by Austin Bay
July 19, 2006
How do you stop rockets fired from a hijacked state?
That's a complex question, but Israel must answer, or risk
suffering the most drastic of consequences -- its own demise.
Appreciating the thorny, multi-dimensional difficulties Israel
confronts -- from bitter house-to-house battles to the highest levels of
international diplomacy -- begins with a basic understanding of the Katyusha
rocket Hezbollah fires at Haifa and other Israeli cities.
I should say Katyusha-type, for the rocket Hezbollah employs
out-ranges Russia's World War II Katyushas and the improved models Moscow
later aimed at NATO ground units in Western Europe.
Even the updated versions are "dumb" -- unguided "barrage" or
"area weapons." The dumb-but-deadly rockets are not fired at specific
targets, unless "Haifa" and "Tel Aviv" are considered specific targets.
When fired from positions in southern Lebanon or Gaza,
extended-range Katyushas threaten anywhere from 60 to 70 percent of Israel's
population. Every Israeli citizen may soon be a bull's-eye -- Hezbollah
leaders boast of striking "beyond, beyond Haifa." Indeed, there are
indications that longer-range rockets are being employed. NATO handbooks
once referred to these rockets as "FROG-type" -- Free Rocket Over Ground.
Some can carry chemical warheads.
As range increases, these unguided rockets "scatter" over a
wider and wider surface area. In the case of northern Israel, Hezbollah is
clearly targeting predominantly civilian zones. If a rocket hits a hospital
in the civilian area, it hits a hospital. Hezbollah's attacks on Haifa --
especially compared to Israeli attacks in Gaza and Lebanon, which typically
utilize modern precision weapons -- are quite indiscriminate.
But then Hezbollah's leader, Hassan Nasrullah, and the mad
mullahs of Iran who arm, finance and guide him, believe the whole of Israel
is a target, one Iran indicates it will hit some day with another area
weapon: a city-busting nuclear warhead.
In the past week, 1,400 rockets have hit Israeli cities, most
from firing positions inside Lebanon.
But now for the layer of complexity: Hezbollah hides these
weapons among apartment houses and in villages, nesting rockets in Lebanese
Hezbollah controls these neighborhoods -- not the Lebanese
In other words, Israel suffers rocket attacks from a Lebanon
that "is not quite Lebanon" in a truly sovereign sense. The rockets, of
course, come from "somewhere," but Hezbollah's "somewhere" is a political
limbo in terms of maps with definitive geo-political boundaries. Lebanon is
a peculiar form of failed state. It's not the madhouse of Somalia or the
impoverished dreg of Zimbabwe, rather, Lebanon is a hijacked state.
Lebanon's status as a hijacked state will continue so long as
the Lebanese government cannot control Hezbollah -- and control means disarm
So Hezbollah attacks Israel with ever-more-powerful,
longer-range rockets, then hides behind the diplomatic facade of the greater
Lebanese nation state.
Iran and Syria -- the powers behind Hezbollah -- then appeal to
the United Nations (a product of the Westphalian "nation-state" system) to
condemn Israel for attacking Lebanon -- when Israel is attacking Hezbollah,
which "is and is not Lebanon."
Thus terrorists and terror-empowering nations, like Iran and
Syria, abuse the nation-state system -- or exploit a "dangerous hole" in the
Everybody's got to be somewhere, but maps and UN seats and press
bureaus don't make an effective nation state; they are the trappings of
Weaknesses in the Westphalian system exist, in part because it has never
been a complete system. (The Westphalian system evolved from the Treaty of
Westphalia (1648) and the series of peace settlements that ended the Thirty
Years' War in Europe.) Westphalia's "nation-state" system has always faced
"gaps" (anarchic regions) and "failed states" (which are often collapsing
tribal empires with the trappings of modernity, not the institutions).
Israel says disarming Hezbollah is one of its objectives. But to
truly achieve that goal -- to stop the rockets, in any permanent way --
means ending Iran's and Syria's ability to hijack Lebanese neighborhoods.
And that means holding Iran and Syria responsible for hijacking
Lebanon and supporting Hezbollah's rain of rocket terror. Holding Iran and
Syria responsible may well mean taking the war to Tehran and Damascus.