The Strategypage is a comprehensive summary of military news and affairs.
 News As History - November 23, 2009




New Strategy - Wargames at Discount Prices
1.Modern Air Power: War Over the Middle East
2.Commander: Napoleon at War
3.Close Combat: Watch am Rhein
4.Gallic Wars
5.Fast Action Battle: The Bulge

100+ Computer and Board games all with free shipping.
 
 
 
Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
United States Discussion Board
Sign In   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Guantánamo suspects want to stay, say officials
WarNerd    11/3/2009 6:37:00 AM
It was bound to happen ...
========================================
Guantánamo suspects want to stay, say officials

As President Barack Obama's deadline to close Guantánamo looms, some occupants of the notorious detention centre would rather prolong their stay than be sent to maximum security prisons on the US mainland, according to camp officials.


By Alex Spillius in Guantánamo Bay
Published: 8:46PM GMT 01 Nov 2009


Detainees in orange jumpsuits sit in a holding area under the surveillence of US military police at Camp X-Ray at Naval Base Guantanamo Bay, Cuba Photo: AFP/GETTY

Despite its reputation, the regime at the Pentagon facility on Cuba's southern coast offers privileges that would not be enjoyed at the federal "supermax" prison at Florence, Colorado, the likely alternative for the most dangerous al-Qaeda suspects.

Sensitive to criticism that the detention centre was not meeting international standards, the Pentagon has gradually improved living conditions at Guantánamo.



Adm Thomas Copeman, the commander, now confidently describes it as a "model detention facility" in terms of environment, though he refused to be drawn on the policy and legality of detentions that have lasted for nearly eight years, in most cases without trial.

Peter King, a Republican congressman who visited earlier this year and wants the prison kept open, said that "if there's any scandal at Guantánamo, it is that the detainees are treated too well".

The 221 remaining inmates receive between four and 20 hours outdoor recreation in the Caribbean sun and anything from weekly to almost unlimited access to DVDs and receive three newspapers (USA Today, plus one Egyptian and one Saudi Arabian title) twice a week. Every bed has an arrow pointing towards Mecca and every cell a prayer rug.

Adm Copeman said "generally speaking the rules are about the same" for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the self-confessed mastermind of the September 11 attacks, and the 15 other "high value detainees", who are held at Camp 7, which is out of bounds to the media.

The detainees' diet is exclusively Middle Eastern and halal, in observance of regional and religious sensitivities. Dates, olive oil and honey are provided daily and pita bread is baked on the premises. They drink the same bottled water as the prison's staff and have the same access as other prisoners to 16,000 books and 1,600 magazines held at the library.

An escorted tour of Guantánamo by the Daily Telegraph revealed that Camp 7's requested reading included Gardens of the World by Mick Hales, Fine Art Flower Photography by Tony Sweet and a copy of Birds and Blooms magazine, material in keeping with nature-bound leisure pursuits approved by conservative Islam. Two volumes of the Tales of the Arabian Nights were also in the pile. Tomes on Islamic theory are in plentiful supply and demand, said library staff.

At the low security Camp 4, detainees could be seen sitting in the yard chatting and hanging up their laundry. A new gravel football field was recently completed.

At Florence, Colorado, prisoners would also spend 22 ½ hours a day in a 9ft by 9ft cell with the only natural light coming from a skylight outside.

Exercise would be limited to an hour and a half indoors five days a week and they would have minimal contact with others, including the 33 other international terrorists held there. An official study found that most inmates suffer psychological trauma from the severe isolation.

Since 2005 an Arab American cultural adviser, who for security reasons is identified only by the name of Zak, has been employed at Guantánamo to liaise with detainees.

He said that some detainees would rather stay put than go on trial in the US, where they would probably receive a life sentence or could wait years for a death sentence to be carried out.

"They know there will not be the same privileges as here," he said. "Given the choice of being sentenced forever in Guantánamo or moved to supermax, it is 'no, can I stay in Gitmo?'. Here they can be outside, they can smell the sea."

Camp guards and senior officers said similar feedback had been received from detainees fearing a tougher life in US jails or back home. The claims could not be independently verified as the Pentagon does not allow journalists to interview detainees, while lawyers for several prisoners did not return requests for comment.

Controversy does still surrounds the centre. Detainees' lawyers make repeated complaints about mental illness and force-feeding of hunger strikers, while earlier this year the prison suffered its fifth prisoner suicide. Adm Copeland described a "psychological battleground" where detainees regularly spit at guards or fling faeces and urine.

In May, ethnic Uighur Chinese detainees embarrassed officials by staging a protest in front of visiting reporters, waving art pads asking if Mr Obama was a "communist or a Democrat".

Despite being cleared for release in 2003, destinations have not been found for most of the Uighurs. Washington refuses to send them and other nationals to home countries where they may face persecution.

The debate now is much less about conditions than a deeply troubled legal process that has prosecuted only three detainees in nearly eight years.

Eric Holder, the US attorney general, is struggling to meet the president's promised Jan 22 closing date. He is expected to refer at least 40 prisoners for transfer to trial in US courts some time next year and to refer the majority for transfer overseas, however difficult that continues to prove.



link

TelegraphNews

© Copyright of Telegraph Media Group Limited
 
Quote    Reply

Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Sort in Reverse Order Posted

WarNerd    the link   11/3/2009 6:38:46 AM
link
 
Quote    Reply

sentinel28a       11/3/2009 3:01:51 PM
Don't blame 'em.  Gitmo isn't exactly a tropical paradise, but at least you get to see the sky.  Supermax...not so much.
 
I heard a few of them might be sent to my home state of Montana.  They can't like that idea either...not when the locals are saying "We hope they try to escape."
 
 
Quote    Reply

Ispose    Gitmo was a mistake   11/3/2009 3:56:44 PM
Holding the prisoners at Gitmo was a mistake. Going in we should have given them the status accorded Prisoners of War...they are locked up until the war is over....or, also in accordance to the Geneva convention, since they were captured bearing arms while dressed a civilians they should have been immediately shot.
Treating them as criminals and prosecuting them is the stupidest thing we could have done.
 
Quote    Reply

buzzard       11/3/2009 4:57:49 PM
Actually the idea of putting them in Gitmo was effectively a prisoner of war plan, but with the careful acknowledgment that they did not properly deserve prisoner of war status and could be more vigorously interrogated. I am reasonably certain that the Bush administration expected that like prisoners of war, they would be incarcerated for the duration.
 
However, the intercessions of rabid leftists botched that plan by fighting it to death in the courts. Then the Supremes in a fit of national self immolation(as well as insane mis-interpretation of the constitution) decided that granting legal status to people who should have be shot by any reasonable laws of war was a good idea. How the Supremes got the loony notion that prisoners of war (and that's a charitable granting) deserve to be treated with the due process reserved for domestic criminal offenses blows my mind. Good lord think of the fifth column we could have had during WW II if we had idiots like that on the Supreme Court at the time. In fact there was a precedent set vis a vis enemy combatants at the time which was pretty much ignored in the recent decisions.
 
Honestly every leftist who bitched, moaned and whined about Gitmo should have been shipped off to the front line to appreciate how those people operate. We were overly merciful, as is our nature (and not something to be ashamed of), but as usual the left exploited a virtue as a weakness and did the worst possible thing with it.
 
Quote    Reply



StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2009StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy