Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Russia
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
Could The Russians Conduct A Surprise Invasion Of Poland?
CJH
8/22/2008 5:50:50 PM
How Would The Russians Conduct A Surprise Invasion Of Poland? Could they do it? What subterfuge would be necessary in order to minimize the chance of opposition? Would The Russians have to invade Ukraine, Lithuania or Belarus in order to succeed? Would they initiate their assault from Kaliningrad and support their spearhead with forces arriving through Latvia and Lithuania?
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
Pages:
1
2
3
NEXT
VelocityVector
8/22/2008 6:18:53 PM
Russia can either nuke Poland back into the Stone Age such that NATO could perceive no valid reason to intervene or else whittle the country away by stoking internal dissension until Russia gets invited to encroach. Russian leadership cannot prevail in a conventional battle against NATO, Russian losses would be so dramatic that it would shock even the Russian national conscience.
v^2
Quote
Reply
Nanheyangrouchuan
8/22/2008 9:30:03 PM
Russia can either nuke Poland back into the Stone Age such that NATO could perceive no valid reason to intervene or else whittle the country away by stoking internal dissension until Russia gets invited to encroach. Russian leadership cannot prevail in a conventional battle against NATO, Russian losses would be so dramatic that it would shock even the Russian national conscience.
v^2
I imagine that the Russians would turn off NATO's oil and gas first, limiting the ability to respond and the Europeans have no taste for a fight anyways.
Quote
Reply
CJH
8/23/2008 12:00:13 AM
Russia can either nuke Poland back into the Stone Age such that NATO could perceive no valid reason to intervene or else whittle the country away by stoking internal dissension until Russia gets invited to encroach. Russian leadership cannot prevail in a conventional battle against NATO, Russian losses would be so dramatic that it would shock even the Russian national conscience.
v^2
That begs the question as to whether our NATO allies would have the political will, given their economic interests, to fight Russia.
Quote
Reply
afrc
8/23/2008 1:04:44 AM
That begs the question as to whether our NATO allies would have the political will, given their economic interests, to fight Russia.
Well, Poland did sign ABM treaty with US despite war in Georgia and some strong posturing from Russia. Baltic states also would love to stick it to the old boss. However, the real question is what pretext would Russia use to invade Poland? The response of other NATO members will depend on moral justification and popular support. At the end all NATO countries realize that if they don't respond to protect one country when they are morally right, it will be their turn next when Russia does not like something about them. Divided we fall.
As far as interests, Russian economy benefits greatly from oil and gas sales, so both sides have something to lose from the conflict.
Russian military has no way of conducting a large ground operation without being noticed. Military buildup in Kaliningrad area will prompt an equal buildup on the other side. Russia will have more problems suppling the troops across the Baltic Sea. Russian Air Force does not have enough of the latest planes to counter NATO Air Force... especially if US sends Raptors to Europe (and there are more than 100 of them in service). Russia can try to use tactical missiles to strike Poland and prompt NATO to cross into Russia and fight in on friendly territory. All NATO has to do is destroy as much as possible (power plants, oil storages, refineries, pipelines, water systems, grain storage, railways, bridges) and let Russian Winter finish the job. Russian PVO still needs a lot of work to be able to counter a massive air strike. There will be a lot of planes lost, but it is doable. Not a good option for Russians. And once again you have nukes... but we all know how this story ends.
So it is hard to answer your question in general. One has to know all the details before starting to speculate.
Quote
Reply
CJH
8/23/2008 4:27:13 PM
I suppose that a clandestine Russian presence in Poland and its neighbors would be and probably is a fact.
Agents provocateurs might be useful for creating a pretext which would need only to remain unexposed long enough for the Russians to react. Confronted by a Russian occupation as a fait accompli, what could the West do to Russia even if the cause was suspicious?
Quote
Reply
Knjaz
8/26/2008 2:17:30 PM
It's hard to think of pretext for this invasion. Russia dont need to annex Poland. And ABM sites can be taken out by nukes or massive air assaults (of course, those Patriots in Poland greatly increases chances that nukes will be used in case of war, instead of conventional bombers).
There's nothing more that could lead to a Russian attack on Poland.
Quote
Reply
StevoJH
8/27/2008 12:48:55 PM
Russia can either nuke Poland back into the Stone Age such that NATO could perceive no valid reason to intervene or else whittle the country away by stoking internal dissension until Russia gets invited to encroach. Russian leadership cannot prevail in a conventional battle against NATO, Russian losses would be so dramatic that it would shock even the Russian national conscience.
v^2
I imagine that the Russians would turn off NATO's oil and gas first, limiting the ability to respond and the Europeans have no taste for a fight anyways.
The only reply i can think of to your "have not taste for a fight" comment, is that, isnt that what hitler thought of the British in WWII? :P
Quote
Reply
CJH
8/30/2008 12:31:28 PM
Russia can either nuke Poland back into the Stone Age such that NATO could perceive no valid reason to intervene or else whittle the country away by stoking internal dissension until Russia gets invited to encroach. Russian leadership cannot prevail in a conventional battle against NATO, Russian losses would be so dramatic that it would shock even the Russian national conscience.
v^2
I imagine that the Russians would turn off NATO's oil and gas first, limiting the ability to respond and the Europeans have no taste for a fight anyways.
The only reply i can think of to your "have not taste for a fight" comment, is that, isnt that what hitler thought of the British in WWII? :P
Let us hope.
However, your example is from a time when there was an extreme aversion to war on the part of national leaders and people who had experienced WWI. A repeat of Verdun, Passchendael, the Somme, etc was what people feared.
That was a very understandable practical aversion but is not the EU's current attitude toward war more of a philosophical character?
Quote
Reply
CJH
8/30/2008 12:35:07 PM
I was disregarding the EU's economic interests.
Quote
Reply
CJH
8/30/2008 1:01:01 PM
It's hard to think of pretext for this invasion. Russia dont need to annex Poland. And ABM sites can be taken out by nukes or massive air assaults (of course, those Patriots in Poland greatly increases chances that nukes will be used in case of war, instead of conventional bombers).
There's nothing more that could lead to a Russian attack on Poland.
I am sure the Kremlin has some very imaginative and creative people working for it. I can't rise to their level but I can make an attempt which at least suggests something of the kind.
Perhaps a presumably smuggled low yield nuclear device is or devices are discovered in eastern Europe/Russia. One might even be detonated somewhere. The Russians "investigate" and find some kind of connection with clandestine activity in or somehow connected to Poland. Perhaps Chechens are implicated. Perhaps the Russian or other mafia is involved. The Russians decide this is what you get with a new eastern Europe and resolve to set things right.
Quote
Reply
1
2
3
NEXT
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
AIR DEFENSE: Never Enough Air Defense Missiles
SUBMARINES: US Colombia SSBNs Behind Schedule
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
CHINA: China April 2024 Update
SUBMARINES: New Submarines for Norway
WEAPONS: Russia Running Out of Antique Weapons
SOMALIA: Somalia April 2024
ARTILLERY: New Iranian Weapons
INTELLIGENCE: NATO Suspects a Threat
ATTRITION: Russia fires on Ukrainian Fakes
NAVAL AIR: Tritons Assemble
WEAPONS: South Korean Arms Exports to the Middle East
LIBYA: Libya April Update
ARTILLERY: Russia Bombards Ukraine With North Korean Missiles
WARPLANES: South Korea’s Troubled KF-21 Jet Fighter Project
AIR WEAPONS: Drones Dominate Ukrainian Battlefield
SUBMARINES: Ukraine Obtains Anti-Submarine Weapons
MURPHY'S LAW: Nationwide Impact of Ukraine War in Russia
STRATEGIC WEAPONS: American ARRW Missile Tested
SURFACE FORCES : Vasily Bykov class Corvettes
SPECIAL OPERATIONS: Tatar Rebels in Crimea
PROCUREMENT: China Supercharges Military Spending
ARMOR: M1A2SEP3 Tank Paradox
AIR DEFENSE: Russia Seeks Answers
ARTILLERY: HIMARS Prevails Against Russians
ARTILLERY: Chinese-Truck Mounted Artillery
SURFACE FORCES : Zumwalt Class Destroyers Find a Purpose
ARTILLERY: NATO Artillery Shell Shortage
SUBMARINES: Lada Class Submarine Abandoned
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
Procurement: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
WARS China: China April 2024 Update
Weapons: Russia Running Out of Antique Weapons
Intelligence: NATO Suspects a Threat
Submarines: New Submarines for Norway
Artillery: New Iranian Weapons
Attrition: Russia fires on Ukrainian Fakes
WARS Somalia: Somalia April 2024
Naval Air: Tritons Assemble
Weapons: South Korean Arms Exports to the Middle East
On PointIsrael's Airspace Defense Victory: Credit Reagan's SDI
Air Weapons: Drones Dominate Ukrainian Battlefield
Artillery: Russia Bombards Ukraine With North Korean Missiles
Warplanes: South Korea’s Troubled KF-21 Jet Fighter Project
WARS Libya: Libya April Update
Submarines: Ukraine Obtains Anti-Submarine Weapons
WEAPONS: Russia Running Out of Antique Weapons
CHINA: China April 2024 Update
SUBMARINES: New Submarines for Norway
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
PROCUREMENT: Neutral Switzerland Upgrades Its Military
SUBMARINES: US Colombia SSBNs Behind Schedule
AIR DEFENSE: Never Enough Air Defense Missiles
LIBYA: Libya April Update
WEAPONS: South Korean Arms Exports to the Middle East
NAVAL AIR: Tritons Assemble
ATTRITION: Russia fires on Ukrainian Fakes
INTELLIGENCE: NATO Suspects a Threat
ARTILLERY: New Iranian Weapons
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
StrategyPage
Account Manager
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Advertise With Us
Search