Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Israel Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: How did Israel secure its status as a nation state after WWII?
Yimmy    10/25/2006 5:03:01 PM
Opinions anyone?
 
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Pages: 1 2 3 4   NEXT
HoundOfHello       10/25/2006 8:35:50 PM
Two things: the fact that both the US and the USSR agreed that Israel was cool, and the fact that the Israelis beat the cr@p out of the bad neighbors who wanted to deny them that status. The former was important because it ensured that Israel would not be in some sort of diplomatic limbo in the UN (then still regarded as actually being useful), and the latter was important because status would have been irrelevant if they had lost.

-HoH

 
Quote    Reply

Yimmy       10/25/2006 8:55:33 PM
"status would have been irrelevant if they
had lost. "

I like that... mind if I use it?
 


 
Quote    Reply

Shirrush       10/26/2006 6:59:34 AM
Has it?
Is there any other nation-state on Earth, which status and legitimacy are being as constantly dicussed and challenged as Israel?
Kiribati? nah!

 
Quote    Reply

Heorot    Yimmy   10/26/2006 8:37:30 AM

Opinions anyone?


This is a good place to start from the British viewpoint.

 

 
Quote    Reply

Yimmy       10/26/2006 4:20:54 PM

Has it?
Is there any other nation-state on Earth, which status and legitimacy are being as constantly dicussed and challenged as Israel?
Kiribati? nah!



I don't think anyone can argue that Israel is a state, although the concept of a "nation-state" could be argued.  People may not like it, but they can't really pretend it doesnt exist!
 
Quote    Reply

jastayme3       10/26/2006 9:15:19 PM

 The basic mottos are "in the land of the blind the one eyed man is king."

And "knowlege is power".

And "wounded animals are dangerous"

The Jews had foreign knowlege. They knew how to build a modern state from reading about the states around. And they spent about fifty years practiceing during the days of the Mandate. By world war ii the Yishuv was capable of ruling on it's own. When the British left Jewish regions nothing changed but a few procedural thises and thats.
By contrast the Palestinian Arabs hadn't thought to build a decent political lobby let alone a counterpart to the Yishuv. When the British left everything collapesed in the Palestinian Arab zones. The dynastic states were better organized but still basically giant sheikdoms.
The Jews had skilled people from far away and money from far away. Arab states had more money but did not know what to do with it. The Palestinians did not have that.
The Jew's had known for a long time that they would have to fight for survival and were prepared. The Arabs expected a pogram not a war.
The Jews had fewer resources of both personal and arms but they made it go farther-they were able to get a tremendous Military Participation Ratio which made up for the low population.
The Yishuv could not compare with a Great Power but it was very formidable for the region. And in the land of the blind the one eyed man is king.
Finally the Jews were desperate. And desperation has a power of it's own. Someone said the Arabs declared a holy war but the Jews fought one. Survival is a very strong motivation. As is "We won't have any more @#! goyim think they can pick on us and not get it back!" In the meantime the Arabs were fighting among themselves and the strength of their motives was mixed. Some Arabs had come simply  because they had nothing better to do. Desperation  isn't enough ffor maneuver war but it is most useful in attrition war.
More and more Jews were immigrating, increasing the new states military potential. At the same time the Arabs were losing manpower at an intolerable rate in attritional fighting in Jerusalem and around the Kibbutzim. At the final phase the Jews could field a force that was superior in all areas to the Arabs and the Arabs were incapable of going farther.
At that point the Jews could turn to the attack-with interior lines. The Arabs were incapable of resisting. And the Jews could conquer more then was alloted to them by partition and justify it by Vae Victas. And at that momment no one in the entire world was in the mood to object. Even the British mainly wanted out by that time. The Jews simply stopped before the world's mood changed, when they had conquered enough to make a geographically defensible state
 
Quote    Reply

jastayme3       10/26/2006 9:21:45 PM

Two things: the fact that both the US and the USSR agreed that Israel
was cool, and the fact that the Israelis beat the cr@p out of the bad
neighbors who wanted to deny them that status. The former was important
because it ensured that Israel would not be in some sort of diplomatic
limbo in the UN (then still regarded as actually being useful), and the
latter was important because status would have been irrelevant if they
had lost.



-HoH


To be honest the second was the most important. Says something about the world doesn't it? If the Arabs had won the world would have simply gone "tsk, tsk" over the "poor Jews" without helping a bit. And to be fair the world was stuffed with unfortunate people more then usual then, and few care about those they have no connection too. As the Jews won it was necessary to have some diplomatic influence with them. Some things never change.

 
Quote    Reply

jastayme3       10/26/2006 9:33:38 PM

Has it?
Is there any other nation-state on Earth, which status and legitimacy are being as constantly dicussed and challenged as Israel?
Kiribati? nah!


Probably not. But I note that the challenges to Israel's legitimacy do not seem to inspire the Kneset to disolve the State of Israel.
 
Quote    Reply

Yimmy       11/17/2006 6:17:50 AM
Nobody else got any comments on how Israel came into being?
 
 
Quote    Reply

Herald1234    Just this...........   11/17/2006 6:52:59 AM
Many, of the actual fighters among the Israelis, had excellent training in the Second World War. Whether as partisans, or volunteers, or former soldiers in Allied armies who emigrated to the British Mandate prior to 1947, that gave the Israelis a ready-made officer and NCO corps for their forces. You cannot overestimate how much that latent professionalism combined with their iron determination and desperation became a force multiplier.

Something else. People might consider this culturally chauvinistic, but European civilization  produces, or at least it produced then, organized efficient bureaucratic and corporate-minded organizational people who thought, acted, and worked as cohesive units.

Arab culture then, and I'm not sure it isn't true now, wasn't capable of that.

Israelis knew enough to pull basic equipment maintenance and drill themselves until their arms fell off..

That accounts for maybe half of why they were so effective.

The rest of it may have just been sheer grit.

Herald

 
Quote    Reply
1 2 3 4   NEXT



 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics