Military History | How To Make War | Wars Around the World Rules of Use How to Behave on an Internet Forum
Leadership Discussion Board
Sign In   Return to Topic Page
Subject: Military career of Ataturk. (Part 1)
ilpars    6/15/2004 3:06:21 PM
This is requested by densoflex. I thought best to put this under another topic. Mustafa Kemal Ataturk (1881-1938): Ataturk was born at Selanica at the time a cosmopolit city, it was the cultural capital of Ottoman Empire the most "European" city of the empire. He were always a brilliant student especially at mathematics, literature and French. He finished the military academy as the second best. Like all top graduates of Ottoman Academies he were sent to Europe to learn from an European military academy. In his case it was Ecole Militarie of France. He was handsome and atractive. In all of his life he was a lady's men. Later a 17 years old Zsa Zsa Gabor was one of his conquests. In his letters he told he had his most beatiful year in Paris. Appearently he was a popular gentleman at Paris. After his return, he wrote several books about training and commanding of platoon, company, battalion and regimently. I have these books probably they were greatly influenced by the French regulations. He was appoined to a unit at Sežanica his home city. His company and later battalion was the model of his ideas. From all over Selanica, young officers were coming to see his training methods. He was one of the leaders of young idealistic offiecers of Turkish army. Other most influential young officers of his age were Enver (his greatest rival) who trained at Germany became a personal friend of later Kaiser of Germany in WW1; Cemal who was trained at UK; and naval officer Rauf who trained at USA. Note: As you can see the most brilliant Ottoman officers always trained at other countries to bring new military ideas to the empire. Side effect was they too much influenced by the country they were sent to. These 4 men were all very active in the secret Ittihad and Terakki Party which was trying to make a coup to make Ottoman Empire a parliamentry monarchy like United Kingdom. The coup succeeded at 1908. Ittihad and Terakki Party became a legal party and entered the first elections of Ottoman Empire. They were not majority and did not form the government but they were very influential. Enver and Cemal were at the top circle of the party but Mustafa Kemal and Rauf bey were not. That was the time Enver-Kemal enmity has begun. They were very friendly and close to each other but the ones who knew them did nknow that they hated each other. Kemal was openly discussing that Army personnel must not involve in politics. To make an example he quited from the party. At 1911, Italy invaded Libya last Ottoman land at Africa. As at late 19th century UK had invaded Egypt, there were no land connection to Libya from the empire and Italian navy was much superior. Ottoman government sent voluntary officers to Libya to organize defence from the locals. Both Enver and Mustafa Kemal went and both were very successful against Italians. At 1912, Balkan states (Bulgaria, Serbia, Greece and Montenegro) declared war to Ottoman Empire. The empire needed every officer he had. Both commanders started to return. First Balkan War was a total disaster for the empire. Balkan states attacked the Empire before it finished its mobilization. In fact mobilisation had planned so badly that, the war ended before the mobilisation. Political enmities divided the officers corps so badly that, they could not organised a defense. A politically superior junior officer refusing to obey a politically inferior senior officer was a common thing. The result was a total disaster. Only battleships had stopped the highly trained and well commanded Bulgarian army at Catalca (150 km from Istanbul). Selanica was lost to Greek army. A close friend of Mustafa Kemal later wrote that Mustafa Kemal cried after he learned the lost of his home city. He continously told his fellow officer "How could you do that? How could you lost Selanica?". On his return Mustafa Kemal was on the staff of the corps which defended Geliboli against Bulgarians. A great fortune for the future. Bulgarian army was much more successful than his allies and made a mistake of alienating all of them. Previously neutral Romania opened the second phase. Romania, Greece, Serbia and ottoman Empire attacked Bulgaristan. Enver was the first officer who entered Edirne one of the ex-capitals of Ottoman Empire. He used this greatly for propaganda. He was known as the saviour of Edirne. Cemal was very successfull at Catalca front. Both men returned to Istanbul and started a new coup. This time they put a puppet to the throne Murad V. Enver, Cemal and Talat (civilian leader of Ittihad and Terakki) trio became the new true leaders of the empire. They all promoted to Pasha (use for both Generals and high level bureacrats). Enver Pasha became the new CiC of the empire before commanding any unit larger than a battalion. He probably knew his limitations and turned to his old friend now Kaiser of Germany. Germany sent a advisory council commanded by General von Goltz. Advisors included some very talented
 
Quote    Reply

Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest

Pages: 1 2
densoflex    RE:Prequel for Part2 : The leading Troika of OE and Mustafa Kemal   6/18/2004 8:21:52 AM
So, at the outbreak of WW1, Turkey was run by a political party with three leading perosnalities: Talad (PM), Enver and Celad. But had the Empire still (at least) nominally a sovereign? If yes what were the powers of the Sultan ? Was there a constitution and could Turkey be called a parlementary regime in 1914? Also, was Enver Pasha CiC (i.e. military) or instead Minister of War (i.e. civilian)? Same for Cemal: was he a minister or a kind of military or civilian governor? (These questions to understand better the structure of Ottoman goverment). At this time Kemal had a military appointment, so nominally he was a mere subordinate officer amongst many others. Is it correct, or already at this time he had an influence which was far beyond his nominal rank? Did he communicate freely with whoever in the government? Densoflex
 
Quote    Reply

ilpars    RE:Prequel for Part2 : The leading Troika of OE and Mustafa Kemal   6/18/2004 8:53:42 AM
There was constitution, a parliament and a Sultan. When WW1 started, Ittihad and Terakki declared a Martial Law and disbanded the parliament. Legally Sultan (Murad V) had many rights, but he was afraid to use them. So practically OE was ruled by a Party dictatorship. Enver Pasha was CiC and minister of War. That was what Mustafa Kemal objected. In Ittihad and Terakki rule, civilian and military positions are intermingled. Cemal Pasha was both commander of 4th Army at Syria and also responsible for all the Civil administration of Syria and Iraq. At 1914 Mustafa Kemal was a lietunant Colonel. he was one of the very few who openly critisized Party's politics and still have never have been sued or lost his command. That was because Cemal Pasha's protection. But that does not saved him from Mustafa kemal's critisism either. Mustafa Kemal already well known in the army because of his military books and critisism and had far more influence in the army that his rank would suggest. All officers knew that his promotion was stopped by because of Enver Pasha. But after Gellipoli even Enver could not stop his rapid promotion. He simply proved that he was the best commander in the army. Denying to promote him could damage Enver's reputation. After Gellipoli he had so much prestige that, he could comminicate with anyone in the cabinet. Once he even tried to replace Enver. After that incident Enver never let him to stay in Istanbul. He immediately sent him to Syrian front under the command of Falkenhayn. Falkenhayn and Mustafa truly hated each other and Falkenhayn asked his removal from command. Then he was sent to Germany with Crown Prince Vahdettin. After his return he again sent to Syria this time under the command of his friend von Sanders. As a note: At the start of WW1, Mustafa Kemal was at Bulgaria as a military attache. He tried hard for a Bulgarian-Ottoman alliance before both sides joined the Central powers. After watching an Opera at Sofia, he told his Bulgarian officer friend "Now, I know how you defeated us at Balkan Wars. You are West, we are still East."
 
Quote    Reply

macawman    RE:Prequel for Part2 : The leading Troika of OE and Mustafa Kemal   6/19/2004 12:50:08 AM
Interesting thread ilpars. I find it odd that the 2nd language with the business/technical class in Turkey is German, especially since Ataturk was pro British. One thought on the subject could be because of a substantial number of Turks working in Germany. I realize that this German influence could be waning since German immagration laws hve become stricter since the reunification. Your thoughts on the subject..
 
Quote    Reply

ilpars    Business-Technical terms in Turkish language - macawman   6/19/2004 4:03:04 AM
Many technical terms used in Turkish comes from German language. That is largely because the influence of Jewish scientists that escaped from Germany to Turkey in Turkish science between 1930-1960 period. In business most of the imported terms came from English.
 
Quote    Reply
1 2



StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2012StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy