Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Military Science Fiction Discussion Board
Sign In   Return to Topic Page
Subject: If Earth Was Attacked
L4zyB0i    3/9/2006 4:32:29 PM
How many men can some of the larger nations draft and arm to resist an invasion? China, US, Russia, India, EU all seem to be capapble of putting up quite a fight, and any invasion would likely be highly disadvantaged numbers wise. Its really hard to take enough soldiers from your planet to attack one lightyears away that can arm 100 million plus soldiers. So first off, how many soldiers does the world have in its armed forces right now while we are mostly all at peace? Secondly, how many could we equip to fight? Although there hasnt been another world war to show us the Earth's industrial might, we must have at least doubled what we were capable of producing during the 40's right? The US in its 4 years of total war in WW2 built close to 300,000 combat aircraft. Granted, planes have gotten more complicated and more expensive, but their capability's have also taken a quantum leap. Would we win with sheer numbers alone if we united to defend our planet?
 
Quote    Reply

Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest

Pages: PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7   NEXT
Mr_Omniscient    Re:If Earth was attacked.   10/7/2006 7:53:23 AM
  I'm gonna go back on myself a little bit by saying that my worst case scenario example may not be the worst possible.
A friend put it forward to me that perhaps their could be an alien race who are completely invincible. I know it seems extreme, but if you think about it there is no reason why an alien race wouldn't be able to replace cells quicker than they die, and still maintain the same basic biological structure. Thus these aliens wouldn't die (of natural causes) and would be able to heal wounds unbelievably quick. Now I would say that these aliens would still have found ways to kill each other, because I know it is possible to kill something if you can destroy its cells quicker than it can replace them and it is incongruous to think an alien race would be unable to kill itself. My friend interrupts me here and suggests that these aliens have never had an internal war, and therefore have had no need to produce weapons. This would mean that these aliens may never have experienced death and because they could replicate their cells very quickly we would be unable to kill them with anything less than a nuclear (or really powerful conventional eplosive) bomb. I think that if an alien race hadn't experienced death at any point whatever, they would surely have no moral opinion on killing. This would mean that they probably wouldn't be aggresive, because they are not threatened in any way, and they probably woudn't have any intention of killing, because they've never heard of it.  Why Then would they invade?  Well if they regenerated their cells, that organic material had to come from somewhere. To regenerate that quickly they would need a massive enegy input, which would lead directly to a means of attack. Starvation. If they came, we'd have to slow them down until they either starved or moved on. Unfortunately the only way to starve an invinvcible race, would be to destroy all the organic material we couldn't hide, fortunately we have thousands of cubic miles of caves and tunnels across the world. So in the end we could defeat almost any alien race that invaded (please dont get invasion confused with annihalation), agree?
 
Quote    Reply

Ehran       10/8/2006 10:35:48 PM
how are you supposed to destroy ALL organic material on the surface of the earth?  you notion also assumes these hypothetical advanced aliens are some kind of morons incapable of figuring out they should bring some canned beans etc to tide them over.

mex ftl travel requires a bit more than an advance in theory it requires some fairly hefty rewriting of the laws of the universe as we understand them today.  we can see some pretty funky stuff at the quantum level but getting anything like that to happen at the macro scale doesn't seem to be a happening thing.

 
Quote    Reply

Bruzazki       10/9/2006 10:17:20 AM
Aliens capable of FTL travel would probably have enough mechanization to deploy completely robotic forces to complete extermination with no risk to themselves.  Much of the evolution of US military equipment and practice in the last 30 years has been in lowering risk to the individual soldier/sailor/airman.  It would be much closer to 'Terminator' than 'War of the Worlds.'  Semi-autonomous or autonomous machines would be doing the work while the aliens orbited out of easy reach.  Our ability to exhaust their supply of resources, whether that meant fuel, food, equipment, would probably be greater than our ability to kill them outright.  
 
Quote    Reply

doggtag       10/9/2006 1:20:07 PM

mex ftl travel requires a bit more than an advance in theory it
requires some fairly hefty rewriting of the laws of the universe as we
understand them today.  we can see some pretty funky stuff at the
quantum level but getting anything like that to happen at the macro
scale doesn't seem to be a happening thing.


Back when Newton first wrote out his Laws of  Motion, Kinetics, & Gravity,
no one believed in those days and ages that mankind would one day be flying heavier-than-air machines to cross the globe in a matter of hours just as routinely as people his day and age rode horse and carriage.
It took the ideas of two men named Bernoulli and Venturi, and years of inventors' ingenious tinkering, to prove that an airfoil shape could be created that allows us to, effectively, "skirt around" gravity.
 
Give some extraterrestrial culture a few hundred more years (or thousands?) of advancement beyond mankind's achievements,
and it shouldn't be all that hard to comprehend that, while they may not technically be able to travel faster than light, through ingenuity and further understandings of other physical laws (certainly all of which even we don't know), they may have found a means of "skirting around" the limitations imposed by light speed travel just as we, technically, circumvent the pull of gravity by using airfoils acting on the atmosphere.

 
Quote    Reply

stingray1003       11/28/2006 7:56:33 PM
I doubt any alien race would attack a home world unless they were dead set trying to commit genocide. And if they were they must really hate us and we would really hate them and it would most likely end up with huge casualties on both sides.
 
 If an alien race turned up and started mining mars, taking water from europa etc, setting military bases up on mercury etc, would we be able to defend our territory? Thats a diffrent matter.
 
 Would humans stand by and watch another species do extremely well off the resources in our solar system? Claiming planet after planet and taking all the valuables?
 
 No way. We would launch nukes, build spaceships and go nuts to protect the bodies around the sun. Could we sustain a war off earth? I think given the will we could.  We went from Wright brothers to Landing on the moon in less than 70 years, and that wasn't a flat out race and we are far more capable now than then.
 
 If we turned the entire world over to producing space weapons with in a few years we would be pretty competitive to fend off most attempts on our solar system.
 
 Much like the US/Russia in WWII. The world is a very good producer/manufacturer. The germans may have had the technological edge (ICBM's, jet planes, Uboats etc) but production is a killer. Unless they have planet size ships able to build competitively near here forget it.
 
Quote    Reply

Herald1234    Erasure.   11/28/2006 8:15:34 PM
Just seed the life-bearing planet in a target solar system with  a tailored disease designed to kill the unaware tool using sapient. Then move in and harvest.

If you want to be spectacular, Chicxilub them. Game over.

Herald
 
Quote    Reply

andyf    sneaky   11/29/2006 11:34:06 AM
or to be really sneaky,, cause a greenhouse effect,  or pop yellowstone with some funky space laser.
life is fairly fragile, and any invader wouldnt be trying to wipe us out, theyd have to be real smart to NOT wipe all the multicellular life out.
you put a big impactor or 2 in, global winter,
but that said what reason would they have for coming here? surely anything that major is gonna knacker up their war-aims?
id say your motive would have to be :
slaves
religion
 
nothing else would be worthwhile.
 
Quote    Reply

Herald1234    About that laser...........   11/29/2006 12:52:15 PM
Popping Yellowstone will kibosh North America and make Europe cold for about seventy winters. Rest of the planet will bundle up in furs and breath through cheesecloth. Not good enough to just pop the caldera. Need to punch into the mantle to really put the boot in.

Herald
 
Quote    Reply

Treadgar       11/30/2006 8:25:54 AM
 
Quote    Reply

andyf    ok, not just the lasers   12/19/2006 2:56:22 PM
we'll use a 2 gigaton thermonuclear depth charge type weapon on the deep ocean trenches.
yellowstone and  any major calderas they get the laser.
oh, and we'll use the big laser to write on the moon, a cryptic message....'cha...'
 
 
Quote    Reply
PREV  1 2 3 4 5 6 7   NEXT



StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2012StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy