NEW: Follow the Editorial Staff on
StrategyPage Twitter Link


GROUND COMBAT +

AIR COMBAT +

NAVAL OPERATIONS +

SPECIAL OPERATIONS +

HUMAN FACTORS +

SPECIAL WEAPONS +

WARFARE BY THE NUMBERS +

LOGISTICS +

TOOLS +


Visit StrategyPage's US Cavalry Store



Murphy's Law Article Index : Current 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
 Latest
 News
 
 Most
 Read
 
 Most
 Commented
 Hot
 Topics

Indian Nuclear Sub Running On Empty

August 18, 2009: Last month, India launched its first nuclear submarine, the INS Arihant (Destroyer of Enemies). This came after over a decade of planning and construction. But now it's been revealed that the Arihant was launched without its nuclear reactor, which will not be ready for another year, or so. No one is saying for sure when the reactor will be ready. At that point, Arihant will have to go back into dry dock, be torn open, and have the reactor installed. Or parts of it, or just the fuel cores. It's unclear exactly what state the Arihants reactor is in. What is known is that the Arihant cannot move under its own power (as it has none), and apparently is not equipped with weapons. Other major systems may also be missing. So why was the Arihant launched at all? Probably because work on the sub had been going on for more than a decade, and it was becoming embarrassing to have nothing to show for all that effort.

Once the Arihant has a working reactor and weapons systems, it will undergo up to two years of testing and sea trials before being accepted for service. The Arihant is based on the Russian Charlie II sub, which it resembles. A leased Russian Akula II nuclear sub will basically serve as a training boat for India's new nuclear submarine force. Russia retired all its Charlie class subs in the early 1990s. India leased one from 1988-91, and gained a great deal of familiarity with it. The Charlie class had eight launch tubes, outside the pressure hull, for anti-ship missiles. The Arihant has vertical launch tubes, apparently large enough for the cruise missiles, but not any SLBM (Sea Launched Ballistic Missile) India has (like the Sagarika, which is too long to fit in a vertical silo on the Arihant.) Actually, the exact purpose of vertical launch tubes on the Arihant is unclear. The navy revealed very little detail on the new sub (which, until two years ago, the government refused to say anything about.) Access by photographers was restricted.

The new Indian SSN was long referred to as the ATV (Advanced Technology Vessel) class. There are apparently to be five boats in the class, assuming that the first one works well. The ATV is a 5,000 ton boat, and comparisons have also been made to the new Chinese 093 (Shang) class, which is a 6,000 ton boat that entered service two years ago, after more than a decade of construction. That was China's second class of SSNs. The first, the Han class, was a disaster.

India is trying to learn from Chinas mistakes. That's one reason the ATV project has been kept so secret. Another reason for the secrecy was that so much of the ATV project involved developing a compact, light water reactor technology that would fit in a submarine. This 85 MW reactor makes the Arihant underpowered by the standards of other SSNs, and the Indians give the Arihant's top speed as 55 kilometers an hour.

Once the Arihant class SSN is proven, a modified version can be built as a SSBN (ballistic missile carrying sub). This was how everyone else did it, including the Chinese. Get an SSN operational, then modify the design to include some SLBM launch tubes. But the Arihant already appears to have vertical launch tubes, but not of sufficient diameter and length to hold any of the SLBM (sea launched ballistic missiles) in service.

 

 

submit to reddit
Send Link to a Friend
Next Article COUNTER-TERRORISM: Cutting Off What The North Koreans Love Most


Email Me When A New Comment Is Made
Show Only Poster Name and Title     Sort in Reverse Order Posted

maruben    More Info   8/18/2009 10:06:11 AM
India's nuclear submarine named INS Arihant
Posted by on 2009&>4180;7&>6376;16&>6085; (EST)
India's first nuclear powered missile submarine, INS Arihant, will be launched on July 26 at Visakhapatnam by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's wife.
 

INS Chakra, the first nuclear submarine to serve with the Indian Navy, was a Charlie I class attack submarine leased from the Soviet Union. Photo Credit: USDOD
July 16, 2009, (Sawf News) - India's first nuclear powered missile submarine, INS Arihant (destroyer of enemies) will be launched on July 26 at Visakhapatnam by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's wife, reports India Today.
The launch date marks the tenth anniversary of the conclusion of the Kargil War.
The launch will involve floating the submarine in a completely-enclosed dry-dock called the Shipbuilding Centre (SBC) in Visakhapatnam. Later the submarine will be towed out to an enclosed pier for its harbor trials.
The submarine is expected to stay in the enclosed dock possibly for several months as its nuclear power plant is started and tested. It will then cruise into the Bay of Bengal for sea trials.
The ATV reportedly is equipped with 12 launch tubes of 2.4m diameter each. Initially, each missile tube will likely accommodate 3 0.74m diameter K-15 Saagrika missile. Later the tubes could accommodate the 2.0m diameter Agni IIISL (The submarine launched version of the Agni V / Agni 3+) missiles with MIRV capability.
If all goes well, it will take between two to three years for the submarine to be commissioned into the Navy.
L&T is reported to have completed hull sections of two more ATV at its Hazira facility which will be transported to the SBC for assembly after the Arihant vacates dock space.
The submarine is believed to be using 10 meter diameter titanium hull, fabricated in Hazira, covered with rubber acoustic tiles.
The hull diameter matches that of the Charlie II class submarine on which Arihant's design is reportedly based.

INS Arihant: An analysis

 

During the launch of INS Arihant on Sunday, July 26, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh did not mince words while acknowledging Russia's role in the fruition of the challenging project. Photo Credit: PIB

July 26, 2009, (Sawf News) - During the launch of INS Arihant on Sunday, July 26, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh did not mince words while acknowledging Russia's role in the fruition of the challenging project.

"I would also like to express our appreciation to our Russian friends for their consistent and invaluable cooperation, which symbolizes the close strategic partnership that we enjoy with Russia."

India is reported to have acquired design of the Charlie II class nuclear submarines from Russia and the ATV was based on those designs.

The Arihant is 112m long as compared to 103m Charlie class subs, probably because a section was added in the middle to accommodate its missile tube.

Its 10m beam is the same size as a Charlie class sub.

Like the Charlie II subs, Arihant has a single nuclear power plant which gives it a rather limited max underwater speed of 24 kts. Not enough to chase warships or get away from them when it is detected.

Though the Arihant is based on the Charlie II class, it likely incorporates a lot of advancements in propulsion, noise suppression, command and control, communication and sonar that the Russians learnt since they built the Charlie II subs, as well as what the Indians learnt while building the HDW boats.

Unofficial illustrations of the boat show elements of Akula design like the towed sonar at the aft. However, Arihant is unlikely to be based on the Akula II or the more modern Graney class Russian subs, as reported in some sections of the press, since these subs use a twin hull design and are therefore considerably heavier. Not surprisingly the Akula is powered by a 190 MW reactor.

A lot of recent speculation in the press has focused on the nuclear propulsion of the Arihant with many analysts saying that the success of the project depended on its reactor reaching criticality. BARC has an excellent track record and the reactor is likely to have been tested before being fitted. Nuclear subs routinely power up and down. There is good reason to believe that problems with the reactor design have long been sorted out.

Once Arihant's nuclear propulsion is proven the stress will shift to weapon testing.

The Sagarika's limited range of 700km makes it inadequate even as a deterrent against Pakistan, let alone China.

There have been misleading press reports that as a vital component of India's credible minimum deterrent strategy, Arihant is designed to lurk in littoral waters of Pakistan and China to fire its very limited range nuclear missiles in case India comes under a nuclear attack. Nothing could be further from the truth.

It will be years, more likely decades, before the Navy acquires the confidence to send an Arihant class nuclear submarine close to the Chinese or even Pakistani mainland. At the very least the sub would need to repeatedly demonstrate its ability to operate under the sea for months without returning to base.

Arihant's limited underwater speed of 24 kts makes it incapable of running away from modern warships once detected. Nuclear subs tend to be noisy when operating at max speeds, Arihant will in all probability be very noisy.

Acoustic and magnetic signatures are unlikely to be priorities with project managers grappling with their first nuclear submarine project.

As soon as Arihant is deployed on patrol its movement will be tracked by the Americans and possibly by the Chinese.

There isn't a boomer armed with nuclear missiles in the open oceans that isn't being tracked by America. Russian boomers that threaten America are essentially those that are lurking under the ice in the Arctic circle or in Russian coastal areas.

China has operated nuclear submarines for over 25 years now, but none of their submarines have ventured too far away from the Chinese mainland. Their subs are, however, equipped with missiles that can be launched at the US mainland from within Chinese waters.

The acknowledged range of the Sagarika missile, 700 km, is likely its range with a 500 kg warhead. With a lighter nuclear warhead it could conceivably go as far as 1500 km. Deployed in Indian territorial waters the Arihant can threaten Pakistan but not China.

Hopefully, DRDO will be ready with the Agni IIISL within a year or two which will give Indian Strategic Command the option to launch counter value nuclear strikes on mainland China from within Indian waters.

It could well be another 5 years before that capability is reached.

It could probably be a decade before an Arihant nuclear submarine leaves the Indian ocean.

It is likely that followup nuclear subs will accommodate more sections to carry at least 12 launch tubes instead of the four that the sub currently carries. They will need more powerful nuclear power plants to propel their greater weight and achieve speeds in excess of 30 kts.

 
Quote    Reply





New Strategy - Wargames at Discount Prices
1.Modern Air Power: War Over the Middle East
2.Commander: Napoleon at War
3.Close Combat: Watch am Rhein
4.Gallic Wars
5.Fast Action Battle: The Bulge

100+ Computer and Board games all with free shipping.
 
 
 

StrategyWorld.com© 1998 - 2009StrategyWorld.com. All rights Reserved. StrategyWorld.com, StrategyPage.com, FYEO, For Your Eyes Only and Al Nofi's CIC are all trademarks of StrategyWorld.com Privacy Policy