Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Fighters, Bombers and Recon Discussion Board
Sign In   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Rafale F3 leading Brazilian F-X race on the promise of extensive tech transfer over Super Hornet
SlowMan    8/4/2009 3:43:03 PM
< link > Contenders Rafale F3 : $130 million per plane + extensive tech transfer Super Hornet : $90 million per plane, weapons and support + will buy some parts from Brazilian suppliers. Gripen NG : $60 million per plane. Will build half of NGs in Brazil. Rafale F3 is favored over Super Hornet because of the promise of an extensive tech transfer.
 
Quote    Reply

Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest

Pages: PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39   NEXT
SlowMan       9/10/2009 10:45:49 AM
@ sentinel28a

> Mainly because France is giving away the farm on this one.

Desperate people take drastic actions.

@ Rufus

> once again it becomes obvious that if the Rafale is able to win it will only be because of politics, not capabilities.

Most international arms trade is like that.

>  it is possible the Brazilian defense establishment will try to fight this decision to avoid equipping their airforce with an inferior jet

And not get the tech and nuclear subs?
 
Quote    Reply

SlowMan       9/10/2009 10:53:29 AM
@ gf0012-aust

> yes genius, read it again.  or do you struggle to comprehend the written word.

And you seem to struggle to read people's intentions from the picture.

> what relationship does the photo have to the fact I stated.

You stated that F-22 wasn't noisy enough to violate local EPA rule. Kedena residents strongly disagree based on the posted picture of protest.

> and the aircraft were banned when and where under what local statute?  they haven't.

They did. Except that USAF and the higher ups in Japanese government decided to ignore it.

>  its a public debate that has not turned into anything formal

Actually the resolution was passed unanimously.

> and 3 others who have no NATO affiliation at all.

Israel and Singapore aren't JSF partners, but Security Cooperative Participants. JSF was basically a program to develop a new NATO standard fighter like F-16 before it. Accordingly it addresses the needs of NATO members, not that of countries in high security threat region.

> SHornet is not being wound down.

US Navy doesn't want more of it and is cutting down purchases. There are some in Washington DC who want USAF to adopt Super Hornet to fill the fighter gap, we will see.

But the firm orders for Super Hornet is being depleted rapidly.

> as backdoor enquiries from other countries.

Such as?

@ Phaid

> Lula's announcement was based on the agreements reached in the discussions with Sarkozy.  But this was only the first step.

Yes, but the backing of Brazilian president makes it difficult for the defense minister to overturn his boss's preference.

> So, basically, none of the French promises are really concrete at all, and neither Dassault, SAAB, nor Boeing have made their Best And Final Offers.

I am pretty sure Boeing and Saab's bid doesn't include nuclear subs. French package does.

@ Bluewings12

> Besides , why Brazil should buy a lesser plane by choosing the Super Hornet ???

Because the package is more comprehensive.

I agree Rafale F3 is a lesser plane than Super Hornet is. However, the carrot of full tech transfer and nuclear sub dangling in front was just too much for Brazil to pass.

 
Quote    Reply

Bluewings12       9/10/2009 12:02:54 PM
SlowMan :
""I agree Rafale F3 is a lesser plane than Super Hornet is""
 
Actually , I meant the opposite .
 
The Brazilian deal is in fact (in total) worth $17.1 billion .
- Euro 5.5 billion for the Rafales without weaponry (1 more billion for the weapons)
- Euro 1.85 billion for 50 Eurocopters
- Euro 4.9 billion for 4 Scorpenes and a nuclear attack sub
 
Then , there is also the related and needed infrastructures and the Tech transfert . Dassault will build the first 6 Rafales in France and the others will be sent in kit to the Brazilian assembly line . Not a single screw or bolt will be built in Brazil .
 
The most important part is not the deal in itself but the new long term cooperation in between France and Brazil .
 
Cheers .

 
Quote    Reply

french stratege       9/10/2009 12:52:06 PM
Rufus
Even the famous pro Eurofighter biased study from British DERA (with underestimates on mica or Rafale performance) put Rafale F3 with PESA above F18 and SU35).
Now we offer Rafale F3+AESA.
Game over on performance vs F18E.
F18E will be similar to Rafale only on radar and combat autonomy and inferior for rest.
Our offer to brasil is much more expensive than US one but we offer opportunity to Brasil to become a nation free on pressure from major weapons suppliers.
Of course a part of brasilian army is not in favor of Rafale since Brasilian military will have to pay price difference on their budget (so less for the rest).
But if Brasil want to be a major diplomatic player in the world with an autonomous defense, they have no choice unless US make a better offer and respect it.
 
Now Rufus I offered to some US SP members to meet them when I was in USA months ago to prove them who I'am.You would have been clearly surprised.You are clearly uninformed.
 
 
Quote    Reply

french stratege       9/10/2009 12:58:00 PM
"Dassault will build the first 6 Rafales in France and the others will be sent in kit to the Brazilian assembly line . Not a single screw or bolt will be built in Brazil .
"
It is false Bluewing
We offer Brasil to coproduce the Rafale including on some high tech components according to number they buy, and likely full access to drawing and software except some very specific secrets.
However it is obvious that code would be modified with them in order to not give away some France specific features likley on ECM and ECCM.I don't know any nation in world which give all the same source code for export for such systems.
It is a strategic partnership which will remove US dependance of Brasil.
Likely we will make such an offer to India
 
Quote    Reply

french stratege       9/10/2009 12:59:46 PM
It is a deal on the same magnitude that France had with Israel or USSR with China in the sixties.
 
Quote    Reply

SlowMan       9/10/2009 2:26:58 PM
< link >
 
According to AFP, Brazilian president received a letter signed by Sarkozy guaranteeing unrestricted tech transfer, and this was the final nail that closed the deal.
 
The US countered by announcing that US would transfer technology necessary for local production of Super Hornet, meaning just airframe fabrication and assembly tech and not AESA radar or avionics.
 

 
Quote    Reply

sentinel28a       9/10/2009 2:33:06 PM
FS, Brazil doesn't depend on the US for hardly anything in its armed forces.  Most of its Army equipment is either home-grown or French; most of its naval equipment is European, and only a third of the air force uses American equipment (the C-130, KC-707 conversions, and F-5s)--everything else is either French or made by EMBRAER.  The Rafale will likely replace the F-5, since the Mirage III was already replaced by the Mirage 2000.
 
And as usual, Bluewings, you can stop the mental masturbation over the Rafale anytime.  Can the F3 lase its own bombs?  Because earlier Rafales couldn't.  The Super Hornet could from the moment it rolled out of the factory.  With suitable improvement, the Rafale would be the equal of a Super Bug, but not as it sits now and certainly not as it was rolled out.
 
Good heavens, French guys! Your pet aircraft finally got a good contract!  Be happy with that.
 
Quote    Reply

Rufus       9/10/2009 3:33:55 PM
"FS, Brazil doesn't depend on the US for hardly anything in its armed forces.  Most of its Army equipment is either home-grown or French; most of its naval equipment is European, and only a third of the air force uses American equipment (the C-130, KC-707 conversions, and F-5s)--everything else is either French or made by EMBRAER.  The Rafale will likely replace the F-5, since the Mirage III was already replaced by the Mirage 2000."
 
 
Something one would think a self proclaimed expert would already know...
 

 
Quote    Reply

Bluewings12       9/10/2009 3:44:47 PM
sentinel :
""And as usual, Bluewings, you can stop the mental masturbation over the Rafale anytime.""
 
Uh ? Maybe it is you who should inform yourself ...
 
""With suitable improvement, the Rafale would be the equal of a Super Bug""
 
??? excuse me but the Rafale won on technical every evaluation and competition it did enter . That goes for South-Korea , Singapore , Switzerland and Brazil . Tell me , how often the SH was dropped first or second ? So ?..
 
Are the foreign armed forces overestimating the Rafale  when they flew it or are the internet posters underestimating the aircraft ? Pick your choice ...
 
FS , could you please find an official paper who proves your saying regarding who will build the aircraft , thank you .
 
Cheers .
 
Quote    Reply



StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2012StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy