Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Commandos and Special Operations
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
Difference between CT teams and SWAT
bravoss
1/31/2007 2:03:24 PM
whats the difference between swat teams such as for example LAPD SWAT or german SEK and counter terrorist units such as GSG-9 or FBI HOSTAGE RESCUE TEAM. i know the SWAT teams and SEK operate state wide and GSG-9 and HRT operate country wide. is there a difference in their roles,i mean there must be because if there wasnt there wouldnt be a need for both units. is it that the CT units engage high risk missions such and SWAT teams are more of a unit for arresting criminals and doing some minor risk hostage rescues ? if someone knows,please explain. and also is there a big difference between the training. i'm also a bit confused because GSG-9 is taking part in SWAT world contest and it is not the SWAT team. thank you.
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
Pages:
1
2
3
NEXT
bravoss
1/31/2007 2:05:04 PM
sorry for grammar errors, i was in hurry.
Quote
Reply
longrifle
1/31/2007 7:19:19 PM
City/county SWAT teams function within their jurisdiction. Whether the perp does or doesn't have a hostage is irrelevant when he's violated state law and not federal law. You wouldn't call FBI HRT (assuming they were even close by) because some cranker beat his wife and then barricaded himself in his house and refused to come out. That's a local issue.
SWAT also operates in a permissive environment (for the most part).
Quote
Reply
bravoss
2/1/2007 10:15:12 AM
thanks mate. i thought similar. so counter terrorist teams have harder and more rigorous training than swat,right?
Quote
Reply
longrifle
2/1/2007 2:15:10 PM
Federal agenies and the military have a much more rigerous training and selection progarm than most SWAT teams. There might be a few exeptions - full time teams like Los Angeles - but most part time SWAT teams couldn't hope to approach the proficiecy levels of FBI HRT, Delta, etc.
It's just common sense. Most SWAT members are patrol officers first and get to train for SWAT about eight hours a month. Most teams have the best patrol officers in their departments - men who stay in shape, shoot on their own, and are motivated - no doughnut cops, etc.
We have a rigerous PT test twice a year and make the most of our training time each month, but eight hours is only eight hours no matter what. Thankfully the average nationwide SWAT sniper shooting a couple of years ago was estimated at 51 yards. Basically, across the street. The longest recorded was 187 yards. We're not Delta and don't claim to be. Fortunately we usually don't have to be.
Quote
Reply
GOP
2/1/2007 2:30:33 PM
Federal agenies and the military have a much more rigerous training and selection progarm than most SWAT teams. There might be a few exeptions - full time teams like Los Angeles - but most part time SWAT teams couldn't hope to approach the proficiecy levels of FBI HRT, Delta, etc.
It's just common sense. Most SWAT members are patrol officers first and get to train for SWAT about eight hours a month. Most teams have the best patrol officers in their departments - men who stay in shape, shoot on their own, and are motivated - no doughnut cops, etc.
We have a rigerous PT test twice a year and make the most of our training time each month, but eight hours is only eight hours no matter what. Thankfully the average nationwide SWAT sniper shooting a couple of years ago was estimated at 51 yards. Basically, across the street. The longest recorded was 187 yards. We're not Delta and don't claim to be. Fortunately we usually don't have to be.
Wow, only 8 hours a month? Is that enough to even retain your skills? Not knocking you guys whatsoever, I just thought it was more like 16-20 hours a month. Yeah, most SWAT teams can't even compete on anywhere near the same level as Delta/ST6/HRT/GSG-9/etc because the Tier 1 guys train constantly, full time; have a huge budget to run high end training exercises; work with each other often and master certain entry techniques, etc; get top of the line gear; etc.
Just curious. I've been watching the "Dallas SWAT" and "Detroit SWAT" shows on TV, and they never handle any bank robberies/hostage situations. So who would handle hostage situations (like at a a bank, etc)...would the FBI SWAT team come in, or the local team, or would a FBI HRT unit come in?
Quote
Reply
longrifle
2/1/2007 3:17:38 PM
GOP,
The prognosis isn't quite as bleak as you think. Everybody usually gets a 40 hour school each year in addition to the monthly trainings. Also consider the average callout involves one suspect.
Joe Bob gets drunk and beats his wife. Wife runs out of the house and calls 911 from the neighbors. Joe Bob refuses to come out when the cops show up. Joe Bob has guns.
The cops have patrol units and snipers on the outer perimeter. Negotiations might go on for hours. If the entry team makes an entry sometimes it will be more of a probe than a dynamic entry (situation dependent), flash bangs and gas happen, of course, but not always. So drunk out of shape Joe Bob who doesn't shoot that often might be up against one or two stacks of 4-5 cops each, not counting patrol units and snipers on the perimeter.
Seldom are shots fired. Joe Bob goes to jail.
I've never shot or been on a callout where shooting occured; just laid out there on the perimeter and watched Joe Bob walking past windows through my rifle scope.
Patrol units will be first on scene to a robbery of any kind. SWAT will respond if it isn't over before they can stage and get deployed. Depending on what's being robbed the locals could be relieved by the feds, again, if the negotiations go on and on and they can get there before it's over.
Quote
Reply
Horsesoldier
2/1/2007 4:05:51 PM
Besides the big picture issues discussed already there are also a lot of differences down at the TTP/SOP level reflecting the fact that was mentioned earlier -- SWAT usually operates in a permissive environment. Use of deadly force and rules of engagement also differ in some particulars due to the differences between law enforcement missions and military missions.
Quote
Reply
GOP
2/1/2007 4:29:04 PM
GOP,
The prognosis isn't quite as bleak as you think. Everybody usually gets a 40 hour school each year in addition to the monthly trainings. Also consider the average callout involves one suspect.
Joe Bob gets drunk and beats his wife. Wife runs out of the house and calls 911 from the neighbors. Joe Bob refuses to come out when the cops show up. Joe Bob has guns.
The cops have patrol units and snipers on the outer perimeter. Negotiations might go on for hours. If the entry team makes an entry sometimes it will be more of a probe than a dynamic entry (situation dependent), flash bangs and gas happen, of course, but not always. So drunk out of shape Joe Bob who doesn't shoot that often might be up against one or two stacks of 4-5 cops each, not counting patrol units and snipers on the perimeter.
Seldom are shots fired. Joe Bob goes to jail.
I've never shot or been on a callout where shooting occured; just laid out there on the perimeter and watched Joe Bob walking past windows through my rifle scope.
Patrol units will be first on scene to a robbery of any kind. SWAT will respond if it isn't over before they can stage and get deployed. Depending on what's being robbed the locals could be relieved by the feds, again, if the negotiations go on and on and they can get there before it's over.
I didn't mean to make it look that bad, but looking back at my post I guess I misworded alot of it. Basically, I think that the Tier 1 guys are in a league of their own, it's nothing against SWAT or any other unit. They are the best of the best, and evn the Tier 2 guys (like Army SF, the Teams, etc) can't really touch them.
LOL, Joe Bob's crises is what makes up 90% of the Dallas/Detroit SWAT shows.
So what is this "probe" entry thing? I have seen it on the TV shows listed above, but basically it kind of looks like they open a door quitely, and sneak in there before Joe Bob see's them or hears them...and they kind of point their guns at Joe Bob and say "get down" and that's it. Definitely anti-climatic for the show! I want to see them go in their like ST6/CAG, kick down doors, throw flash bangs, hit Joe Bob with their rifle butts, etc...but they just kind of knock on the door and tell Joe Bob to "get on the floor buddy"
Quote
Reply
longrifle
2/2/2007 12:14:16 AM
"So what is this "probe" entry thing?"
Less than a dynamic entry with gas and flashbangs where a good time is had by all.
Probing to contact is usually done when you don't know exactly where the suspect is in the building. One example would have a stick moving down a hallway and search teams breaking off to clear rooms.
A covert entry is similar. It usually involves peeking around corners and under doors with mirrors.
Quote
Reply
Horsesoldier
2/2/2007 8:46:05 AM
So what is this "probe" entry thing? I have seen it on the TV shows listed above, but basically it kind of looks like they open a door quitely, and sneak in there before Joe Bob see's them or hears them...and they kind of point their guns at Joe Bob and say "get down" and that's it. Definitely anti-climatic for the show! I want to see them go in their like ST6/CAG, kick down doors, throw flash bangs, hit Joe Bob with their rifle butts, etc...but they just kind of knock on the door and tell Joe Bob to "get on the floor buddy"
Bear in mind that while "violence of action" is a watchword for both LE and military DA stuff, for law enforcement there's a much higher risk of "violence of action" being interpreted somewhere as "excessive force," etc.
Also, SWAT actions most places will differ from how military special operations do things right from the get go -- most LE agencies don't do explosive entry. You'll notice on Dallas SWAT and such that those guys are really, really good at mechanical breaching, door pulls, etc. For a military special operations unit, a lot of the entries those guys do with pull hooks, etc., would be done with explosives.
Quote
Reply
1
2
3
NEXT
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
PHILIPPINES: The Plan To Stop China
PROCUREMENT: USMC Builds Their Backup System
MURPHY'S LAW: How Islam Breeds Defeat In The Air
SURFACE FORCES : Saar For The Rest Of Us
NIGERIA: The Hills Are Alive With The Sound Of Burning Churches
WINNING: Victory For The Bad Guys In Darfur
ATTRITION: The Destruction Of The Syrian Air Force
IRAQ: Holding Off The Holocaust
AIR DEFENSE: Patriot Gains A Longer Reach Against Missiles
PROCUREMENT: How Israeli Tech Gets To Eager Moslem Customers
MURPHY'S LAW: How The Generals Learned To Tolerate The Internet
YEMEN: Al Qaeda Scrambles To Survive
AFGHANISTAN: Taliban Divided On Making Peace
ISRAEL: Palestinians Inspired, Confused And Divided By Syria
MURPHY'S LAW: The Search For Politically Correct Weapons
COUNTER-TERRORISM: Why Syrian Rebels Have Their Own Internal Civil War
INFORMATION WARFARE: Data Mining Screws The Pirates
RUSSIA: The Red Army Gets Its Mojo Back
INFORMATION WARFARE: NetTraveler Joins Red October
WARPLANES: Yet More New Arrival Dates For The F-35
ARTILLERY: Caesar Gets Bulletproof, Just In Case
INDIA-PAKISTAN: Dark Days For The Generals
NAVAL AIR: U.S. Navy Ships Get a New UAV
INTELLIGENCE: How To Spot North Korean Spies
PROCUREMENT: Russia Battles Incompetent Shipyards
MURPHY'S LAW: The Chinese Edge Over South Asia
SYRIA: A Bloody Summer Guaranteed
SUDAN: Misery
NAVAL AIR: Russia Plays Catch Up
IRAN: The Sure Thing
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
Attrition: The Destruction Of The Syrian Air Force
WARS Iraq: Holding Off The Holocaust
Air Defense: Patriot Gains A Longer Reach Against Missiles
Procurement: How Israeli Tech Gets To Eager Moslem Customers
Information Warfare: Data Mining Screws The Pirates
Murphy's Law: How The Generals Learned To Tolerate The Internet
Murphy's Law: The Search For Politically Correct Weapons
WARS Russia: The Red Army Gets Its Mojo Back
WARS Yemen: Al Qaeda Scrambles To Survive
WARS Israel: Palestinians Inspired, Confused And Divided By Syria
WARS Afghanistan: Taliban Divided On Making Peace
Artillery: Caesar Gets Bulletproof, Just In Case
Warplanes: Yet More New Arrival Dates For The F-35
Counter-Terrorism: Why Syrian Rebels Have Their Own Internal Civil War
WARS India-Pakistan: Dark Days For The Generals
Information Warfare: NetTraveler Joins Red October
Naval Air: U.S. Navy Ships Get a New UAV
Intelligence: How To Spot North Korean Spies
Procurement: Russia Battles Incompetent Shipyards
Murphy's Law: The Chinese Edge Over South Asia
WARS Syria: A Bloody Summer Guaranteed
Naval Air: Russia Plays Catch Up
Intelligence: World War II LST Threatens China
NBC Weapons: New Nukes Overshadowed By Massive Retirements
WARS Iran: The Sure Thing
MURPHY'S LAW: The Search For Politically Correct Weapons
SYRIA: A Bloody Summer Guaranteed
MURPHY'S LAW: Russian Diplomats Wield Their Missiles Deftly
IRAN: The Sure Thing
IRAQ: Holding Off The Holocaust
WARPLANES: Yet More New Arrival Dates For The F-35
INTELLIGENCE: World War II LST Threatens China
SUBMARINES: American SSN Fleet Shrinks
RUSSIA: The Red Army Gets Its Mojo Back
MURPHY'S LAW: How The Generals Learned To Tolerate The Internet
ATTRITION: The Destruction Of The Syrian Air Force
NIGERIA: The Hills Are Alive With The Sound Of Burning Churches
SURFACE FORCES : Saar For The Rest Of Us
MURPHY'S LAW: How Islam Breeds Defeat In The Air
WINNING: Victory For The Bad Guys In Darfur
COUNTER-TERRORISM: Why Syrian Rebels Have Their Own Internal Civil War
ARTILLERY: Caesar Gets Bulletproof, Just In Case
INTELLIGENCE: Chinese Spies Slip Into India
INDIA-PAKISTAN: Dark Days For The Generals
PROCUREMENT: USMC Builds Their Backup System
Iraq: Holding Off The Holocaust
Procurement: USMC Builds Their Backup System
Surface Forces: Saar For The Rest Of Us
Murphy's Law in Action: How Islam Breeds Defeat In The Air
Philipines: The Plan To Stop China
Leadership: Shut Up You Whore,
Who's Winning: Victory For The Bad Guys In Darfur
Nigeria: The Hills Are Alive With The Sound Of Burning Churches
Procurement: How Israeli Tech Gets To Eager Moslem Customers
Books of Interest
Gettysburg: The Last Invasion
American Gun: A History of the U.S. in Ten Firearms
The Chinese Information War: Espionage, Cyberwar, Communications Control and Related Threats to United States Interests
The Guns at Last Light: The War in Western Europe, 1944-1945 (Liberation Trilogy)
From Amazon
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Prediction Market
Wargames
Measure of Respect
On War and Warfare
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
Military Movie Reviews
StrategyPage
Subscribe
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Account Manager
Advertise With Us
Search