Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Commandos and Special Operations Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Navy SEALs vs CAG vs SF vs Devgru vs AFSOC vs SAS vs SBS vs GSG9 vs GIGN
GOP    5/18/2006 12:08:29 AM
Who wins??? I go with NAVY SEALS! Alright, time to end all of this SOF vs SOF garbage. Basic rules: Rule 1: SOF combat divers cannot be compared with SOF CT, etc. Statements such as Navy SEALs vs SAS are impossible to compare. You must at least be comparing similar units to have a true comparison in training. Rule 2: SOF units are made up of people, which are all different and have different skill levels. SOF units are impossible to compare because each small team in a particular unit has different people which make up that small team. If we follow rule 1, and compare SOF CT Teams, then CAG may have a better small team than the SAS...and vice versa. It all varies when dealing with people. Rule 3: It is impossible for people out of the loop (ie: Civilians like me, Active or former regular military, etc) to compare current SOF units without relying on both old information, possible biased information, or just plain wrong information. Rule 4: Post like "Navy SEALs vs British SAS" will NEVER yield any conclusive evidence and will NEVER yield anything productive. Rule 5: NEVER COMPARE SOF UNITS! BOTTOM LINE. ---------------------------------------------
 
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Pages: PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7   NEXT
historynut       12/17/2007 10:49:39 AM

>>The one that shows up with a gun to a knife fight?<<

No, the one who shows up with a laser designator to a knifer fight.

Re: Jim Bowie's fight with some gentlemen in a dark warehouse. They had guns, he had a knife. They couldn't shoot for fear of hitting each other. He could stab anyone he found. Maybe it's not what you have but how you use it.
 
Quote    Reply

bob the brit       12/17/2007 9:45:33 PM




The SAS and SBS are my favorites to win because they are both trained in similar ways and both are also trained to do what other special forces wouldn't even dream of doing.The US Navy Seals and the SAS are easy to compare.....ready for it,the SAS would obviously kick their ass.




No SAS would even make it through SEAL hell week. The SEALS are tougher and in better shape physically and mentally. My brother was a SEAL. He once had three Marines back down from fighting him. SEALS are crazy mother fuckers. Don't talk about what you don't have the foggiest clue what you are talking about.


Wow, thank heavens i never crossed his path, I'd have probably wet myself. I've got a nervous twitch that happens whenever I'm scared and he would probably have wanted to hurt me because of it, but I'd have ran away, but heck, he's a SEAL, so he'd head to the nearest phone booth spin real quick and fly after me with his cape fluttering in the wind right? After all you said SEALs are like superman. And wow, only shorts and t-shirt? He must be tough! I never leave the house without having at least two sets of trousers on, a long sleeve shirt, a cardigan, and a coat, oh and my mitten too. But only shorts and T-shirt? that makes people really tough, I know. Those Marines were lucky to have escaped because your brother sounds scary and I bet he'd have really hurt them. WOW, I wish I knew your brother.
 
Quote    Reply

bob the brit       12/17/2007 9:54:35 PM




The SAS and SBS are my favorites to win because they are both trained in similar ways and both are also trained to do what other special forces wouldn't even dream of doing.The US Navy Seals and the SAS are easy to compare.....ready for it,the SAS would obviously kick their ass.




No SAS would even make it through SEAL hell week. The SEALS are tougher and in better shape physically and mentally. My brother was a SEAL. He once had three Marines back down from fighting him. SEALS are crazy mother fuckers. Don't talk about what you don't have the foggiest clue what you are talking about.


question for you, why do you keep talking then? muppet!
i have a clue, thus feel myself entitled to talk about things i feel knowledgeable enough to offer my opinion/expertise on. there are others like me that do have a clue and share that same entitlement to talk. there are others that don't have a first hand clue, but gain insight in a respectful and eager manner. then there are those that don't have a clue, don't give a toss, and don't show respect [they're the billy-no-mates of SP], then there's you, it may be true that your brother was a SEAL and himself has a clue, but you don't and have only degraded your brothers reputation [if he was a SEAL] as a SEAL, and to finish... if he is like you explain [doubtable] then he deserves such degredation of reputation and makes me wonder if hell week really is as successful as it used to be in weeding out the muppets [i.e. people like you]
you have been told, goodbye and have a pleasant day [and don't come back to me F 'ing and blinding, others did and their handle magically disappeared]
 
Quote    Reply

static       12/18/2007 12:20:38 AM
Of course, then there are the smartass uh-merr-cuns such as myself who have just learned whose toes not to step on.  This SOF comparison bit is like a disease, it is even cross-contaminating threads now!  This whole section will have to be quarantined off before long, and it will turn into a prototypical zombie move.  Mough and Bob will have to run around with rifles and shotties saving everyone from the SEAL and SAS baddies while the rest of us offer comic relief.

 
Quote    Reply

Old Grunt       12/18/2007 8:03:53 AM
Come on Bob, you know the types of deadly weapons a SEAL can fashion from his trousers!
Urkle's brother was just trying to keep the playing field level with those pansy Marines.  Heck, there was only three of them anyway, he probably should have asked for a blindfold to make it fair.  They're just lucky he didn't use his heat vision on them!!
 
Quote    Reply

bob the brit       12/18/2007 10:48:51 AM

Come on Bob, you know the types of deadly weapons a SEAL can fashion from his trousers!

Urkle's brother was just trying to keep the playing field level with those pansy Marines.  Heck, there was only three of them anyway, he probably should have asked for a blindfold to make it fair.  They're just lucky he didn't use his heat vision on them!!



blindfolded still wouldn't have been fair old G... his x-ray powers still would have given him a most unfair advantage [unless said blindfold was thick lead or something], no I think it best to say that the fairest match would have been for 'Urkle's [I like that one, suprisingly being a brit, I still know who your talking about] brother to take on Force recon, with them getting one free stab per person. Basically Theo [if your still about] your brother should have told those silly bootnecks not to bring a knife to a superhero fight.
 
Quote    Reply

bob the brit       12/18/2007 10:50:29 AM
I know I've notied this a bit late but this lads plot seems to be of the 'my BROTHER's penis is larger than yours' variety, not sure I've seen that one.
 
Quote    Reply

ker       12/21/2007 9:23:11 PM
Hidding behind the layers of this thread there is some thing worth talking about.
 
First layer is todem worship.  Some people have todem animals.  The feel a conection with these spirtual animals and it helps them in some ways.  For some people elit units are todem.  (Sports teams and bands work for other people.)  I confess that I do this with the military in general.  I do it in a much more sopisticated way now than I did when I was six years old.  I was scaired to put my face in the watter and told the swim instructor that I didn't need to swim cause I was gona be in the Army like my dad. 
 
Next layer is people who take the time to mock the shallow todem people.  "You don't know how to revear the elit because you don't do it like I do."  If some on has a SEALs poster on his wall it is better for the world than if he has a Scare Face Movie poster.  On the other hand fans need to learn some manners.  "I am gonna be a SEAL" is much better than "I was/am a SEAL but don't tell anybody." 
 
This all becomes very circular because underneath it is the question of how do you measure things.  I get a bigger vicaious buzz when meditating on Army SF than on Navy.  My fantasy realm is more highlands than river delta I guess.  No harm.
But when people are talking about which todem works for them but can not seperate that from concreat force struture decisions the conversation no where but it goes and goes and goes.
 
My wolf spirt animal will beat your Miami Dolphins spirt animal by three touchdowns.
 
Now we can make light of spirt animal stuff but it is very old and very useful moral building method.  The Screaming Egales by any other name are not the same.  Troops fighting more primative cultures will some times adopt parts of the cloths of the people they defeat.  Why do the brits still where funny hats when they gaurd the seats of power in London? Belive me it is not just to sell post cards.
 
So I got side tracked on the moral thing.
 
What I wold like to hear about with the elits is how you make a package of seletion, training, arming and suporting a unick unit and how that conects with mission assighnment and planning.  We can count who can do more comando push ups.  What is more important is who should get what jobs. 
 
Lets not think of them as compeating with each other but as different clubs in a gulf bag.  Each one dose some needed jobs.  We as a nation want to learn how to use each elit well in prusit of national goals.  That is the important thread.
----------------------------------------------------------
This is Pannima invation time frame information and some one may have shanged things with out telling me.  Sending SEALs to take down an air feild is like sending experienced combat engenears to do hasty defence.  They can do it but it's a waste of training.  Further more not all missions call for the same leavel of aggreasion and if you tune a person up as hypper aggresive you must account for that when giving them particular task to preform.
 
Quote    Reply

GOP       12/22/2007 6:37:03 PM
The sad thing about Theo is, that if his brother genuinely is a SEAL, and genuinely did/does what he says (beat up 8 guys trying to jump him, etc), then he does sound like a badass. But Theo is defacing him, the SEAL Teams, and the SAS/UK all at the same time.
 
The real question is why was he walking alone in Tijuana anyway? And was he unarmed? If I was by myself in Tijuana, I'd be packing for sure. As a SEAL, and someone who is used to combat enviroments and scenarios, it seems he would always be carrying...especially in that kind of area.
 
Quote    Reply

static       12/23/2007 3:28:20 AM
Well...

Totally with you on the whole Theo thing but TJ is part of Mexico and guns are pretty much a no-go down there.  Lots of signs and such on your approach (at least in the Nogales area).  Just because you are a SEAL doesn't mean you get to break the rules of other countries when you are not on a mission or whatever.  And one of the guys who I was talking to when I was considering the SEAL route told me that sometimes guys go down there to party on the weekends, TJ is pretty close to Coronado I guess.  I even think they have to do a ruck run down and back but I'm not sure.

So on the whole it sounds like he has some exposure to the NSW scene, but I'm nor sure if his brother really was a SEAL or not.  Whatever.  It looks like he finally sprung his story on the wrong crowd, still waiting to see what GF has to say about Mr. Rohman or whatever the Dive Motivator guy's name was.

 
Quote    Reply
PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7   NEXT



 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics