Brigades and Regiments

Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title Sort in Reverse Order Posted

Pages: 1 2 3 4 NEXT

Roman RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/8/2004 8:42:57 AM

Can a brigade have multiple regiments as sub-units?

Quote Reply

Sam RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/8/2004 9:14:15 PM

Roman I can only give you the USMC answer. And very generic because Brigades will be tasked org. A Regiment (infantry) consist of 3 infantry Battalions and a HQ Company. A Brigade consist of A Command element an Infantry Regt, reinforced with tanks, amtracks, artillery,LAR, recon and other things. Commonly called a Regt Landing Team (RLT) A Marine Air Wing element consisting of fixed (F/A-18 and/or AV-8s)and rotary wing (CH46/53, UH-1 and AH-1) Called a Marine Air Group (MAG) Maybe wrong on the designation. Never did Swing with the Wing! A Combat Service Support Detachment. Doing that beans, bullets bandages, 3d echelon maint thing. (CSSD)

Quote Reply

Sam RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/8/2004 10:01:46 PM

Yes Brigades may have more than 1 regt assigned. But once you reach 3 they want to call it a Division or MEF (Marine Expeditionary Force). Which can include mult brigades or division size units. MEF being the largest level of command element. (3 Star at least)

Quote Reply

Ehran RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/11/2004 5:36:03 PM

in the british descended armies regiments are admin organizations which provide battalions to form brigades which do the fighting. the regiment's primary role is to train troops to keep the battalions ranks filled.

Quote Reply

Roman RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/11/2004 11:28:53 PM

Thanks guys - your explanations were very helpful! :)

Quote Reply

Roman RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/11/2004 11:31:27 PM

So basically a brigade is a reinforced, more independent and better supported regiment, but it can actually contain more than 1 regiment. As such, I would guess it can have perhaps 16,000 or maybe even up to 20,000 personnel when all the attachments are included.

Quote Reply

mike_golf RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/11/2004 11:54:26 PM

Roman, You got answers that are a bit too specific for what I think you are asking. In general a brigade is the smallest unit at the operational level as opposed to the tactical. In general a regiment is still a tactical unit. A unit can't really act at the operational level without organic logistics, artillery, etc. The US Armored Cavalry Regiment is unique in this. It is an operational level unit, not tactical. The appellation of regiment is kept for reasons of tradition.

Quote Reply

Roman RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/12/2004 12:00:33 AM

Aha, thanks mike_golf! So brigade is essentially a regiment with attachments that make it capable of independent operations at an operational level. Thanks again!

Quote Reply

mike_golf RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/12/2004 12:40:59 AM

Yes, correct. Just to throw a monkey wrench in the works, there was a time in the American Army where brigades had multiple regiments. And in some armies a regiment is about the equivalent in combat power of an American battalion. In the Soviet Army a Brigade was an independent formation assigned at the Army or Army Group level. It had nearly the combat power of a Red Army division and was used for operational actions, especially pursuit and exploitation. It would typically spearhead the Operational Manuever Group, which would consist of an independent brigade and one or more divisions. Hehe, just wanted to confuse things a bit now that I clarified them.

Quote Reply

Roman RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/12/2004 1:04:34 AM

Very interesting info on differences between countries. Now I see why U.S. divisions in WWI had 40,000+ troops - they had brigades as sub-units, which in turn had regiments as subunits. In effect, U.S. brigades were the equivalent to everybody else's divisions!

Quote Reply

ozigrunt RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/12/2004 7:42:15 AM

"Now I see why U.S. divisions in WWI had 40,000+ troops" They did???!!! Roman, the unit names Platoon, company, battalion, regiment, brigade, division, army, army group etc. vary GREATLY from era to era, army to army, nation to nation. They will very from organisation, function, degree of independence to size. They are a very unreliable means of comparison unless you know the detail. e.g a polish inf pl was about 65 men. German and most others were around the 35. I think the Marines made three major manning changes to their platoon in the three years of Island hoping. The size came down as firepower went up. Even within the one period the meaning can change. In WW2 a british Brigade was a fairly rigid org of a hq + 3 Bns commanded by a Brigadier with an attached arty bn (but called a regiment). But in Nth Africa it became the bases of a flexible operational unit been reinforced with armour, anti-tank and arty units and ranged up to 6500 men. This was a major organisational development during WW2 when ad hoc, or at least task oriented, groups were built around a corp HQ with attached arms appropriate for the task. The names of these groups varied for army to army. The Brits called them Brigades, the Yanks regimental groups, Germans Combat Groups,Australians Task Force and the Japs called them by the name of the appointed commander, e.g. the Toyo Force. And to confuse things further a regiment could be a bn size group and a company could be called a squadron and a platoon a troop - just depending on the Corp or Arm that it referred to. Do you wish to rephrase your question.....????

Quote Reply

Worcester RE:Brigades and Regiments - aaarrrrgh!!! It is very simple 10/12/2004 2:23:39 PM

Much gnashing of teeth!!!! Two points (which I've mentioned before)... (1) a UNIT is ALWAYS, ALWAYS a battalion sized organization (regardless of the latest Pentagon nomenclature calling brigades "units of action"...ignore it). A battalion is 550-850 soldiers commanded by a Lieutenant Colonel who OWNS his troops; they all BELONG to him and will all identify themselves as belonging to the same UNIT. Each UNIT has limited endurane without the support of suppor troops within the same BRIGADE. (2) a BRIGADE is a FORMATION of UNITS. It is commanded by a BRIGADIER GENERAL who will have a variety of different UNITS to allow him to accomplish a specific war mission. For example an ARMORED BRIGADE may have 2 TANK UNITS, 1 INFANTRY UNIT, 1 ARTILLERY UNIT, 1 ENGINEER SUB-UNIT AND 1 SIGNALS SUB-UNIT, 1 MEDICAL SUB-UNIT, 1 LOGISTICS UNIT plus military police, a records offcie, burial detail. An INFANTRY BRIGADE will have 2 OR 3 INFANTRY UNITS, 1 ARTILLERY UNIT, 1 LOGISTICS UNIT, etc. A MECHANIZED BRIGADE will have 2 INFANTRY + 1 TANK UNIT, etc. Each BRIGADE is formed for a specific task and mission with 4-6 units which belong to that brigade. As a war develops, UNITS may be added to or taken from a BRIGADE on a TEMPORARY basis to accomplish specific immediate missions. At the end of a war a BRIGADE will usually have the same UNITS it started with. A BRIGADE is the smallest formation of ALL ARMS. a REGIMENT may be one of FOUR things:- (1) REGIMENT (or Regimental Combat Team) in the US Marine Corps is commanded by a Colonel and means a grouping of 2-4 UNITS designed for a landing operation. It is like the front end of a BRIGADE, but has less LOGISTICS support, relying on ships for supply. It is not designed to be as independent as a BRIGADE in full scale war. (2) A US Cavalry REGIMENT is a special structure based on tradition consisting of a number of armored UNITS; the Regiment, Squadrons (battalions), Troops (Companies) and Platoons. Think of it as an armored version of a US Marine regiment; it is designed for fast reconnaissance and shock action and has limited self-support. It operates independently usually within a larger DIVISION. (3) A US infantry REGIMENT is usually an administrative structure for a number of UNITS. Foe example the 1/257, 2/257 and 3/257 are the 1st, 2nd and 3rd battalions of the 257th Regiment. They may serve together or separately in formations like a Brigade or Division. (3) A UK Cavalry REGIMENT is a tank UNIT. The squadrons are companies, the troops are platoons. It is grouped with other UNITS within a BRIGADE. (4) A UK infantry REGIMENT is the administrative "home" for the battalions (like in the US army), but the Regiment NEVER takes the field...the individual battalions will serve usually with diferent BRIGADES on different missions. In summary:- A UNIT is what you wear on your cap badge or lapel badge - infantry battalion, armor battalion, UK armor regiment, marine battalion. A BRIGADE is what you wear on your shoulder patch. a REGIMENT as a formation is rare today and is a "small brigade".

Quote Reply

JohnBarry RE:Brigades and Regiments 10/12/2004 3:06:22 PM

Is anyone going to start explaining UOA and UOEx and UOEy? Just Kidding ozigrunt had the best answer to Roman's orginal question- "the unit names Platoon, company, battalion, regiment, brigade, division, army, army group etc. vary GREATLY from era to era, army to army, nation to nation. They will very from organisation, function, degree of independence to size." May be better if you specified a country and time period.

Quote Reply

mike_golf Not quite that simple 10/12/2004 10:30:52 PM

Worcester, I had to disagree with you in several places where you are not correct. Not to start a war, but there were inaccuracies. I was trying to avoid getting too specific, since I don't think that is what Roman was really looking for. Additionally, your answer only addresses Anglo military tradition. At the bottom I provide a short guide to Russian military formations. (2) a BRIGADE is a FORMATION of UNITS. It is commanded by a BRIGADIER GENERAL who will have a variety of different UNITS to allow him to accomplish a specific war mission. This is not true for all Armies, nor even for all NATO Armies. In the US Army, for example, a brigade is commanded by a Colonel, not a brigadier general. Brigadiers, in the US Army, are assistant division commanders. A BRIGADE is the smallest formation of ALL ARMS. Again, not true in the US Army. As part of the Army's transformation effort the battalion is the smallest combined arms formation, not the brigade. (2) A US Cavalry REGIMENT is a special structure based on tradition consisting of a number of armored UNITS; the Regiment, Squadrons (battalions), Troops (Companies) and Platoons. Think of it as an armored version of a US Marine regiment; it is designed for fast reconnaissance and shock action and has limited self-support. It operates independently usually within a larger DIVISION. Actually a US cavalry regiment operates as an operational unit at the Corps level, not the division level. An ACR is capable of sustaining itself independently for a significant period of time is an operational unit. It is larger than a brigade, with more firepower, helicopters, transport and logistics. As the US Army re-organizes that will change. (3) A US infantry REGIMENT is usually an administrative structure for a number of UNITS. Foe example the 1/257, 2/257 and 3/257 are the 1st, 2nd and 3rd battalions of the 257th Regiment. They may serve together or separately in formations like a Brigade or Division. Strike the infantry part and you are correct. In the US Army, infantry, armor and artillery regiments are administrative structures. The child battalions are assigned to operational brigades. A UNIT is what you wear on your cap badge or lapel badge - infantry battalion, armor battalion, UK armor regiment, marine battalion. Not true in the US Army, a regiment is what you wear on your epaulettes and it is your regimental affiliation (i.e. your home regiment). You wear your branch (i.e. armor, infantry, cavalry, artillery, etc.) affiliation on your lapel. A BRIGADE is what you wear on your shoulder patch. Unless you are assigned to an independent brigade, you wear a division on your shoulder patch. There are very few independent brigades in the US Army. Except for the 3 Cavalry Regiments. If, like me, your home regiment is the 11th Cavalry, then you would wear both a regimental patch on your shoulder and a regimental crest on your shoulder epaulettes. Russia (in the past countries that were aligned with the USSR, including the Warsaw Pact and many middle eastern nations, used this system of military formations) Platoon - basic manuever unit. 3 tanks, 3 IFV + infantry Company - 3 platoons plus a company commander Battalion - 3 companies, a very small battalion staff, minimal combat support Regiment - 3 battalions, all arms, recon, anti-air, combat support Division - 3 regiments,artillery, recon, anti-air, logistics, transport. This is, traditionally, the smallest operational unit in the Russian army. Army - 2 to 6 divisions, army level artillery, helicopters, etc. This is the operational equivalent to an American Corps Brigade - an independent operational unit, nearly a division in capabilities with all of its attached artillery, helicopters, combat support. It is generally the centerpiece of an Operational Manuever Group. In Russian doctrine the OMG exploits the breakthrough and consists of 1 to 2 brigades and 2 to 4 category A divisions.

Quote Reply

Sam RE:Brigades and Regiments - aaarrrgh Worchester 10/12/2004 10:38:16 PM

Well done. Only one small correction "A BRIGADE is the smallest formation of ALL ARMS." Except for a Marine Expeditionary Unit. The smallest Marine Air Ground Task Force consisting of a Command element (COL), Battalion Landing Team, A Composite Helo (46/53/AH-1)squadron, a 6 plane Harrier det and a MEU Service Support Detachment. The RLT in A MEB is the ground assault element. They do not get their logistical support from ships. They get them from the BSSD. We Marines learned in WW2 that ships sometimes leave us high and dry. RLT- Regt Landing Team sometimes referred to as a Regt Combat Team. MEB- Marine Expeditionary Brigade, Sometimes referred to as the Marine Expeditionary Force Forward. In the Marine Corps this structure is pretty much kept together. If we want to add/subtract units for a specific mission then that element becomes a Task Force. Us Marines always have to be different. It keeps the navy guessing

Quote Reply

Pages: 1 2 3 4 NEXT

	News As History - November 25, 2009
	Home News How to Make War Wars Around the World Austin Bay's On Point Dirty Little Secrets Features Al Nofi's CIC Prediction Market Wargames Measure of Respect On War and Warfare Videos Photos Jokes Community Military Discussion Boards Military Jokes Military Photos Military Book Reviews Military Movie Reviews Military Links Wargame Store StrategyPage Subscribe Login Feedback About Us Search Account Manager Advertise With Us