery Ammunition Quality and Quantity
Weapons of the World: Unjammable Wire Controlled UAVs
Surface Forces: Naval Reload Realities
Armor: Russia Rebuilds Its Tank Forces
Procurement: Ukraine War Crippled Russian Arms Exports
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
StrategyPage
Account Manager
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Advertise With Us
Search