Article Archive: Current 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Special Operations: Commandos In Chains
   Next Article → MURPHY'S LAW: The P-8 Flies, Sort Of
May 1, 2009: Once again, Special Operations troops in Afghanistan have run into problems with ROE (Rules of Engagement). This time around, Czech commandos were recently sent home because their ROE prevented them from doing what commandos do. In at least one case, Czech commandos were held back from an operation because it was considered too dangerous. In other situations, the Czechs opted out of an operation because they believed they did not have sufficient manpower.

This sort of thing influences the use of most foreign troops in Afghanistan. NATO commanders in Afghanistan are not happy with all the strings attached to their authority by politicians back home. The ROE for NATO troops contain over seventy restrictions on how the NATO commander may use troops assigned to him. Most of these have to do with where national contingents can be moved, and how much they can be exposed to danger.

Last year, Germany is pulled its commandos out of Afghanistan. The KSK commandos have been there for most of the last seven years. Many Germans, especially leftist politicians and journalists, have not been happy with that. This has resulted in several unflattering, and largely inaccurate, articles about the KSK in the German media. There was also an investigation of several KSK men, accused of kicking an Afghan prisoner. While the KSK were allowed to fight, they also operated under an increasing number of restrictions. They generally could not fire at the enemy unless first fired upon. This led to at least one senior Taliban leader getting away from the KSK. The fleeing Taliban honcho was not firing at the pursuing KSK, so the commandos could not take him down.

Germany sent 120 KSK commandos to Afghanistan in late 2001. They were not given their own area of operation, but worked with American special forces and commandos as needed. The KSK commandos were the first German troops to engage in combat since 1945 (not counting some communist East German military advisers who may have had to defend themselves in places like Africa. German peacekeepers in the 1990s Balkans did not have to fight.) KSK's achievement was celebrated in late 2001, when a supply of quality German beer was flown in for the troops. This celebration became a scandal, at least according to indignant media reports,  back in Germany.

The KSK were respected by their fellow special operations soldiers, and particularly liked because the Germans were sent beer rations (two cans a day per man). The KSK troops would often share the brew with their fellow commandos, which sometimes resulted in favors in the form of special equipment or intel data. Even with the restrictions, the KSK saw lots of action, but little of it was publicized, lest it generate more criticism back home. But the growing list of restrictions on the KSK led to them becoming useless for commando operations, and they were withdrawn.

There were also Arab commandos in Afghanistan, who eventually got pulled because of a growing list of restrictions, and fear that the presence of these elite troops be widely known. "Moslems fighting Moslems" is a hot button issue in the Islamic world, even though the Arab commandos were eager to go after al Qaeda, and other Arab terrorists known to be operating in Afghanistan.

All this was a major disappointment to the commandos involved. Afghanistan has become something of an Olympics for foreign commandos, a place where they could operate under fire against a dangerous (and thus worthy) foe. Most commandos have trained to deal with Islamic terrorists (especially commandos in Islamic countries) and Afghanistan was an opportunity to do what they have trained so hard for.

Next Article → MURPHY'S LAW: The P-8 Flies, Sort Of

Show Only Poster Name and Title     Newest to Oldest
Bob Cortez       5/1/2009 6:49:06 AM
Frustrated foreign spec ops types might be a great recruiting pool.
Quote    Reply

WarNerd       5/1/2009 3:27:48 PM

Frustrated foreign spec ops types might be a great recruiting pool.

For whom?
Quote    Reply

LB    Pathetic   5/1/2009 4:29:20 PM
It's simply pathetic that so many members of NATO are unwilling to fulfill their obligations.  Being unwilling to have troops engage in combat roles in UN sponsored nation building mission is to abandon any pretext that these nations are willing partner with others.
The US assists to liberate Europe, rebuilds it mostly by itself, leads the effort to defend it for the entire Cold War, has to fly around 85% of the combat sorties over Kosovo, and the one time it asks for a bit of assistance and NATO agrees it turns out most members were not really willing to pay much more than lip service and risk angering the pacifist leftist electorate.  The same pacifist leftist electorate demonstrated against Pershing II and GLCM and was willing to live under the SS-20 umbrella.
The thing is that effort was funded by the KGB and GRU and the Europeans eventually did take the missiles which directly led to INF Treaty.  Now they are asked to do far less and even less willing.  My honest reaction is disgust and loathing at the profound lack of duty and national honor.

Quote    Reply

Nasty German Idiot       5/1/2009 6:27:58 PM
I love how People buy these ridiculous strategypage articles.  Yeah German Commandos did nothing but to drink beer and share it with their Allies :) 
Wow how ignorant can somebody be. 
Quote    Reply

jak267       5/2/2009 5:01:58 PM
The Europeans are a laughing in Obama's face.
Quote    Reply

Photon       5/2/2009 5:20:55 PM
Lesson learned in regards to waging wars nowdays:
Before getting involved, make sure to purge detractors and those sympathetic to your enemies from your turf, before kicking the door.  Basically clean out your home front first.
Quote    Reply