Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Artillery Discussion Board
   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Charge Error Incident
ArtyEngineer    4/15/2008 5:44:36 PM
Folks were talking about this today. Next post has link to NY Times Article. I really feel for the Chief, he didnt catch the error and dropped his round on a rifle range. Thats pure Murphys Law in action.
Quote    Reply

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
ArtyEngineer    Link to Article   4/15/2008 5:45:42 PM
Quote    Reply

Carl S       4/15/2008 7:47:24 PM
Activating that link led to the front page (eventually). & a search for Artillery & US Army did not turn up any news story.  More clues please?
Quote    Reply

ArtyEngineer       4/15/2008 8:11:06 PM
Here is article, just realised my first post isnt very clear.  This is an old incident, 1989, but it came up today as we were discussing in this age of digiatal comm and digital data transfer from observor to FDC and then to the gunline how people can still shoot "out of the box".

Army Won't Try Two in Artillery Accident

Published: December 31, 1989

The base commander here has decided against a court-martial for two artillery gunners whose errant round last Sept. 27 killed 3 soldiers and wounded 24.

Army investigators had charged the two cannoneers, Sgt. Edward C. Tyler of Washington and Specialist Nickoles W. Holly of Canton, Ohio, with dereliction of duty and negligent homicide, counts that could have resulted at court-martial in 15 months' confinement, loss of wages and bad-conduct discharges.

But on Friday the base commander, Maj. Gen. Raphael J. Hallada, announced that a court-martial would not be ''appropriate.'' He said he had based his decision ''on the evidence, on the spotless records of Tyler and Holly and on my determination that the accident was a tragic mistake resulting from a momentary violation of safety procedures rather than a criminal act.''

The investigators had found that during a firing exercise with a 105-millimeter howitzer, Specialist Holly was to remove excess powder bags for the firing of a lesser charge and was to display the bags to his section chief, Sergeant Tyler. The inquiry concluded that Specialist Holly had failed to do this with one round and that Sergeant Tyler had not caught the error. The result was that the round landed on a nearby rifle range, where it exploded near a group of 80 soldiers who were lined up in formation.

But General Hallada said, ''I was not convinced a jury would find that Holly and Tyler blatantly disregarded what a reasonably careful person would have done under the circumstances.''

The general said he had met with the two cannoneers and their commanding officers to review the actions that led to the accident. ''The two soldiers know that they caused the accident.'' he said. ''The officers know that this happened on their watch. These were very emotional meetings. Every one of them would give anything to have that round back.''

Quote    Reply

VelocityVector       4/15/2008 10:20:35 PM

A more recent incident, which should read "artillery incident results in death of Don Gato."  Then again, we just killed a cougar on the North Side of Chicago -

Misfired Artillery Hits Home, Hurts Cat

3 days ago

JEFFERSON TOWNSHIP, N.J. (AP) — A piece of artillery that was apparently misfired by the military crashed through the roof of a home miles away Friday and injured a young girl's cat, which had to be euthanized, officials said.

No people were injured when the 2-pound piece hit the Jefferson Township home about 2 1/2 miles from the Picatinny Arsenal and landed in the girl's bed, said Peter Rowland, arsenal spokesman. She wasn't home, but her cat was sleeping on the bed.

. . .



Quote    Reply