Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Armed Forces of the World Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Your Dream War Movie
jastayme3    8/26/2007 5:21:04 PM
Why not? No one is satisfied with the selection available. So work off your frustration: give the title and plot summary of your dream war movie.
 
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Pages: PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11   NEXT
Nichevo    Age of Sail   8/31/2007 7:09:09 PM
Any of a zillion naval actions during the French Revolution/Napoleonic Era.  Glorious First of June - St. Vincent - Trafalgar - Algeciras - etc., etc., etc.  Just film more Patrick O'Brian (or CS Forester) books.  Or do a Rise & Fall of Napoleon and How The RN Made it Happen.  Yeah, though a Napoleon pic would feel the need to focus on land warfare.  Snore!
 
Quote    Reply

Nichevo    Age of Sail   8/31/2007 7:10:42 PM

A decent Anglo-Boer War movie with a Boer General like de la Rey in the main role.  Or von Lettow-Vorbeck's campaign against the British Empire in Africa with said general in the main role.  Both epic stories that would play out well on the big screen.  How someone like Lawrence of Arabia gets a decent film whilst those gentlemen don't is beyond me.


Because, regrettably, it's just not important who lives or dies or wins or loses in Africa, and even more sadly, it is in the ME.
 
Quote    Reply

Hugo       9/1/2007 3:59:41 AM




A decent Anglo-Boer War movie with a Boer General like de la Rey in the main role.  Or von Lettow-Vorbeck's campaign against the British Empire in Africa with said general in the main role.  Both epic stories that would play out well on the big screen.  How someone like Lawrence of Arabia gets a decent film whilst those gentlemen don't is beyond me.




Because, regrettably, it's just not important who lives or dies or wins or loses in Africa, and even more sadly, it is in the ME.

It's not that I don't think Lawrence deserved his story to be told, I just think there are more interesting stories.  De la Rey deserves his own epic.
 
Quote    Reply

Carl D.       9/16/2007 9:53:08 PM
Well it looks like the Poles are taking the matter of a Battle of Vienna film into their own hands...http://www.thenews.pl/archives/1207-Gibson,-De-Niro-in-Polish-big-budget-film-project.html

Gibson, De Niro in Polish big budget film project?

Created: Friday, September 14. 2007

The most expensive ever big-budget movie is about to be made in Poland. “Victoria” retells the story of the Polish victory in the 1683 Battle of Vienna. Possible highlights include Hollywood cast and “Lord of the Rings” special effects crew.

The budget for the movie is to be 200 million zloty (50 million euro).

The ambitious plans for the project include asking Mel Gibson to direct and play the part of king Sobieski for 20 million dollars, casting Robert De Niro, as well as getting the famous “Lord of the Ring” crew to create special effects.

The first ever film fund in Poland is being created by Mariusz A. Bialek, producer of “Victoria”. Investors will buy shares and make profit when, or rather if, the film starts to gross money.

Such funds have been successful abroad.

“A film fund would definitely prove an interesting change for investors, especially in a time of prolonged corrections of the stock market. Films can be a highly profitable investment, but a risky one as well”, Mateusz Walczak, President of New World Alternative Investments told Puls Biznesu.

The fund will be open so anyone will be able to buy shares. “The price per share has not yet been established”, says Bialek, who will pay for the film with his own money.

He first got interested in making the movie after the 9/11 attacks. “The associations seemed obvious. Here was another clash of two religious worlds. 11 September 1683 Muslim fighters were also at the heart of Western civilization. And then too the Western world united”, recounts Bialek.

The work on “Victoria” started 3 years ago when Bialek asked scriptwriter Cezary Harasimowicz to write the script.

Getting such stars as Mel Gibson involved are optimistic, however, as his diary is full for the next six years.



 
Quote    Reply

BasinBictory       9/17/2007 1:20:04 AM

Red Storm Rising.  I don't think one movie would be enough, but one can dream.

 

I'd also love to see an Alien invasion movie with more military action and less bs.  I loved the hill scene in War of the Worlds, and I'd love to see a movie with more of that.



Hell yeah! I'd love to see a good adaptation of Red Storm Rising! I feel that that book was Clancy's masterpiece, because the characters are believeable, and didn't include the superhuman feats of Jack Ryan.
 
There has been a movie about the Winter War between Finland and the USSR. It was called, not surprisingly, "The Winter War" (I cannot recall the Finnish name for it) but I thought it was a very good movie. The Soviet uniforms and tanks look period-correct for the Winter of 1939.
 
I would love to see a movie made about the Battle of Chalons in 451 A.D. The legions of Flavius Aetius against the Hunnish Horde of Attila. Until that battle, Attila's forces rode nearly unopposed across Gaul, laying waste to nearly everything they passed. Their depravities were such that they were viewed as almost an evil force of nature rather than a mere invading army. A movie based on the book "Sword of Attila" would be nice, historical accuracy aside.
 
Quote    Reply

BasinBictory       9/17/2007 1:39:14 AM
Some other war movie ideas I'd love to see brought to screen:
 
* A movie based on the book "The Guns of August" This was Barbara Tuchman's book about the opening days of WW1. It was fascinating reading, and in the early months of the war, neither side had quite caught on to the concept of trench warfare yet, so casualties were horrendous as generals sent their men into battle against machine guns for pretty much the first time.
 
* A Vietnam or Korean war movie told from the perspective of the South Vietnamese or the South Koreans. I realize that "Tae Guk Gi" is a SK war movie, but would like to see others. Most war movies feature Americans only.
 
* More movies about the Great War. Maybe the exploits of General Lettow-Vorbeck in Africa would be a good adventure.
 
* A movie made about Napoleon's invasion of Russia.
 
* A movie made about the Falklands War
 
* A movie made about the Punic Wars
 
* A movie about the Sack of Constantinople by the Ottoman Turks
 
Quote    Reply

Bob Roberts       9/25/2007 12:58:09 PM
Sorry about bringing up an old post but I just had to put my two cents in on this subject.   I too have always felt that a accurate telling of the Battle off Samar during the Leyte campaign would be awesome.  A good WW I movie would be great perhaps all quiet on the western front but with German actors and obviously in the German language; additionally something covering Verdun would be really interesting I don't think there has ever been anything as close to hell on earth as that battle was.  I'd really like to see a movie that took place during the Philippine-American war, a subject that has in few formats much less film.
 
Quote    Reply

Heorot    Rakossy   9/25/2007 2:34:38 PM

Rakossy by Cecelia Holland would make a great movie. And the story would resonate with current times. This is a review from Amazon that describes the book: It describes my opinion better than I could.

 

RAKOSSY was written in 1967 and, intentionally or not, Cecelia Holland presaged the current Christian-Muslim conflict by 30 years. Or perhaps instead, that conflict has never really ended and Ms. Holland had merely coincidentally selected a slice of history ripe for story-telling. Anyway, in RAKOSSY we have Muslims invading Europe, which some think is dangerously close to happening now in a non-military style immigration-political takeover of Christian democratic Europe. Rakossy is the name of a small-time Hungarian border baron on the frontier with the Turkish empire, who decides, in 1525, to defend his castle against a Turkish invasion. Baron Rakossy is a rational man and therefore a modern man, putting aside all other considerations but what is logical and necessary for survival. Rakossy's character is contrasted with his brother, Denis, an efeminate, poetic soul, a lover and not a fighter -- Rakossy's opposite. The Turks are led by the wily Mustafa, the Sultan's commander. This is the second novel of Ms. Holland's, her first being THE FIREDRAKE. I have read RAKOSSY maybe a half dozen times and it never gets old. Unfortunately, this book is currently out of print but can be found in the used book market or at the library. A very entertaining and well-written novel in the terse, crisp style Ms. Holland is known for, RAKOSSY is highly recommended for all fiction lovers, not just historical novel fans. I still think THE FIREDRAKE is her best book but I keep re-reading RAKOSSY, which should tell me something.


 
Quote    Reply

Covey       9/26/2007 11:52:51 PM

Something like Independence Day or Mars Attacks, but with serious military action focus and showing the resistance of the whole world not just the US.

An author by the name of Harry Turtledove has a series of books that falls right into this.  Earth invaded by Aliens during WW2, but thinking we still wear armor and carry swords.  Recon was a bit old do to speed of light etc.

 
Quote    Reply

jastayme3       9/28/2007 2:36:52 AM

"Thirty-one knots"-the career of Adm Arleigh Burke.

 
Quote    Reply
PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11   NEXT



 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics