Military History
|
How To Make War
|
Wars Around the World
Rules of Use
How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Artillery
Discussion Board
Return to Topic Page
Subject:
105mm howitzer or 120mm mortar?
Brock
4/20/2007 12:28:46 AM
As an infanteer I think I would rather be supported in this day and age by a 120mm mortar given the plus and minuses of the 120mm over 105mm towed howitzers. Any thoughts?
Quote
Reply
Show Only Poster Name and Title
Newest to Oldest
IsoT
Weight on target
4/20/2007 1:47:24 AM
120mm mortar shell weights about 12kgs and range in neighbourhood of 10kms, give or take 2kms
and 105mm shell weights about 15kgs and range about 17 kms.
SO with guns you'll get more TNT on target and longer range. Also generally artillery fires tighter group that mortars. Of course that is not such a big factor as mortars generally shorter range to target so dispersion is about the same. Where mortars come handy is their ability fire 120mm guided munitions (like strix) which can help you take out tanks. As to my knowledege there is no similar system for artillery in 105mm league.
Also 105mm are bit oldish systems and NATO is upping to 155mm league, where you can toss a 40 kg grenade out to 30kms with standard ammo. You can do the math....
In Finland FO would also factor in the fact that mortars fire in 6 tube company and artillery fires in 18 gun batallion, so you get about three times the explosives on target in same time.
Quote
Reply
Carl S
4/20/2007 9:54:54 PM
I've favored the 120mm mtr/155mm howitzer combination for a couple decades. Specificlly the French designed RT120 whic has a bit more range than 10km. Lighter for both tactical & stratigic transport than any 105mm howitzer, and less maintiance overhead. The RT120 design is approximatly three decades old. I'd expect with a bit of R& D money an even better launcher/ammo combo could be fielded rivaling any more expensive 105mm howitzer/gun.
Quote
Reply
Latest
News
Most
Read
Most
Commented
Hot
Topics
KOREA: Send In The Serfs
INFORMATION WARFARE: Be Careful What You Say
COUNTER-TERRORISM: Is Terrorizing Terrorists A War Crime?
ELECTRONIC WEAPONS: Gorgon Stare
ISRAEL: Go On Syria, Make My Day
NAVAL AIR: Keeping The Chinese Blind
LOGISTICS: The Flaw In North Korean War Plans
LEADERSHIP: Shut Up You Whore,
WEAPONS: Bigger Is No Longer Better
NIGERIA: Blitzkrieg Breaks Boko Haram
WARPLANES: Turkish UAV Exports
CONGO: Peacekeeping Becomes War
NAVAL AIR: Mixing Droids And Pilots In The Same Squadron
SUBMARINES: The Chinese Plan To Catch Up
MURPHY'S LAW: The Sad Death Of Euro Hawk
INDONESIA: Islamic Terrorists Down But Not Gone
BALKANS: Serbs And Albanians Sort Of Make Peace
MURPHY'S LAW: Searching For Mister Big
COUNTER-TERRORISM: The Other Al Qaeda
WEAPONS: Russia Resists A Revolutionary AK
SPACE: Chinese KillSats Threaten GPS Network
SYRIA: Iran Shows How It Is Done
NAVAL AIR: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
NAVAL AIR: China Learns From The Masters
ARTILLERY: The Tale Of The North Korean TELs
COUNTER-TERRORISM: A Taliban Cry For Help
MYANMAR: China Tries To Be The Good Guy
WARPLANES: Rafale Fades Some More
MURPHY'S LAW: A Melancholy Milestone For MiG
MURPHY'S LAW: China Bans Military Hotrods
Subscribe to Our RSS Feed
Leadership: Shut Up You Whore,
WARS Korea: Send In The Serfs
WARS Israel: Go On Syria, Make My Day
Naval Air: Keeping The Chinese Blind
Logistics: The Flaw In North Korean War Plans
Information Warfare: Be Careful What You Say
Counter-Terrorism: Is Terrorizing Terrorists A War Crime?
Weapons: Bigger Is No Longer Better
Electronic Weapons:
Submarines: The Chinese Plan To Catch Up
WARS Nigeria: Blitzkrieg Breaks Boko Haram
Weapons: Russia Resists A Revolutionary AK
Murphy's Law: The Sad Death Of Euro Hawk
Space: Chinese KillSats Threaten GPS Network
Naval Air: Mixing Droids And Pilots In The Same Squadron
Murphy's Law: Searching For Mister Big
WARS Congo: Peacekeeping Becomes War
Naval Air: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
Warplanes: Turkish UAV Exports
WARS Syria: Iran Shows How It Is Done
Counter-Terrorism: The Other Al Qaeda
WARS Indonesia: Islamic Terrorists Down But Not Gone
WARS Balkans: Serbs And Albanians Sort Of Make Peace
Naval Air: China Learns From The Masters
Artillery: The Tale Of The North Korean TELs
NAVAL AIR: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
WARPLANES: Rafale Fades Some More
COUNTER-TERRORISM: A Taliban Cry For Help
YEMEN: Death Squads Gone Wild
NAVAL AIR: Mixing Droids And Pilots In The Same Squadron
CONGO: Peacekeeping Becomes War
ARTILLERY: The Tale Of The North Korean TELs
COUNTER-TERRORISM: Is Terrorizing Terrorists A War Crime?
ISRAEL: Go On Syria, Make My Day
LOGISTICS: The Flaw In North Korean War Plans
BALKANS: Serbs And Albanians Sort Of Make Peace
INDONESIA: Islamic Terrorists Down But Not Gone
MURPHY'S LAW: The Sad Death Of Euro Hawk
COUNTER-TERRORISM: The Other Al Qaeda
SUPPORT: The Chinese Air Force Underground
SPACE: Chinese KillSats Threaten GPS Network
WEAPONS: Russia Resists A Revolutionary AK
MURPHY'S LAW: Searching For Mister Big
SUBMARINES: The Chinese Plan To Catch Up
WEAPONS: Bigger Is No Longer Better
Fighters, Bombers and Recon: Best All-Around Fighter of World War II
Dirty Little Links: News Links.
Naval Air: Replacing Carriers With Cruise Missiles
Counter-Terrorism Operations: Is Terrorizing Terrorists A War Crime?
Books of Interest
The Guns at Last Light: The War in Western Europe, 1944-1945 (Liberation Trilogy)
Fallujah Awakens: Marines, Sheikhs, and the Battle Against al Qaeda (Blue and Gold)
SPECIAL OPERATIONS IN THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION
Bunker Hill: A City, a Siege, a Revolution
The Way of the Knife: The CIA, a Secret Army, and a War at the Ends of the Earth
From Amazon
News
How To Make War
Wars Around The World
Austin Bay's On Point
StrategyTalk
Dirty Little Secrets
Features
Al Nofi's CIC
Prediction Market
Wargames
Measure of Respect
On War and Warfare
Videos
Photos
Jokes
Community
Military Discussion Boards
Military Jokes
Military Photos
Military Book Reviews
Military Movie Reviews
StrategyPage
Subscribe
Login
Feedback
About Us
Search
Account Manager
Advertise With Us
Search