Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Armed Forces of the World
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
Turkey vs. Greece who better?
Irish Emo dudes
1/4/2007 7:32:39 PM
Greece spends 7 billion on their military and has american weapondry turkey spends 12 billion and also has american weapondry both used f-16's but turkey has ordered 100 f-35's not sure what greece is getting i think eurofighters...whose better militarily and who would win in a war (two different questions) and another thing i would like to know who is better trained?
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
Pages:
PREV
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
NEXT
Godofgamblers
3/27/2007 11:45:47 PM
OK I heard enough. First of all for those of you who think one side will surprise the other you are gravely mistaken. Both sides have spies and radar that will pickup any planes or ships leaving Turkey or Greece. Both military are in the process of replacing alot of their 1960s equipment. So one side just doesn't have the firepower to completely overrun the other. Further Turkey cannot commit all their forces to their boarders with Greece. Every boarder Turkey has is hostile.
It wouldn't surprise me if their old friends the Kurds wouldn't take advantage of this opportunity. Also do you guys know what the terrain is like in Northern Greece. During the winter most of those areas are hard to drive through and so you cannot afford the war to last very long. How are you going to support your troops. So lets say Turkey takes the islands. Again how to you plan to support them. Turkey doesn't have the naval power and again the greeks will know they are coming. The Greek force in the North is all armored divisions that just need to hold turkey from advancing. Again army sidze and equipment won't matter because the terrain doesn't give you the advantage. You can have a billion troops and you would still have to march single file. I hope I didn't spoil everyones brain storming
Good post... I could respond with a quote from Clausewitz :
"
If you entrench yourself behind strong fortifications, you compel the enemy seek a solution elsewhere.",
but your post is basically true, a reality check.
However, I could add that in our times, war is no longer about the complete destruction of the enemy's army (as in Napoleon's time) or of a mustering of countries' economies and war potential against each other (as in WWI and II) but nowadays, we are more likely to see a conflict between two countries fought out by small groups of special forces troops or a small number of regular troops, not for conquest of a country but for an island or small piece of territory.
Occupation is no longer the ultimate objective since the world community would not stand for it (in the case of European countries bound by various treaties) and simply because the occupation would be too costly in any Risk/Reward scenario.
As a result, I think it is possible to reflect upon the capabilities of Greece and Turkey in a conflict (not an out and out WWII style combat). In such a scenario,
air lift, special forces capability, reach of air and naval forces
, would be the determining factors.
Power Projection, political will and military tech
are thus the key factors in a small, local conflict which would be of
limited duration
(because of RoI --- a long battle would obviate whatever military gains could be had),
high tech
(both sides would attempt to use superior tech to gain and exploit an edge) and
diplomatic
, i.e. it would be fought as much in boardrooms (seeking political capital, approbation and legitimation and to 'spin' a victory) as on the battlefield.
So a war is still possible:)
Quote
Reply
kane
3/28/2007 11:56:18 AM
Ok we're in the 21 th century and it's too bad that the people who are non-Turk still think the same way about Turks
Look guys Turks are not Arabs
Not all the Turks are Muslims----Turk=/=Muslim
90%of the pop is Muslim-but Turkry is
secular
Well more secular than Israel
BTW no Muslim country will help Turkey because they think we are aganist Islam
Kane, no disrespect intended whatsoever, but what would you consider yourself? For example, people in Europe are European, people in the US/Canada could be considered North American, etc. The Europeans don't want you, the Muslims can't stand you, so what are you guys?
By the way, I am pro-Turkey.
We are Turkish :)
Actually there are plenty other countries that we can make alliance with .........central asian Turkic republics ....these are Azerbeycan,Turkmenistan,Kazakistan,Kirgizistan and Sinkiang(Uygurs in China)
These Central Asian countries has good amount of resources and oil
And Iran would be a good choice too if they weren't in trouble
But I always support being with Europe,wish they weren't two-faced but those guys are still same just like 500 years ago
Quote
Reply
kane
3/28/2007 12:01:03 PM
OK I heard enough. First of all for those of you who think one side will surprise the other you are gravely mistaken. Both sides have spies and radar that will pickup any planes or ships leaving Turkey or Greece. Both military are in the process of replacing alot of their 1960s equipment. So one side just doesn't have the firepower to completely overrun the other. Further Turkey cannot commit all their forces to their boarders with Greece. Every boarder Turkey has is hostile.
It wouldn't surprise me if their old friends the Kurds wouldn't take advantage of this opportunity. Also do you guys know what the terrain is like in Northern Greece. During the winter most of those areas are hard to drive through and so you cannot afford the war to last very long. How are you going to support your troops. So lets say Turkey takes the islands. Again how to you plan to support them. Turkey doesn't have the naval power and again the greeks will know they are coming. The Greek force in the North is all armored divisions that just need to hold turkey from advancing. Again army sidze and equipment won't matter because the terrain doesn't give you the advantage. You can have a billion troops and you would still have to march single file. I hope I didn't spoil everyones brain storming
Yeah thats if we invade Greece,same for you if you invade us
This is not Persian army.....you're saying mountains are advantage.Turkish troops have been fighting with terrorists in BIGGER mountains since 1980s and our army is one of the most experienced(actually the most) army in guerilla/mountain fighting
About the islands?Well some of those islands are like 200 meters away from mainland, I can see them with my eyes....don't forget how you got those islands :)
Italians loaned it from us,then war broke and they took over them and then gave them to you
Quote
Reply
GOP
3/28/2007 8:50:25 PM
Turkish troops have been fighting with terrorists in BIGGER mountains since 1980s and our army is one of the most experienced(actually the most) army in guerilla/mountain fighting
Time to put the nationalistic bs aside. The Indian and Pakistani militaries are by far the most experienced forces in the world in mountain fighting, and some countries (look at Sri Lanka and some countries in Africa) have been fighting guerillas a whole lot more than you guys. Look kane, the only difference between you and the Muslim extremists is where your allegiance lies. It is very dangerous to buy into everything your country says dude, every country has problems. Nationalism can be a dangerous thing (check out the CCP and the Chinese people)
Quote
Reply
kane
3/29/2007 4:46:45 AM
Turkish troops have been fighting with terrorists in BIGGER mountains since 1980s and our army is one of the most experienced(actually the most) army in guerilla/mountain fighting
Time to put the nationalistic bs aside. The Indian and Pakistani militaries are by far the most experienced forces in the world in mountain fighting, and some countries (look at Sri Lanka and some countries in Africa) have been fighting guerillas a whole lot more than you guys. Look kane, the only difference between you and the Muslim extremists is where your allegiance lies. It is very dangerous to buy into everything your country says dude, every country has problems. Nationalism can be a dangerous thing (check out the CCP and the Chinese people)
It's not nationalism........I just told some facts,they may not be the best but faar more experienced than Greeks.Actually Greeks didn't get into any fight since WW2 and well.......they had conflict with us in Cyprus
I do know nationalism can be dangeorus,same goes for you....I've followed many of your posts and I can say you're a nationalist too
And well I'm actually a little on the left and a patriot and I love my races history.I'm not a 100% Turk myself, almost everybody living on Anatolian soil is a mixture of countless ethnicities
Quote
Reply
kane
GOP
3/29/2007 4:49:25 AM
and allegiance to what?
Quote
Reply
GOP
3/29/2007 4:48:12 PM
and allegiance to what?
Turkey.
Quote
Reply
kane
3/29/2007 5:44:21 PM
and allegiance to what?
Turkey.
um.....no thats not our ONLY difference from those Muslim extremists
Quote
Reply
GOP
3/30/2007 3:22:19 AM
and allegiance to what?
Turkey.
um.....no thats not our ONLY difference from those Muslim extremists
No Kane, my point was that your allegiance to Turkey is as strong as the extremists allegiance to jihad. OK, look at the nationalism in your posts. You say Turkey is the most experienced military in the world at mountain fighting...yet Pakistan and India have had full scale wars in the mountains before and have had almost daily scuffles up there for a good 25 years or so. You say that country is the most experienced at guerilla warfare, yet countries like Sri Lanka have been involved in full scale guerilla war for years now. Before you start making crazy claims, take a look at the facts and see if you have a legit point, or if you are just speaking nationalistic bs.
Quote
Reply
kane
3/30/2007 5:25:38 AM
and allegiance to what?
Turkey.
um.....no thats not our ONLY difference from those Muslim extremists
No Kane, my point was that your allegiance to Turkey is as strong as the extremists allegiance to jihad. OK, look at the nationalism in your posts. You say Turkey is the most experienced military in the world at mountain fighting...yet Pakistan and India have had full scale wars in the mountains before and have had almost daily scuffles up there for a good 25 years or so. You say that country is the most experienced at guerilla warfare, yet countries like Sri Lanka have been involved in full scale guerilla war for years now. Before you start making crazy claims, take a look at the facts and see if you have a legit point, or if you are just speaking nationalistic bs.
Turkish troops have been fighting in this guerilla/mountain style for about 27 years
How can you prove that Sri Lanka and Pakistani/Indian troops are better than us?I can not prove you that we are better either.
I'm just saying that our soldiers are among the top guys
Yes I'm a nationalist but I know the capabilities of Turkish army
What we lack?
We can't produce our own fighter
Our economy is not independant
We don't have our own assault rifle(we got the licence of M-4 and G3 thats what we produce)
We don't have our own MBT(it'll be ready in 2012)
We don't have long range missiles
And we do not use nuclear energy(Thats why our effect on global warming is 0.9% and USA is about 25%
Anyway you're a nationalist too and your claims are not supported
The years are similar,PKK began it's assaults from Northern Iraq and Southeast Turkey in 1980s
After first gulf war they gathered tens of thousands men,in 1994 they were sacked from Turkish hakkari region(mountains and northern Iraq(secret operation in Iraq))
After the 2.gulf war thank to USA they gathered more men and began attacking civillians again
Quote
Reply
PREV
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
NEXT
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
MURPHY'S LAW: All-Seeing, All Deceiving
SPACE: Russia Lost in Space
STRATEGIC WEAPONS: Sentinel Replacing Minuteman
MURPHY'S LAW: Ukraine War Revelations
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine Maximizes and Militarizes Competition
RUSSIA: Sabotage, Incompetence and Corruption in Russia
WARPLANES: Russian Stealth Fighter Survives
LOGISTICS: Successfully Surviving Sanctions
WINNING: Black Sea Battles
ATTRITION: What Russia Has Lost
LOGISTICS: EU Hits and Misses
SURFACE FORCES : South Korean Frigates
WARPLANES: T7 Turns into F7
ISRAEL: Israel Dismantles Hamas
MALI: Mali Menaced by Terrorists
SURFACE FORCES : New Norwegian Coast Guard Ships
SUBMARINES: SSGN Sunsets
LIBYA: Libya Gets Busy
YEMEN: Yemen the Unyielding
SURFACE FORCES : Karakurt-Class Corvettes
INDIA-PAKISTAN: India-Pakistan Debts and Rebels
LOGISTICS: France Mobilizes Industry for War
CONGO: Congo and Central Africa Continue to Struggle
LOGISTICS: Finding a More Suitable Ride
WINNING: Tunnel Warfare Troops and Techniques
ELECTRONIC WEAPONS: Listening in on the Enemy
IRAQ: Iraq the Threatened Neighbor
ARMOR: The Universal Tank Vulnerability
SYRIA: Syria Sort of Survives
AIR DEFENSE: Arrow Makes First Combat Intercept
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
Armor: Novel German Anti-Tank Mines for Ukraine
Forces: Taiwanese Military Personnel Come to America
Procurement: Ukraine 2024 Aid from NATO Announced
Weapons: Ukraine Creates a Killer Robot
WARS Afghanistan: Lost in Afghanistan
Artillery: Archer, Counterbattery and UAVs
Logistics: Economic Casualties of the Ukraine War
Logistics: Seeking a Munitions Supply Edge
Murphy's Law: All-Seeing, All Deceiving
Space: Russia Lost in Space
Murphy's Law: Ukraine War Revelations
Strategic Weapons: Sentinel Replacing Minuteman
WARS Russia: Sabotage, Incompetence and Corruption in Russia
WARS Israel: Israel Dismantles Hamas
Procurement: Ukraine Maximizes and Militarizes Competition
Warplanes: Russian Stealth Fighter Survives
AFGHANISTAN: Lost in Afghanistan
STRATEGIC WEAPONS: Sentinel Replacing Minuteman
SPACE: Russia Lost in Space
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine Maximizes and Militarizes Competition
MURPHY'S LAW: Ukraine War Revelations
LOGISTICS: Seeking a Munitions Supply Edge
RUSSIA: Sabotage, Incompetence and Corruption in Russia
LOGISTICS: Economic Casualties of the Ukraine War
MURPHY'S LAW: All-Seeing, All Deceiving
ARTILLERY: Archer, Counterbattery and UAVs
AFGHANISTAN: Lost in Afghanistan
WEAPONS: Ukraine Creates a Killer Robot
PROCUREMENT: Ukraine 2024 Aid from NATO Announced
FORCES: Taiwanese Military Personnel Come to America
ARMOR: Novel German Anti-Tank Mines for Ukraine
SURFACE FORCES : New Japanese Missile Frigates
PROCUREMENT: Russia Sells Iran 50 Su-35s
Afghanistan: Lost in Afghanistan
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
StrategyPage
Account Manager
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Advertise With Us
Search